By: Barrientos S.B. No. 1730 97S0588/1 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED AN ACT 1-1 relating to due process for certain educational support personnel. 1-2 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-3 SECTION 1. Chapter 22, Education Code, is amended by adding 1-4 Subchapter D to read as follows: 1-5 SUBCHAPTER D. EDUCATIONAL SUPPORT PERSONNEL 1-6 Sec. 22.101. DEFINITIONS. In this subchapter: 1-7 (1) "Board" or "board of trustees" means the governing 1-8 board of a public school district. 1-9 (2) "Educational support employee" or "employee" means 1-10 an employee of a school district who does not fall within the 1-11 definition of "teacher" in Section 21.201. The terms include but 1-12 are not limited to bus drivers, custodians, food service employees, 1-13 maintenance employees, security personnel, educational aides, 1-14 educational secretaries, and paraprofessionals. 1-15 (3) "School district" or "district" means any public 1-16 school district in this state. 1-17 (4) "Party" or "parties" means the administration of a 1-18 school district and an educational support employee. 1-19 Sec. 22.102. EVALUATIONS. The board of trustees of each 1-20 school district shall provide, by written board policy, for the 1-21 periodic written evaluation of the performance of each educational 1-22 support employee in its employ at annual or more frequent 1-23 intervals. 2-1 Sec. 22.103. RECOMMENDATION. Before the employment of any 2-2 educational support employee may be terminated, the superintendent 2-3 shall recommend such action in writing to the board of trustees. 2-4 Sec. 22.104. NOTICE. (a) In the event the board receives a 2-5 recommendation from the superintendent for the termination of the 2-6 employment of an educational support employee, the board, after 2-7 consideration of the written evaluation required by Section 21.502 2-8 and the reasons for the recommendation, shall, in its sole 2-9 discretion, either reject the recommendation or give the employee 2-10 written notice of the proposed termination. 2-11 (b) The notice of proposed termination shall contain a 2-12 statement of all the reasons for such action, including all 2-13 relevant dates and conduct of the employee. 2-14 Sec. 22.105. REQUEST FOR HEARING. If the employee desires 2-15 to protest the proposed termination, the employee must notify the 2-16 superintendent or board of trustees and the commissioner in writing 2-17 not later than the 15th day after the date the employee receives 2-18 the notice under Section 21.504. 2-19 Sec. 22.106. HEARING. (a) If the employee requests a 2-20 hearing under Section 21.505, the board shall hold a hearing and 2-21 render a decision not earlier than 30 days and not later than 75 2-22 days after receiving the employee's request for a hearing, unless 2-23 otherwise agreed by the parties. At the board's discretion, a 2-24 panel composed of three members of the board, in lieu of the full 2-25 board, may hold the hearing and render the board's decision. Once 3-1 the decision to use a three-member panel has been made, the full 3-2 board may not take the case away from the panel without the 3-3 employee's permission. A panel under this section shall be 3-4 composed of two board members selected by the employee and one 3-5 board member selected by the board. 3-6 (b) At the hearing, the administration has the burden of 3-7 proof to prove good cause for termination by a preponderance of the 3-8 evidence and shall present its case first. The employee may 3-9 present a rebuttal case. The administration and the employee may 3-10 examine and cross-examine witnesses and introduce other relevant 3-11 evidence. 3-12 (c) The hearing shall be moderated by a hearing examiner 3-13 appointed by the commissioner, who shall be assigned from the same 3-14 list of hearing examiners and in the same manner as the 3-15 commissioner assigns hearing examiners under Section 21.254. The 3-16 role of the hearing examiner is to schedule and recess the hearing, 3-17 with input from the parties and board; issue subpoenas, on a 3-18 showing of good cause by either party, for the attendance of 3-19 witnesses; administer oaths; rule on motions; rule on the 3-20 admissibility of evidence using the Texas Rules of Civil Evidence; 3-21 and maintain decorum. The hearing examiner may extend the 75-day 3-22 period provided in Subsection (a) for not more than 45 days on a 3-23 showing of good cause by either party. 3-24 (d) Without request, the administration shall provide the 3-25 employee with copies of every document and every item of physical 4-1 evidence the administration will use in its case at least 20 days 4-2 before the hearing. The employee may reasonably request other 4-3 relevant documents and the administration shall respond within 10 4-4 days. Without request, the administration shall provide the 4-5 employee with a list of witnesses the administration plans to call 4-6 in its case, together with a summary of their anticipated 4-7 testimony, at least 20 days before the hearing. Unless the parties 4-8 agree otherwise, neither party may take depositions or use other 4-9 means of discovery. 4-10 (e) The hearing shall be conducted in the same manner as a 4-11 trial in a district court of this state. A certified court 4-12 reporter must record the proceedings. The school district shall 4-13 bear the expense of the hearing examiner and court reporter. 4-14 (f) The parties may agree at any time to use a hearing 4-15 examiner of their choice, but the person must be a licensed 4-16 attorney in this state or a law professor at any school of law 4-17 accredited by the State Bar of Texas. 4-18 (g) The board or panel may not discuss or deliberate the 4-19 case until the evidence is closed. The employee may allow the 4-20 board to discuss and deliberate the case privately. The board or 4-21 panel must make a decision on the record within the period set 4-22 forth in this section. 4-23 Sec. 22.107. APPEALS. (a) The employee may appeal the 4-24 decision of the board to the commissioner, who shall render a de 4-25 novo decision based on the record of the proceedings before the 5-1 board or panel. The commissioner shall not take any new evidence 5-2 unless procedural irregularities that are not reflected in the 5-3 local record occurred at the hearing before the board or panel. The 5-4 appeal must be filed with the commissioner not later than 45 days 5-5 after the board or panel announces its decision on the record. The 5-6 school district must file its answer and the record of the local 5-7 proceedings with the commissioner not later than 30 days after the 5-8 district has been notified in writing of the appeal. 5-9 (b) The commissioner must render a written decision within 5-10 90 days after receiving the appeal. 5-11 (c) The employee may appeal the commissioner's decision in 5-12 the district court in the county in which the school district is 5-13 located or in Travis County by agreement of the parties. An appeal 5-14 must be filed not later than the 30th day after the employee 5-15 receives the commissioner's decision. The commissioner shall be 5-16 responsible for filing the record with the district court. 5-17 SECTION 2. This Act takes effect September 1, 1997. 5-18 SECTION 3. The importance of this legislation and the 5-19 crowded condition of the calendars in both houses create an 5-20 emergency and an imperative public necessity that the 5-21 constitutional rule requiring bills to be read on three several 5-22 days in each house be suspended, and this rule is hereby suspended.