MINUTES 
          
                     SENATE INTERIM COMMITTEE ON HOME HEALTH 
                         AND ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES 
                            Tuesday, December 2, 1997 
                                     9:30 am 
                         Capitol Extension, Room E1.036 
          
                                      ***** 
          
         Pursuant to a notice posted in accordance with Senate Rule  
         11.11, a public hearing of the Senate Interim Committee on  
         Home Health and Assisted Living Facilities was held on  
         Tuesday, December 2, 1997 in the Capitol Extension, Room  
         E1.036, at Austin, Texas.   
          
                                      ***** 
          
         MEMBERS PRESENT:                        MEMBERS ABSENT: 
         Senator Mike Moncrief                   Senator Mario  
         Gallegos, Jr. 
         Senator Gonzalo Barrientos              Senator Drew Nixon 
         Senator Jane Nelson                      
                                                  
                                      ***** 
          
         The Chair called the meeting to order at 9:35 am.  Senator  
         Nelson was also present at the opening of the meeting.    
          
         The Chair made opening remarks, welcomed invited speakers,  
         state agency staff and the public.  The Chair announced that  
         the purpose of the hearing was to receive public testimony  
         from providers, advocates and families and their  
         recommendations and directions for the Committee.  
          
         The Chair called Michael Crowe, Committee Director, to brief  
         Committee Members on the status of the lawsuit filed in  
         Galveston County by home health providers alleging racial  
         discrimination against several parties, including the state  
         and to respond to questions from the Committee Members.  
          
         Michael Crowe also briefed the Committee Members on the recent  
         changes in federal law that impact home health.  The Chair  
         thanked and dismissed the witness. 
          
         The following members arrived after the roll was called: 
         Senator Gonzalo Barrientos 
          
         There being a quorum present, Senator Nelson  moved that the  
         reading of the minutes of the last hearing be dispensed with  
         and approved by unanimous consent.  There being no objection,  
         the minutes were approved.  
         The Chair then called a panel to testify about the Committee's  
  
         charges regarding the State's 
         Regulatory Framework for Home Health Care and Rehabilitation  
         Services Industries.  The panel members were: 
          
              Anita Bradberry, Executive Director, Texas Association  
         for Home Care. Inc. 
              Mark Gentle, Attorney, American Association of Retired  
         Persons 
              Jonas Schwartz, Representative, Disability Policy  
         Consortium 
          
         The following persons were called by the Chair to respond to  
         questions from Committee Members about home health care in  
         Texas: 
          
              Ron P. Mansolo, Associate Commissioner, Texas Department  
         of Health 
              Heather Vasek, Texas Association for Home Care 
              Dr. William R. Archer, Commissioner, Texas Department of  
         Health 
              Nance Stearman, Director of Health Facility Compliance  
         Division, Texas Department of 
                   Health 
              Julia Beechinor, Texas Department of Health 
          
         The panel testified and responded to questions from Members of  
         the Committee.  The Chair thanked and dismissed the panel. 
          
         The Chair then called a panel to testify about the State's  
         Regulatory Framework for Personal Care 
         Homes and Assisted Living Facilities.  The panel members were: 
          
              Diana Deaton, Executive Director, Texas Assisted Living  
         Association 
              Wilhelmina Gladden, Chair, State Legislative Committee,  
         American Association of Retired 
                   Persons 
              Aaryce Hayes, Representative, Disability Policy  
         Consortium 
              C. W. Mathews, Executive Director, Texas Organization of  
         Residential Care Homes 
          
         The following persons were called by the Chair to respond to  
         questions from Committee Members 
         about personal care homes and assisted living facilities: 
              Marc Gold, Manager, Long Term Care Policy, Texas  
         Department of Human Services 
              Jim Lehrman, Texas Department of Human Services 
          
         The Chair recessed at 12:00 Noon.  
          
         The Chair reconvened the hearing at 12:48 P. M. and recalled  
         the panel to discuss the Committee charges regarding the  
         State's Regulatory Framework for Personal Care Homes and  
         Assisted Living Facilities. 
          
         The Chair called the following persons to respond to questions  
         from Committee Members 
         about personal care homes and assisted living facilities: 
               
              Jim Boyce, Technical Planner, Architectural Barriers,  
         Texas Department of Licensing and       Regulation 
              Rachelle Martin, Director, Code Review and Inspections,  
         Texas Department of Licensing 
                   and Regulation 
          
         The panel testified and responded to questions from Members of  
         the Committee.  The Chair thanked and dismissed the panel. 
          
         The Chair introduced and welcomed Representative Elliott  
         Naishtat as a guest from District 49,  
         Austin, Texas. 
          
         The Chair then called for public testimony.  The following  
         persons provided oral testimony: 
          
              Ms. Johnnie Benson, Colonial Southwest Inc., Fort Worth,  
         Texas 
              Beth Knox, Long Term Care Administration Program,  
         Southwest Texas State University, San 
                   Marcos, Texas 
              Sheree Gipson Jarrell, Texas Occupational Therapy  
         Association, Malakoff, Texas 
              Gary L. Bledsoe, Attorney, Black Owned Home Health  
         Agencies, Austin, Texas 
              Mary Veazie, Affiliated Professional Home Health Care,  
         Houston, Texas 
              Marian Upchurch, Long Term Care Administration Program,  
         Southwest Texas State  
                   University, San Marcos, Texas 
              Darlene Daugherty, Gateway Villa and Texas Health Care  
         Association, Marble Falls, 
                   Texas 
              Marie B. Wisdom, Advocates for Nursing Home Reform,  
         Austin, Texas 
              Carrie Hamilton, Affiliated Professional Home Health,  
         Houston, Texas 
              Ramon B. Carter, Medica-Rents Company, Fort Worth, Texas 
              Phil Cates, Medical Resources, Inc., Austin, Texas 
              Steven A. Wadsworth, Centratex Support Services, Brady,  
         Texas 
          
              Bob Rice, Centratex Support Services, Brady, Texas 
              Mauro Hernandez, Assisted Living Concepts, Inc., Dallas,  
         Texas 
  
              Dr. D. G. Edwards, Greater Dallas Home Health Alliance,  
         Duncanville, Texas 
              Ja'Net A. Nash-Dotson, Dallas Home Health Alliance,  
         Dallas, Texas 
              Dr. Lewis Parker, Jr., South Galveston County Pachyderm  
         Club, Texas City, Texas 
              Lauralee Harris, Texas Mental Health and Aging Coalition,  
         Fort Worth, Texas 
              Laura K. Brown, Coalition of Texans with Disabilities  
         Task Force, Austin, Texas 
              Jacqueline Johnson, Assistant Commissioner, Long Term  
         Care Services, Texas Department         Human Services,  
         Austin, Texas 
              Dr. Jennifer M. Cernoch, Texas Respite Resource Network,  
         San Antonio, Texas 
              Belinda Carlton, Coalition of Texans with Disabilities,  
         Austin, Texas 
              David Wittie, American Disabled for Attendant Programs  
         Today, Austin, Texas 
              Rona Schnall, American Disabled for Attendant Programs  
         Today, Austin, Texas 
              Mario A. Espinosa, Vital Health Care, Inc., Edinburg,  
         Texas 
              Daniel Szeremet, Vital Health Care, Inc., Edinburg, Texas 
               
         The following persons registered, but did not testify:  
          
              Inez Williams, Maximum Care Home Health Agency, Inc.,  
         Dallas, Texas 
              Deborah Lollar, Nursefinders and Home Health Services and  
         Staffing Association, 
                   Arlington, Texas 
              Olga Swan, EK'SELENCE, Garland, Texas 
              Sharon E. Thompson, Texas Health and Human Services  
         Commission, Austin, Texas 
          
         The following persons submitted written materials: 
          
              Ellen Evans, Home Health Services and Staffing  
         Association, Alexandria, Virginia 
              Elaine Nail, Lubbock, Texas 
              The Honorable Senfronia Thompson, Texas House of  
         Representatives, Austin, Texas 
          
         There being no further business, at 6:16 P. M., Senator  
         Moncrief recessed the Committee 
         subject to the call of the Chair.  Without objection, it was  
         so ordered. 
          
         ______________________ 
         Senator Mike Moncrief, Chair 
  
         ______________________ 
         Judy Daugherty, Clerk