By Finnell H.C.R. No. 110
74R5960 SKT-D
CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
1-1 WHEREAS, J. E. Isbell, Inc., alleges that:
1-2 (1) on or about September 26, 1988, it entered into a
1-3 five-year grazing lease agreement with the Parks and Wildlife
1-4 Department for use of the Matador Wildlife Management Area located
1-5 in Cottle County, Texas;
1-6 (2) as required by the lease agreement, it submitted to the
1-7 department $2,476.90, representing two percent of its bid, and the
1-8 first year's lease payment of $24,769;
1-9 (3) under the terms of the lease, it was required to pay an
1-10 annual amount to graze a specific number of cattle on the area from
1-11 September 1 to April 30 of each year, except for the first year
1-12 when the grazing period began on October 1, 1988;
1-13 (4) because the first year's grazing started 30 days late,
1-14 it was overcharged on the first annual lease;
1-15 (5) under the terms of the lease, the department was
1-16 required to provide adequate fences, cattle guards, and watering
1-17 facilities on the area and J. E. Isbell, Inc., as lessee, was to
1-18 maintain these fences and watering facilities;
1-19 (6) the department did not provide sufficient fences and
1-20 cattle guards and J. E. Isbell, Inc., spent over $8,000 repairing
1-21 fences in the first year of the lease;
1-22 (7) the watering facilities were also in poor condition and
1-23 J. E. Isbell, Inc., contends that it should not have to replace
1-24 what should have been provided by the department;
2-1 (8) the department has breached the lease by failing to
2-2 fulfill its obligations and has placed the cost and burden of
2-3 upkeep on J. E. Isbell, Inc.;
2-4 (9) J. E. Isbell, Inc., has attempted in good faith to
2-5 fulfill its obligations under the terms of the lease but has found
2-6 it impossible to continue due to the department's negligence of the
2-7 area; and
2-8 (10) it asks for a refund of the $2,476.90 down payment, a
2-9 refund of one month's lease payment for the 1988-89 overcharge,
2-10 $8,000 reimbursement for replacement of fences, lost profits for
2-11 1988-89 resulting from inadequate fences and watering facilities,
2-12 and damages for the loss of expected profits for the remaining four
2-13 years of the lease; now, therefore, be it
2-14 RESOLVED by the Legislature of the State of Texas, That
2-15 J. E. Isbell, Inc., is granted permission to sue the State of Texas
2-16 and the Parks and Wildlife Department subject to Chapter 107, Civil
2-17 Practice and Remedies Code; and, be it further
2-18 RESOLVED, That the executive director of the Parks and
2-19 Wildlife Department be served process as provided by Section
2-20 107.002(a)(3), Civil Practice and Remedies Code.