BILL ANALYSIS C.S.H.B. 1892 By: Holzheauser (Sims) Finance 5-25-95 Senate Committee Report (Substituted) BACKGROUND Technology holds much of the key to Texas' oil and gas future. New technologies, if developed in Texas, can aid in the recovery of part of the trillions of dollars worth of oil and gas already discovered in Texas. If developed in Texas, these technologies can be marketed to the rest of the world as the world's ability to produce declines. PURPOSE As proposed, C.S.H.B. 1892 provides an exemption from the oil and gas taxes for hydrocarbons produced from wells that use new recovery techniques, and provides civil penalties for false material fact. RULEMAKING AUTHORITY It is the committee's opinion that rulemaking authority is granted to the Railroad Commission of Texas under SECTION 4 (Section 205.008, Tax Code) of this bill. SECTION BY SECTION ANALYSIS SECTION 1. Amends Section 201.053, Tax Code, to delete text providing the tax imposed by Chapter 201 does not apply to gas produced in this state from a well that qualifies under Section 202.056. SECTION 2. Amends Chapter 201B, Tax Code, by adding Section 201.056, as follows: Sec. 201.056. TAX EXEMPTIONS. Provides that the exemptions described by Section 202.056 and Chapters 205 and 206 apply to the taxes imposed by this chapter as authorized by and subject to the certifications and approvals required by those exemption provisions. SECTION 3. Amends Section 202.052(c), Tax Code, to provide that the exemptions described by Section 202.056 and Chapters 205 and 206 apply to oil produced in this state from a well that qualifies under Section 202.056 or Chapter 205 or 206 subject to the certifications and approvals required by those exemption provisions. Deletes the requirement that the rate of tax be reduced to zero. SECTION 4. Amends Subtitle I, Title 2, Tax Code, by adding Chapter 205, as follows: CHAPTER 205. TAX EXEMPTION FOR CATEGORY TWO MARGINAL OIL AND GAS LEASES Sec. 205.001. Defines "barrel," "BOE," "category two marginal lease," "commission," "hydrocarbon," "lease," "lease production," "Mcf," "new well chit," "new well," and "posted price of West Texas intermediate oil." Sec. 205.002. TAX EXEMPTION. Exempts hydrocarbons production from a category two marginal lease (marginal lease) from the taxes imposed by Chapters 201 and 202 if the comptroller has approved the tax exemption under Section 205.006. Sec. 205.003. APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATION. (a) Authorizes the operator of an eligible lease to apply to the Railroad Commission of Texas (commission) for certification of the lease as a marginal lease. (b) Requires the operator to include with the application any relevant information the commission requires. (c) Requires the commission to issue a certificate to the operator. Requires the certificate to contain certain information. (d) Provides that the tax exemption is effective on certain dates. (e) Prohibits the commission from issuing a certificate under this section until the posted price of West Texas intermediate oil (oil) is at or below certain prices. (f) Requires the comptroller to compute the posted daily price of oil for the purposes of Subsection (e). Requires the comptroller to publish, one time, in the Texas Register, the posted price of oil for each of the qualifying 60 consecutive days when the requirements of Subsection (e) are met. Authorizes only the comptroller's computations of the posted daily price to be used to determine when the commission may issue a certification under this section. Sec. 205.004. QUALIFICATION FOR CERTIFICATION. (a) Sets forth the criteria for a lease to be eligible for certification as a marginal lease. (b) Requires the 12-consecutive-month production report period required by Subsection (a) to begin with a month for which some hydrocarbon production is reported to the commission. (c) Provides that a 12-month period is ineligible under Subsection (a) unless during at least seven calendar months of the period some hydrocarbons have been produced and reported to the commission. (d) Provides that production is determined under this section by rounding up to the nearest BOE produced. Sec. 205.005. NEW WELL CHITS. (a) Authorizes the operator of a new well to apply to the commission for new well chits only after five months of production is reported for the well. (b) Requires an operator to apply for new well chits before September 1998. (c) Requires the commission to issue to the operator one new well chit for each BOE capacity from the new well. Requires the operator to notify each person who owns a working interest in a new well of the issuance of new well chits relating to that well and to distribute the appropriate number of chits to each person. Provides that the number of chits each person is entitled to receive is determined by that person's percentaged of ownership interest in the well. (d) Sets forth the BOE capacity for a new oil well on a single-well oil lease or for a new gas well for purposes of issuing new well chits. (e) Sets forth the capacity for a new oil well on a multilevel oil lease. (f) Provides that production from the lease is apportioned between the new well and other producing oil wells on the lease according to the new well BOE capacity test and the sum of the most recent BOE capacity tests for all of the other oil wells on the lease in determining BOE capacity under Subsection (e)(2). (g) Requires a BOE capacity test for a new well to be performed by a certain date on which the operator applies for the new well chits. Requires BOE capacity tests for all other wells to have been performed not earlier than one year before the date on which the operator applies for the new well chits. Requires all BOE capacity tests to be performed in accordance with commission rules. (h) Prohibits the commission from considering hydrocarbons that are vented or flared in determining the BOE capacity of a new well. (i) Authorizes an operator or owner of a working interest to sell or transfer new well chits to another operator or owner or any other person, but only an operator may use a new well chit to qualify a lease for certification as a marginal lease under Section 205.004. Exempts the sale or transfer of new well chits under this subsection from the taxes imposed by Chapter 151, and revenue from that sale or transfer is not included in computing a corporation's new taxable capital or new taxable earned surplus under Chapter 171. Sec. 205.006. APPLICATION FOR AND APPROVAL OF TAX EXEMPTION. (a) Requires the person responsible for paying the tax to apply to the comptroller for the appropriate exemption and include with the application the certificate issued under Section 205.003 by the commission to qualify for the tax exemption provided by this chapter. (b) Authorizes the comptroller to require a person applying for the tax exemption to provide any information necessary to administer this section. (c) Requires the comptroller to approve a person's application if the hydrocarbons are eligible for the tax exemption. (d) Authorizes the comptroller to establish procedures as necessary to comply with this section and Section 205.009. Sec. 205.007. REVOCATION OF CERTIFICATION. (a) Authorizes the commission to revoke a marginal lease certificate if the commission finds that the lease was not eligible for that designation at the time of certification. (b) Requires the commission to notify the operator and the comptroller that the certificate has been revoked. (c) Provides that a tax exemption granted under this chapter is automatically revoked on the date the marginal lease certificate is revoked, and hydrocarbons produced from that lease on or after the day after the date of revocation are not eligible for the tax exemption. Sec. 205.008. COMMISSION DISCRETION AND RULES. Authorizes the commission to adopt and enforce any appropriate rules or orders that the commission finds necessary to administer this chapter. Sec. 205.009. TAX CREDIT. (a) Provides that if the tax is paid at the full rate provided by Chapter 201 or 202 on hydrocarbons produced on or after the effective date of the tax exemption contained in the lease certificate but before the date the comptroller approves the application for the exemption, the operator is entitled to a credit on taxes due in an amount equal to the tax paid during that period. (b) Requires the operator to apply to the comptroller for the credit by the first anniversary of the date the commission certifies the lease as a marginal lease. Sec. 205.010. PENALTIES. (a) Provides that a person is subject to the penalties that may be imposed under Chapters 85 and 91, Natural Resources Code, if the person makes and submits to the commission or the comptroller an application, report, or other document that is used or intended to be used for a certification, tax exemption, or a tax credit under this chapter and the person knows that the application, report, or other document contains a false or untrue material fact. (b) Provides that a person is liable to the state for a civil penalty if the person, after receiving notice from the commission that the person's certificate for a marginal lease has been revoked, applies or attempts to apply for a tax exemption for that lease using the revoked certificate. Prohibits the amount of the penalty from exceeding a certain sum. (c) Authorizes the attorney general to recover a penalty under Subsection (b) in a suit brought on behalf of the state. Provides that venue for the suit is in Travis County. SECTION 5. Amends Title 2I, Tax Code, by adding Chapter 206, as follows: CHAPTER 206. TAX EXEMPTION FOR CERTAIN HYDROCARBONS PRODUCED AS A RESULT OF PRODUCTION ENHANCEMENT PROJECT Sec. 206.001. Defines "commission," "hydrocarbons," "new hydrocarbon recovery technique," "project," and "successful project." Sec. 206.002. TAX EXEMPTION FOR PROJECT AND SUCCESSFUL PROJECT. (a) Exempts hydrocarbons produced from a well that is included in an approved project during the period specified by Section 206.003(d) from the taxes imposed by Chapters 201 and 202 in accordance with Section 206.003(d) if the comptroller has approved the tax exemption under Section 206.006. (b) Exempts hydrocarbons produced from a well in a successful project from the taxes imposed by Chapters 201 and 202 in accordance with Section 206.004(d) and 206.005(c) if the comptroller has approved the tax exemption under Section 206.006. Sec. 206.003. APPLICATION FOR INITIAL PROJECT. (a) Authorizes the operator of one or more wells in a field in which the operator intends to employ a new hydrocarbon technique to apply to the Railroad Commission of Texas (commission) for approval of the project to be eligible for the tax exemption under Section 206.002. (b) Requires the operator to include with the application a statement of the date on which the project begins and the date it will end, subject to commission approval, and any other information the comptroller requires. (c) Requires the commission to issue a certificate to each operator of a well included in the project if the commission approves a project. Requires the certificate to contain certain information. (d) Provides that the tax exemption is effective on the first day the project begins and expires on the 90th day after the date the project ends. (e) Requires the operator to report to the commission the production results from the project by the 90th day after the date on which the projects ends. Sec. 206.004. APPLICATION FOR SUCCESSFUL PROJECT. (a) Authorizes the operator of one or more wells included in a project approved under Section 206.003 to apply to the commission for certification of the project as a successful project under this section if the project is a successful project. (b) Requires the operator to include certain evidence with the application in addition to the other requirements of this chapter. (c) Requires the commission to issue a certificate to each operator of a well that participated in the successful project using the same new hydrocarbon recovery technique (technique). Requires the certificate to contain certain information. (d) Provides that the tax exemption is effective on the first day of the first month after the date on which the commission receives the application for certification of the project as a successful project. Sec. 206.005. APPLICATION FOR ADDITIONAL WELLS. (a) Authorizes an operator of a well located in a field in which a successful project has been certified under Section 206.004 to apply to the commission for certification of the well under this section if the operator uses the same technique approved by the commission for the successful project. (b) Prohibits the commission from issuing a certificate under this section to more than 100 wells in a field, including the original wells certified under Section 206.004, for using the same technique. Requires the commission to determine which wells qualify for certification. Sets forth requirements for the certificate. (c) Provides that the tax exemption is effective on the first day of the first month after the date on which the commission receives the application under this section for certification of the well. Sec. 206.006. APPLICATION FOR AND APPROVAL OF TAX EXEMPTION. (a) Requires the person responsible for paying the tax to apply to the comptroller for the appropriate exemption and include with the application the certificate issued under Section 206.003, 206.004, or 206.005, as appropriate. (b) Authorizes the comptroller to require a person applying for the tax exemption to provide any information necessary to administer this section. (c) Requires the comptroller to approve a person's application if the hydrocarbons are eligible for the tax exemption. Sec. 206.007. REVOCATION OF CERTIFICATION. (a) Authorizes the commission to revoke a certificate if the commission finds that the well was not eligible for that designation at the time of certification. (b) Requires the commission to notify the operator and the comptroller that the certificate has been revoked. (c) Provides that a tax exemption granted under this chapter is automatically revoked on the date the certificate is revoked, and hydrocarbon production from that well on or after the day after the date of revocation is not eligible for the tax exemption. Sec. 206.008. COMMISSION DISCRETION AND RULES. Authorizes the commission to adopt and enforce any appropriate rules or orders that the commission finds necessary to administer this chapter. Sec. 206.009. TAX CREDIT. (a) Provides that if the tax is paid under Chapter 201 or 202 on hydrocarbon production on or after the effective date of the tax exemption contained in the certificate but before the date the comptroller approves the application for the exemption, the operator is entitled to a credit on taxes due in an amount equal to the tax paid on hydrocarbon production during that period. (b) Requires the operator to apply to the comptroller for the credit by the first anniversary of the date the commission certifies the well. Sec. 206.010. PENALTIES. (a) Provides that a person is subject to the penalties that may be imposed under Chapters 85 and 91, Natural Resources Code, if the person makes and submits to the commission or the comptroller an application, report, or other document that is used or intended to be used for a certification, tax exemption, or a tax credit under this chapter and the person knows that the application, report, or other document contains a false or untrue material fact. (b) Provides that a person is liable to the state for a civil penalty if the person, after receiving notice from the commission that the person's certificate has been revoked, applies or attempts to apply for a tax exemption for that well using the revoked certificate. Prohibits the amount of the penalty from exceeding a certain sum. (c) Authorizes the attorney general to recover a penalty under Subsection (b) in a suit brought on behalf of the state. Provides that venue for the suit is in Travis County. SECTION 6. Effective date: September 1, 1995. SECTION 7. Emergency clause.