By: Haywood S.B. No. 1592 97S0731/1 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED AN ACT 1-1 relating to a Red River boundary compact between the States of 1-2 Texas and Oklahoma. 1-3 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-4 SECTION 1. Subchapter B, Chapter 11, Natural Resources Code, 1-5 is amended by adding Sections 11.019, 11.020, and 11.021 to read as 1-6 follows: 1-7 Sec. 11.019. RED RIVER BOUNDARY COMPACT. The Red River 1-8 Boundary Compact shall become effective when approved by the 1-9 legislatures of the State of Texas and the State of Oklahoma and 1-10 enacted into law by and approved by the Congress of the United 1-11 States. 1-12 Sec. 11.020. ORIGINAL COPY. An original copy of the compact 1-13 is on file in the office of the secretary of state. 1-14 Sec. 11.021. TEXT OF COMPACT. The Red River Boundary 1-15 Compact reads as follows: 1-16 PREAMBLE 1-17 The State of Texas and the State of Oklahoma pursuant to the 1-18 acts of their respective governors or legislatures, or both, being 1-19 moved by considerations of interstate comity, have resolved to 1-20 compact with respect to the boundary between the State of Texas and 1-21 the State of Oklahoma along the Red River. 1-22 The States of Texas and Oklahoma acting through their duly 1-23 authorized Commissions, after several years of negotiations, have 2-1 agreed on a historical, equitable and practical boundary and do 2-2 hereby submit and recommend that this Compact be adopted by the 2-3 respective legislatures and approved by the Congress of the United 2-4 States as hereinafter set forth: 2-5 ARTICLE I. PURPOSE 2-6 (a) The States of Oklahoma and Texas recognize that there 2-7 are actual and potential disputes, controversies, criminal 2-8 proceedings and litigation arising, or which may arise, out of the 2-9 location of the boundary line between the states along the Red 2-10 River. 2-11 (b) The party states recognize that the south bank of the 2-12 Red River is the boundary between the states along the Red River. 2-13 (c) The party states recognize the boundary between the 2-14 states changes as a result of the natural action of the river and 2-15 that, because of such changes and the nature of the land, the south 2-16 bank of the river is often not readily or easily identified. 2-17 (d) The party states further recognize that while the south 2-18 bank, at any given time, may be located through expensive and 2-19 time-consuming survey techniques, such surveys can, at best, only 2-20 identify the south bank as it exists at the time of the survey. 2-21 (e) Additionally, the party states recognize that the 2-22 location of the south bank through survey techniques is of minimal 2-23 aid to law enforcement and administrative agencies of the party 2-24 states when, for law enforcement, administrative and taxation 2-25 purposes, they must locate the state boundary line. The interest of 3-1 both party states is thus better served by establishing the 3-2 boundary between the states along the south bank of the Red River 3-3 through use of a readily indentifiable natural landmark, rather 3-4 than through use of an artificial survey line. 3-5 (f) It is the principal purpose of the party states in 3-6 executing this Compact to establish an identifiable boundary 3-7 between the State of Texas and the State of Oklahoma along the Red 3-8 River as of the effective date of this Compact without interfering 3-9 with or otherwise affecting private property rights or title to 3-10 property, and the party states declare that further compelling 3-11 purposes of the Compact are (1) creation of a friendly and 3-12 harmonious interstate relationship; (2) avoidance of multiple 3-13 exercise of sovereignty and jurisdiction, including matters of 3-14 taxation, judicial and police powers, and exercise of 3-15 administrative authority; (3) avoidance of lack of exercise of 3-16 sovereignty and jurisdiction over any lands along the boundary; (4) 3-17 avoidance of questions of venue in civil and criminal proceedings 3-18 which may arise as a result of incidents along the boundary and 3-19 avoid or minimize the future disputes and litigation; (5) promotion 3-20 of economic and political stability; and (6) placement of the 3-21 boundary at a location which can be visually identified or located 3-22 without the necessity of a current survey and which is close to the 3-23 historical boundary location. 3-24 ARTICLE II. ESTABLISHMENT OF BOUNDARY 3-25 (a) The permanent political boundary line between the States 4-1 of Texas and Oklahoma along the Red River shall be fixed at the 4-2 vegetation line along the south bank of the Red River as defined in 4-3 Section (b) of this Article, except for the boundary within the bed 4-4 of Lake Texoma (below the elevation of 645 feet), where the 4-5 boundary shall be the south bank of the Red River as determined at 4-6 the time of construction of the Denison Dam. 4-7 (b) As used in this Compact, the term "vegetation line" is 4-8 defined as follows: 4-9 The vegetation line is the uniform line of vegetation that is 4-10 adjacent to that portion of the river bed that is kept practically 4-11 bare of vegetation by the natural flow of the river. The 4-12 vegetation line is the visually identified consistent concentration 4-13 of vegetation that is continuous with the vegetation beyond the 4-14 river bed. The vegetation line may consist of trees, shrubs, 4-15 grasses, or other vegetation, but shall not include stray 4-16 vegetation, patches of vegetation or islands of vegetation within 4-17 the river bed that do not form a uniform line. Where the river bed 4-18 is entered by the inflow of other watercourses the vegetation line 4-19 shall be a uniform line connecting the uniform line of vegetation 4-20 above and below the inflow of the other watercourse. If the 4-21 vegetation line is indiscernible due to man-made events, the 4-22 vegetation line shall be a uniform line connecting the uniform line 4-23 of vegetation above and below the indiscernible area. 4-24 (c) The vegetation line, as defined, shall by virtue of this 4-25 Compact constitute the legal boundary between the party states and 5-1 remain the boundary as it changes and moves due to the flow of the 5-2 river, whether changed by accretion, avulsion or erosion. 5-3 (d) Should there be a change in the watercourse of the Red 5-4 River, the States of Texas and Oklahoma shall recognize the rules 5-5 of accretion, erosion and avulsion. Both states agree that 5-6 accretion or erosion may cause a change in the boundary between the 5-7 states. With regard to avulsion, both states agree that a change 5-8 in the course of the Red River caused by an immediately perceivable 5-9 natural event which changes the vegetation line will change the 5-10 location of the boundary between the states. 5-11 ARTICLE III. SOVEREIGNTY 5-12 On the effective date of this Compact, the party states agree 5-13 that, along the Red River, bounded on the west at approximately the 5-14 100th Meridian and bounded on the east at approximately the 94th 5-15 Meridian, the State of Oklahoma shall possess sovereignty over all 5-16 lands north of the vegetation line along the south bank of the Red 5-17 River, and the State of Texas shall possess sovereignty over all 5-18 lands south of the vegetation line along the south bank of the Red 5-19 River, provided, however, nothing herein is intended to change or 5-20 affect in any manner the sovereignty of rights of federally 5-21 recognized Indian tribes over lands on either side of the boundary 5-22 line established in this Compact, which rights shall continue to be 5-23 established and defined by controlling federal law. 5-24 ARTICLE IV. PENDING LITIGATION 5-25 Nothing in this Compact is intended to affect the 6-1 jurisdiction of any litigation concerning the title to any of the 6-2 lands bordering the Red River pending in the courts of either of 6-3 the party states or the United States as of the effective date of 6-4 this Compact. Such litigation, if any, shall continue in the trial 6-5 and appellate courts of the jurisdiction where pending until the 6-6 final determination thereof. 6-7 ARTICLE V. PUBLIC RECORDS 6-8 (a) All public records in either state concerning any lands, 6-9 the sovereignty over which is changed by virtue of this Compact, 6-10 shall be accepted as evidence of record title to such lands, to and 6-11 including the effective date of this Compact, by the courts of the 6-12 other state and the federal courts. 6-13 (b) As to lands the sovereignty over which is changed by 6-14 virtue of this Compact, the recording officials of the counties of 6-15 each state shall accept for filing certified copies of documents of 6-16 title previously filed in the other state. The acceptance of such 6-17 documents for filing shall have no bearing upon the legal effect or 6-18 sufficiency thereof, the same being determined by the documents 6-19 themselves and the real estate laws of the jurisdiction in which 6-20 the land was located at the time such instrument was executed or 6-21 effective. The recording officials of the counties of each state 6-22 shall accept for filing documents of title relating to lands the 6-23 sovereignty over which is changed by virtue of this Compact using 6-24 legal descriptions derived from the land descriptions of the other 6-25 state. The acceptance of such documents for filing shall have no 7-1 bearing upon the legal effect or sufficiency thereof. 7-2 ARTICLE VI. TAXES 7-3 (a) Taxes for the year of adoption of this Compact lawfully 7-4 imposed by either Texas or Oklahoma may be levied and collected on 7-5 property by such state or its authorized governmental subdivisions 7-6 and agencies on property, the jurisdiction over which is changed by 7-7 virtue of this Compact, and any liens or other rights accrued or 7-8 accruing, including the right of collection, shall be fully 7-9 recognized; provided, that all liens or other rights arising out of 7-10 the imposition of such taxes must be claimed or asserted within 7-11 five years after this Compact becomes effective and if not so 7-12 claimed or asserted shall be forever barred. 7-13 (b) Except as provided in Sections (a) and (d) of this 7-14 Article, the lands, sovereignty over which is changed by virtue of 7-15 this Compact, shall, after the effective date of this Compact, only 7-16 be subject to taxation by the state gaining sovereignty over the 7-17 land by virtue of this Compact. 7-18 (c) All taxes currently assessed by governmental entities in 7-19 each state as to lands which border and/or cross the boundary line 7-20 established by this Compact shall be presumed to be correct as to 7-21 acreage within the particular jurisdiction absent competent proof 7-22 to the contrary being presented in writing by the property owner or 7-23 owners to the appropriate taxing agencies. All such proof shall be 7-24 presented to the appropriate tax agencies prior to May 1 of the 7-25 year following the year in which this Compact becomes effective. 8-1 In subsequent years it shall be presumed that the acreage taxed in 8-2 each jurisdiction for the previous year was correct unless evidence 8-3 of change is furnished to or obtained by the various taxing 8-4 jurisdictions under rules and regulations as may be adopted by said 8-5 taxing authorities. 8-6 (d) The states recognize that the boundary between the 8-7 states will change from time to time as a result of the natural 8-8 actions of accretion, erosion, and/or avulsion and agree that for 8-9 subsequent years the state within which lands adjoining the 8-10 boundary line are located on January 1 of each year shall have the 8-11 right to impose and collect taxes for the entire ensuing year. 8-12 ARTICLE VII. PRIVATE RIGHTS 8-13 Nothing contained in the provisions of this Compact, or any 8-14 operation thereof, is intended to change the title of any person, 8-15 public or private, natural or artificial, to any of the lands 8-16 herein involved, whether such title to the lands arise or exist 8-17 upon the basis that the lands affected by the designation of 8-18 boundary as set forth in this Compact were previously a part of the 8-19 State of Texas and have now become a part of the State of Oklahoma, 8-20 or were previously a part of the State of Oklahoma and have now 8-21 become a part of the State of Texas, or otherwise. 8-22 ARTICLE VIII. EFFECTIVE DATE 8-23 This Compact shall become effective when approved by the 8-24 legislatures of the State of Texas and the State of Oklahoma and 8-25 enacted into law by and approved by the Congress of the United 9-1 States. 9-2 ARTICLE IX. ENFORCEMENT 9-3 (a) Nothing in this Compact shall be construed to limit or 9-4 prevent either party state from instituting or maintaining any 9-5 action or proceeding, legal or equitable, in any court having 9-6 jurisdiction, for the protection of any right under this Compact or 9-7 the enforcement of any of its provisions. 9-8 (b) This Compact is not binding or obligatory upon either 9-9 party state unless and until it has been enacted by each state and 9-10 approved by the Congress of the United States. Notice of enactment 9-11 of this Compact by Texas and Oklahoma shall be given by the 9-12 governor thereof to the governor of the other state and to the 9-13 President of the United States. The President is hereby requested 9-14 to give notice to the governors of Texas and Oklahoma of the 9-15 consent to this Compact by the Congress of the United States. 9-16 ARTICLE X. AMENDMENTS 9-17 This Compact shall remain in full force and effect unless 9-18 amended in the same manner as that by which it was created. 9-19 ARTICLE XI. FEDERAL SURFACE LANDS 9-20 In order to return use and control of certain lands currently 9-21 owned by the United States Government to private ownership, the 9-22 States of Texas and Oklahoma request the Congress to direct the 9-23 Bureau of Land Management to sell, by sealed bid under the Color of 9-24 Title Act (43 U.S.C. Section 1068 et seq.), the surface estate of 9-25 all federal land located between the 98th Meridian and the mouth of 10-1 the North Fork of the Red River to adjacent, riparian landowners. 10-2 The States of Texas and Oklahoma further request Congress to direct 10-3 the Bureau of Land Management to retain ownership of the minerals 10-4 and continue management of the mineral estate in such lands on 10-5 behalf of the Kiowa, Comanche and Apache Tribes as provided by law. 10-6 SECTION 2. This Act takes effect when approved by the 10-7 legislatures of the State of Texas and the State of Oklahoma and 10-8 enacted into law by and approved by the Congress of the United 10-9 States. 10-10 SECTION 3. The importance of this legislation and the 10-11 crowded condition of the calendars in both houses create an 10-12 emergency and an imperative public necessity that the 10-13 constitutional rule requiring bills to be read on three several 10-14 days in each house be suspended, and this rule is hereby suspended.