1-1 By: Ellis, et al. S.B. No. 456 1-2 (In the Senate - Filed February 23, 1993; February 24, 1993, 1-3 read first time and referred to Committee on Criminal Justice; 1-4 March 31, 1993, reported adversely, with favorable Committee 1-5 Substitute by the following vote: Yeas 6, Nays 0; March 31, 1993, 1-6 sent to printer.) 1-7 COMMITTEE VOTE 1-8 Yea Nay PNV Absent 1-9 Whitmire x 1-10 Brown x 1-11 Nelson x 1-12 Sibley x 1-13 Sims x 1-14 Turner x 1-15 West x 1-16 COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR S.B. No. 456 By: West 1-17 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED 1-18 AN ACT 1-19 relating to the punishment for certain offenses motivated by hate 1-20 and to the eligibility for deferred adjudication, probation, or 1-21 parole for persons charged with or convicted of those offenses. 1-22 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-23 SECTION 1. Subchapter D, Chapter 12, Penal Code, is amended 1-24 by adding Section 12.48 to read as follows: 1-25 Sec. 12.48. PENALTY FOR HATE CRIME. (a) Except as 1-26 otherwise provided by this subsection, the punishment for an 1-27 offense listed in Subsection (b) of this section is increased to 1-28 the punishment prescribed for the next highest category of offense 1-29 if it is shown at the trial of the offense that the defendant was 1-30 motivated to commit the offense because of the race, color, 1-31 ethnicity, religion, national origin, or sexual orientation of the 1-32 victim. If the offense is murder under Section 19.02 of this code, 1-33 the punishment for the offense is not increased, except that the 1-34 provisions of Section 3h, Article 42.12, and Section 8(b)(4), 1-35 Article 42.18, Code of Criminal Procedure, apply to the defendant. 1-36 (b) This section applies to an offense under the following 1-37 sections of this code: 1-38 (1) Section 19.02 (Murder); 1-39 (2) Section 20.02 (False imprisonment); 1-40 (3) Section 20.03 (Kidnapping); 1-41 (4) Section 22.01 (Assault); 1-42 (5) Section 22.011 (Sexual assault); or 1-43 (6) Section 42.07 (Harassment). 1-44 SECTION 2. Article 42.12, Code of Criminal Procedure, is 1-45 amended by adding Section 3h to read as follows: 1-46 Sec. 3h. HATE CRIMES. (a) Sections 3 and 4 of this article 1-47 do not apply to a person convicted of an offense under Section 1-48 19.02, Penal Code, if there is an affirmative finding at the trial 1-49 of the offense that the defendant committed the offense for a cause 1-50 described by Section 12.48(a), Penal Code. 1-51 (b) Section 5 of this article does not apply to a person 1-52 charged with an offense under Section 19.02, Penal Code, if the 1-53 attorney representing the state notifies the court of the intent of 1-54 the state to prove in any trial of the offense that the defendant 1-55 committed the offense for a cause described by Section 12.48(a), 1-56 Penal Code. 1-57 SECTION 3. Subsection (b), Section 8, Article 42.18, Code of 1-58 Criminal Procedure, is amended to read as follows: 1-59 (b)(1) A prisoner under sentence of death is not eligible 1-60 for parole. 1-61 (2) If a prisoner is serving a life sentence for a 1-62 capital felony, the prisoner is not eligible for release on parole 1-63 until the actual calendar time the prisoner has served, without 1-64 consideration of good conduct time, equals 35 calendar years. 1-65 (3) If a prisoner is serving a sentence for the 1-66 offenses listed in Subdivision (1)(B), (C), or (D) of Section 1-67 3g(a), Article 42.12 of this code, or if the judgment contains an 1-68 affirmative finding under Subdivision (2) of Subsection (a) of 2-1 Section 3g of that article, he is not eligible for release on 2-2 parole until his actual calendar time served, without consideration 2-3 of good conduct time, equals one-fourth of the maximum sentence or 2-4 15 calendar years, whichever is less, but in no event shall he be 2-5 eligible for release on parole in less than two calendar years. 2-6 (4) If a prisoner is serving a sentence for an offense 2-7 under Section 19.02, Penal Code, and the judgment contains an 2-8 affirmative finding that the defendant committed the offense for a 2-9 cause described by Section 12.48(a), Penal Code, he is not eligible 2-10 for release on parole until his actual calendar time served, 2-11 without consideration of good conduct time, equals the maximum 2-12 sentence imposed or 10 years, whichever is less. If a defendant is 2-13 serving a sentence for an offense to which both this subdivision 2-14 and Subdivision (3) of this section apply, Subdivision (3) 2-15 controls. 2-16 (5) Except as provided by Subsection (m) of this 2-17 section, all other prisoners shall be eligible for release on 2-18 parole when their calendar time served plus good conduct time 2-19 equals one-fourth of the maximum sentence imposed or 15 years, 2-20 whichever is less. 2-21 SECTION 4. (a) The change in law made by this Act applies 2-22 only to a defendant charged with or convicted of an offense 2-23 committed on or after the effective date of this Act. For purposes 2-24 of this section, an offense is committed before the effective date 2-25 of this Act if any element of the offense occurs before the 2-26 effective date. 2-27 (b) A defendant charged with or convicted of an offense 2-28 committed before the effective date of this Act is covered by the 2-29 law in effect when the offense was committed, and the former law is 2-30 continued in effect for that purpose. 2-31 SECTION 5. This Act takes effect September 1, 1993. 2-32 SECTION 6. The importance of this legislation and the 2-33 crowded condition of the calendars in both houses create an 2-34 emergency and an imperative public necessity that the 2-35 constitutional rule requiring bills to be read on three several 2-36 days in each house be suspended, and this rule is hereby suspended. 2-37 * * * * * 2-38 Austin, 2-39 Texas 2-40 March 31, 1993 2-41 Hon. Bob Bullock 2-42 President of the Senate 2-43 Sir: 2-44 We, your Committee on Criminal Justice to which was referred S.B. 2-45 No. 456, have had the same under consideration, and I am instructed 2-46 to report it back to the Senate with the recommendation that it do 2-47 not pass, but that the Committee Substitute adopted in lieu thereof 2-48 do pass and be printed. 2-49 Whitmire, 2-50 Chairman 2-51 * * * * * 2-52 WITNESSES 2-53 FOR AGAINST ON 2-54 ___________________________________________________________________ 2-55 Name: Anita Mosely x 2-56 Representing: NAACP 2-57 City: Grand Prairie 2-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2-59 Name: Joan Hill Love x 2-60 Representing: African American Interest 2-61 City: Fort Worth 2-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2-63 FOR AGAINST ON 2-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 2-65 Name: Linda Haynes x 2-66 Representing: Self 2-67 City: Fort Worth 2-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 2-69 Name: Emanuel Haynes x 2-70 Representing: Self 3-1 City: Fort Worth 3-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-3 Name: Carolyn Green x 3-4 Representing: African American Interest 3-5 City: Dallas 3-6 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-7 Name: Rose Giddings x 3-8 Representing: Self 3-9 City: Fort Worth 3-10 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-11 Name: Brenda Giddings x 3-12 Representing: African American Interest 3-13 City: Fort Worth 3-14 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-15 Name: Felicia Eldridge x 3-16 Representing: African American Interest 3-17 City: Fort Worth 3-18 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-19 Name: Rev. Billy Thomas x 3-20 Representing: Self 3-21 City: Fort Worth 3-22 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-23 Name: Frank Wallace x 3-24 Representing: NAACP 3-25 City: Fort Worth 3-26 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-27 Name: Constance Tate x 3-28 Representing: African American Interest 3-29 City: Arlington 3-30 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-31 Name: Rev. J. W. Smith x 3-32 Representing: Self 3-33 City: Fort Worth 3-34 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-35 Name: Roger Smith x 3-36 Representing: African American Summit 3-37 City: Wylie 3-38 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-39 Name: Carl Slater x 3-40 Representing: Zion Baptist Church 3-41 City: Fort Worth 3-42 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-43 Name: Diana Ray x 3-44 Representing: Self 3-45 City: Fort Worth 3-46 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-47 Name: Kay Pouncy x 3-48 Representing: Afro-American Interest 3-49 City: Arlington 3-50 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-51 Name: Rev. Devia Phinisee x 3-52 Representing: African American Interest 3-53 City: Dallas 3-54 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-55 Name: Rev. Isiah Phinisee x 3-56 Representing: African American Interest 3-57 City: Dallas 3-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-59 Name: Catherine Peters x 3-60 Representing: NAACP 3-61 City: Grand Prairie 3-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-63 FOR AGAINST ON 3-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 3-65 Name: Billy Cross x 3-66 Representing: Afr-Amer Interest 3-67 City: Fort Worth 3-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-69 Name: Adrian Drake x 3-70 Representing: Kappa Alpha Psi 4-1 City: Dallas 4-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-3 Name: Frank Johnston x 4-4 Representing: Self 4-5 City: Arlington 4-6 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-7 Name: Phyllis Haynes x 4-8 Representing: Self 4-9 City: Fort Worth 4-10 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-11 Name: Faye Johnston x 4-12 Representing: Fort Worth Summit 4-13 City: Fort Worth 4-14 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-15 Name: John Barlow IV x 4-16 Representing: Sweet Home Missionary Baptist 4-17 City: Fort Worth 4-18 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-19 Name: Donald Taylor x 4-20 Representing: Self 4-21 City: Fort Worth 4-22 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-23 Name: Leona Smith x 4-24 Representing: African American Summit 4-25 City: Fort Worth 4-26 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-27 Name: Eunetha Williams x 4-28 Representing: African American Interest 4-29 City: Fort Worth 4-30 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-31 Name: Judy Webster x 4-32 Representing: African American Summit 4-33 City: Denton 4-34 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-35 Name: Alvin Taylor x 4-36 Representing: Self 4-37 City: Arlington 4-38 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-39 Name: Patricia Armstrong x 4-40 Representing: Self 4-41 City: Fort Worth 4-42 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-43 Name: Phyllis Allen x 4-44 Representing: Self 4-45 City: Fort Worth 4-46 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-47 Name: Kelly Allen x 4-48 Representing: Self 4-49 City: Fort Worth 4-50 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-51 Name: Lacey Sloan x 4-52 Representing: Tx Assn Against Sexual Assault 4-53 City: Austin 4-54 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-55 Name: A.C. Armstead x 4-56 Representing: Self 4-57 City: Fort Worth 4-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-59 Name: Vincent Torres x 4-60 Representing: Self 4-61 City: Austin 4-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-63 FOR AGAINST ON 4-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 4-65 Name: Sabrina Foster x 4-66 Representing: Mayor and City Council 4-67 City: Houston 4-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-69 Name: Joe Paniagua x 4-70 Representing: City of Fort Worth 5-1 City: Fort Worth 5-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-3 Name: Rexene Brauchle x 5-4 Representing: Self 5-5 City: Cleburn 5-6 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-7 Name: Louie Prossen x 5-8 Representing: Self 5-9 City: Fort Worth 5-10 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-11 Name: Margaret Bluett x 5-12 Representing: Afr-Amer Interest 5-13 City: Fort Worth 5-14 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-15 Name: Ella Jones x 5-16 Representing: Sisters of Queens 5-17 City: Arlington 5-18 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-19 Name: Versie A. Henderson x 5-20 Representing: Self 5-21 City: Grand Prairie 5-22 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-23 Name: Gwendolyn A. Charles x 5-24 Representing: Self 5-25 City: Irving 5-26 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-27 Name: Taura De Cluette x 5-28 Representing: Paul Quinn College 5-29 City: Dallas 5-30 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-31 Name: Brian Ford x 5-32 Representing: Paul Quinn College 5-33 City: Dallas 5-34 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-35 Name: Gwenda Barrett x 5-36 Representing: Self 5-37 City: Dallas 5-38 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-39 Name: Bettie Beard x 5-40 Representing: Paul Quinn College 5-41 City: Dallas 5-42 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-43 Name: Hattie Boyd x 5-44 Representing: Self 5-45 City: Fort Worth 5-46 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-47 Name: Ursula Brockman x 5-48 Representing: Sisters of Queens 5-49 City: Fort Worth 5-50 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-51 Name: Patrice Campbell x 5-52 Representing: Self 5-53 City: Fort Worth 5-54 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-55 Name: Sharon Armstrong x 5-56 Representing: Afr-Amer Summit 5-57 City: Fort Worth 5-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-59 Name: Rose Mc Gee x 5-60 Representing: Self 5-61 City: Fort Worth 5-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-63 FOR AGAINST ON 5-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 5-65 Name: Aleah Miles x 5-66 Representing: Self 5-67 City: Fort Worth 5-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-69 Name: Marcellus Mitchell x 5-70 Representing: Paul Quinn College 6-1 City: Dallas 6-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-3 Name: Ola Nicholson x 6-4 Representing: Paul Quinn College 6-5 City: Dallas 6-6 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-7 Name: H. Letrice Parks x 6-8 Representing: Paul Quinn College 6-9 City: Dallas 6-10 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-11 Name: Yudexys Penalver x 6-12 Representing: Self 6-13 City: Fort Worth 6-14 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-15 Name: Angelia Love x 6-16 Representing: Self 6-17 City: Fort Worth 6-18 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-19 Name: Annie Love x 6-20 Representing: Self 6-21 City: Fort Worth 6-22 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-23 Name: Lillian Hendrix x 6-24 Representing: Self 6-25 City: Dallas 6-26 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-27 Name: Sam Hugie x 6-28 Representing: Self 6-29 City: Fort Worth 6-30 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-31 Name: Barbara Jackson x 6-32 Representing: Sisters of Queens 6-33 City: Euless 6-34 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-35 Name: Terrie Reed x 6-36 Representing: Self 6-37 City: Fort Worth 6-38 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-39 Name: Linda Revels x 6-40 Representing: Self 6-41 City: Fort Worth 6-42 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-43 Name: Jackie Robinson x 6-44 Representing: Self 6-45 City: Fort Worth 6-46 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-47 Name: Quincy Taylor x 6-48 Representing: Afr-Amer Summit 6-49 City: Fort Worth 6-50 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-51 Name: Willie Mae Thompson x 6-52 Representing: Self 6-53 City: Fort Worth 6-54 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-55 Name: Lonnie Trim x 6-56 Representing: Self 6-57 City: Fort Worth 6-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-59 Name: Natalie Whitlock x 6-60 Representing: Afr-Amer Summit 6-61 City: Fort Worth 6-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-63 FOR AGAINST ON 6-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 6-65 Name: Charles Williams x 6-66 Representing: Tarrant County Sheriff Dept 6-67 City: Fort Worth 6-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-69 Name: Isaac Williams x 6-70 Representing: Paul Quinn College 7-1 City: Dallas 7-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-3 Name: Herman Love x 7-4 Representing: Self 7-5 City: Fort Worth 7-6 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-7 Name: Ralph Mc Cloud x 7-8 Representing: Self 7-9 City: Fort Worth 7-10 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-11 Name: Charlene Cain x 7-12 Representing: Tx Dept of Public Safety 7-13 City: Austin 7-14 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-15 Name: Yvonne Kennedy x 7-16 Representing: NAACP 7-17 City: Dallas 7-18 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-19 Name: Karia Adams x 7-20 Representing: Self 7-21 City: Fort Worth 7-22 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-23 Name: Eldridge Fisher x 7-24 Representing: NAACP 7-25 City: Dallas 7-26 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-27 Name: Victor Smith x 7-28 Representing: NAACP 7-29 City: Dallas 7-30 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-31 Name: Rev Michael Evans x 7-32 Representing: Bethelehem Baptist Church 7-33 City: Fort Worth 7-34 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-35 Name: Jeanne Robinson x 7-36 Representing: New Roads 7-37 City: Haltom City 7-38 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-39 Name: Knox Fitzpatrick x 7-40 Representing: Dist Atty Dallas County 7-41 City: Dallas 7-42 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-43 Name: Delores Woods x 7-44 Representing: Self 7-45 City: Fort Worth 7-46 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-47 Name: Marian Yates x 7-48 Representing: Self 7-49 City: Grand Prairie 7-50 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-51 Name: Deborah Peoples x 7-52 Representing: Afr-Amer Summit 7-53 City: Fort Worth 7-54 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-55 Name: Eva Holley x 7-56 Representing: Self 7-57 City: Fort Worth 7-58 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-59 Name: George Hopton x 7-60 Representing: Self 7-61 City: Arlington 7-62 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-63 FOR AGAINST ON 7-64 ___________________________________________________________________ 7-65 Name: Belinda Jones x 7-66 Representing: Self 7-67 City: Fort Worth 7-68 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-69 Name: Jessie Jones x 7-70 Representing: Self 8-1 City: Fort Worth 8-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-3 Name: Rose Jones x 8-4 Representing: Nat Assn of Blk Social 8-5 Worker 8-6 City: Arlington 8-7 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-8 Name: Kennedy Jones x 8-9 Representing: Greater Missionary Bap 8-10 Church 8-11 City: Mansfield 8-12 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-13 Name: Rev. Roosevelt Sutton x 8-14 Representing: Baptist Ministers Union 8-15 City: Fort Worth 8-16 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-17 Name: John Posey x 8-18 Representing: Self 8-19 City: Fort Worth 8-20 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-21 Name: W. G. Daniels x 8-22 Representing: SCLC 8-23 City: Fort Worth 8-24 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-25 Name: Rev. Mark Harris x 8-26 Representing: Self 8-27 City: Fort Worth 8-28 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-29 Name: Rhonda Cates x 8-30 Representing: Tx Council on Family 8-31 Violence 8-32 City: Austin 8-33 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-34 Name: Marylin E. Miles x 8-35 Representing: Self 8-36 City: Fort Worth 8-37 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-38 Name: Jackie Robinson x 8-39 Representing: Self 8-40 City: Fort Worth 8-41 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-42 Name: Robert Canady III x 8-43 Representing: Self 8-44 City: Dallas 8-45 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-46 Name: Shannon Noble x 8-47 Representing: Tx Women's Political Caucus 8-48 City: Austin 8-49 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-50 Name: Jeffrey W. Travillion x 8-51 Representing: Austin NAACP 8-52 City: Austin 8-53 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-54 Name: Robert Starr x 8-55 Representing: NAACP 8-56 City: Fort Worth 8-57 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-58 Name: Cleon Richard Jr. x 8-59 Representing: Self 8-60 City: Dallas 8-61 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-62 FOR AGAINST ON 8-63 ___________________________________________________________________ 8-64 Name: Avis Herndon x 8-65 Representing: Fort Worth Education Assn. 8-66 City: Fort Worth 8-67 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-68 Name: Rev. B. L. Smitty Smith x 8-69 Representing: SCLC Fort Worth 8-70 City: Fort Worth 9-1 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-2 Name: Georgia Hughes x 9-3 Representing: 456 Tarrant County 9-4 City: Fort Worth 9-5 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-6 Name: Margaret Green x 9-7 Representing: 456 Tarrant County 9-8 City: Fort Worth 9-9 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-10 Name: Calvin C. Robinson x 9-11 Representing: Self 9-12 City: Fort Worth 9-13 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-14 Name: Eunice Givins x 9-15 Representing: Offenses of Hate Crimes 9-16 City: Forth Worth 9-17 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-18 Name: Renee Higginbotham-Brooks x 9-19 Representing: Self 9-20 City: Forth Worth 9-21 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-22 Name: Rev B. R. Daniels Sr. x 9-23 Representing: Coal of Afr-Amer Ministers 9-24 City: Forth Worth 9-25 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-26 Name: Michael Moore x 9-27 Representing: Self 9-28 City: Forth Worth 9-29 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-30 Name: Sara Fike-James x 9-31 Representing: Fort Worth NAACP 9-32 City: Fort Worth 9-33 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-34 Name: William T. Glenn x 9-35 Representing: Coal of Afr-Amer Ministers 9-36 City: Fort Worth 9-37 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-38 Name: Mary Jane Fike x 9-39 Representing: NAACP 9-40 City: Fort Worth 9-41 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-42 Name: Marcus Fike x 9-43 Representing: NAACP 9-44 City: Fort Worth 9-45 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-46 Name: Katrina Fike x 9-47 Representing: NAACP 9-48 City: Fort Worth 9-49 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-50 Name: Brian Evans x 9-51 Representing: Self 9-52 City: Dallas 9-53 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-54 Name: Delta May Sr. x 9-55 Representing: EFWIMA 9-56 City: Fort Worth 9-57 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-58 Name: Irvin Wilson x 9-59 Representing: Self 9-60 City: Houston 9-61 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-62 FOR AGAINST ON 9-63 ___________________________________________________________________ 9-64 Name: Steven Webb x 9-65 Representing: SCLC Fort Worth 9-66 City: Fort Worth 9-67 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-68 Name: John Boston x 9-69 Representing: TDLA 9-70 City: Austin 10-1 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-2 Name: Robert Kepple x 10-3 Representing: TDCAA 10-4 City: Austin 10-5 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-6 Name: Gary Bledsoe x 10-7 Representing: NAACP 10-8 City: Austin 10-9 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-10 Name: Mark Briskman x 10-11 Representing: Anti Defamation League 10-12 City: Dallas 10-13 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-14 Name: George Steele x 10-15 Representing: Fort Worth Police Dept. 10-16 City: Fort Worth 10-17 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-18 Name: Pamela Daniels x 10-19 Representing: African American Interest 10-20 City: Fort Worth 10-21 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-22 Name: Billy Brown x 10-23 Representing: Fort Worth NAACP 10-24 City: Fort Worth 10-25 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-26 Name: Howard Caver x 10-27 Representing: Coalition of Afro-Amer Minist 10-28 City: Fort Worth 10-29 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-30 Name: Mae Cherry x 10-31 Representing: NAACP 10-32 City: Arlington 10-33 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-34 Name: Joyce E. Crump x 10-35 Representing: African-American Interest 10-36 City: Fort Worth 10-37 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-38 Name: Gerald Britt x 10-39 Representing: Great Dallas Comm of Churches 10-40 City: Dallas 10-41 -------------------------------------------------------------------