By Garcia H.B. No. 171 76R1296 KKA-F A BILL TO BE ENTITLED 1-1 AN ACT 1-2 relating to a school district's liability to the parent of a 1-3 student who fails to perform satisfactorily on certain assessment 1-4 instruments. 1-5 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-6 SECTION 1. Chapter 39, Education Code, is amended by adding 1-7 Subchapter I to read as follows: 1-8 SUBCHAPTER I. PRIVATE REMEDY 1-9 Sec. 39.201. DEFINITION. In this subchapter, "parent" 1-10 includes a person standing in parental relation. 1-11 Sec. 39.202. CLAIM AUTHORIZED. A parent may bring a claim 1-12 against a school district under this subchapter if the parent's 1-13 child: 1-14 (1) has been enrolled in the district for at least 1-15 three consecutive school years; and 1-16 (2) while enrolled in the district, has failed to 1-17 perform satisfactorily during three different school years on one 1-18 or more assessment instruments administered by the district under 1-19 Section 39.023(a) or (c). 1-20 Sec. 39.203. DEFENSES. It is a defense to a claim brought 1-21 under this subchapter that: 1-22 (1) the child did not receive the ordinary amount of 1-23 classroom instruction in the school district because the child was 1-24 absent or tardy an excessive number of times; 2-1 (2) the child or the child's parent refused remedial 2-2 actions recommended by the school district, such as reassignment, 2-3 summer school attendance, tutoring, counseling, or repeated grade 2-4 levels or classes; 2-5 (3) the child has a recognized mental or physical 2-6 impediment that precluded satisfactory performance on the 2-7 assessment instruments; 2-8 (4) the child has been suspended, expelled, or 2-9 assigned to an alternative education program or juvenile justice 2-10 alternative education program by the school district; 2-11 (5) the child has been finally determined to have 2-12 committed an offense involving moral turpitude; or 2-13 (6) the proximate cause of the child's failure to 2-14 perform satisfactorily was a factor in the private affairs of the 2-15 child or the child's family beyond the control of the school 2-16 district. 2-17 Sec. 39.204. INITIATION OF CLAIM; LIMITATIONS. (a) To 2-18 initiate a claim under this subchapter a parent must file notice of 2-19 the claim with the school district. A school district that opposes 2-20 a claim must submit the claim to the State Office of Administrative 2-21 Hearings not later than the 30th day after the date the district 2-22 receives notice of the claim. 2-23 (b) A parent must file a claim under this subchapter not 2-24 later than the first anniversary of the last day of instruction in 2-25 the third school year in which the parent's child failed to perform 2-26 satisfactorily on an assessment instrument specified under Section 2-27 39.202. 3-1 Sec. 39.205. ADMINISTRATIVE DETERMINATION OF CLAIM. (a) An 3-2 administrative law judge shall decide the claim in accordance with 3-3 this subchapter and rules adopted by the chief administrative law 3-4 judge of the State Office of Administrative Hearings. The 3-5 administrative law judge shall hear the claim as a contested case 3-6 under Chapter 2001, Government Code. 3-7 (b) If the administrative law judge finds, by a 3-8 preponderance of the evidence, that the claim is valid, the judge 3-9 shall order the school district to pay an award in accordance with 3-10 Section 39.206. 3-11 (c) The parent shall pay the cost of a proceeding conducted 3-12 under this subchapter. The parent is entitled to recover the cost 3-13 from the school district in accordance with Section 39.206 if the 3-14 parent prevails in the proceeding. 3-15 Sec. 39.206. AMOUNT OF AWARD; PAYMENT. (a) A parent who 3-16 prevails in a proceeding brought under this subchapter is entitled 3-17 to recover from the school district: 3-18 (1) a voucher that: 3-19 (A) is in an amount equal to the sum of: 3-20 (i) three times the quotient resulting 3-21 from dividing the school district's gross budget for the school 3-22 year in which the child's third failure occurred by the number of 3-23 students enrolled in the school district that year; and 3-24 (ii) interest on the amount specified in 3-25 Paragraph (A)(i) accruing between the date the administrative law 3-26 judge determines that the parent's claim is valid and the date the 3-27 judge's decision becomes final at the rate specified by Section 4-1 304.003, Finance Code; 4-2 (B) may be used only in paying for educational 4-3 services for the parent's child; and 4-4 (C) may be redeemed by a private or public 4-5 entity chosen by the child's parent to provide educational 4-6 services; 4-7 (2) costs of the proceeding; and 4-8 (3) reasonable attorney's fees. 4-9 (b) A school district shall pay costs of the proceeding and 4-10 attorney's fees directly to the parent. The comptroller shall 4-11 issue the voucher to the parent on behalf of the school district. 4-12 The comptroller may adopt rules necessary to implement this 4-13 subsection, including rules providing for payment of the amount of 4-14 the voucher by the school district. 4-15 Sec. 39.207. JUDICIAL REVIEW. The determination of an 4-16 administrative law judge under this subchapter is subject to 4-17 judicial review as provided by Chapter 2001, Government Code. 4-18 Sec. 39.208. WAIVER OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY. (a) Sovereign 4-19 immunity to suit is waived and abolished to the extent of liability 4-20 created by this subchapter. 4-21 (b) This subchapter does not subject a teacher, 4-22 administrator, member of the board of trustees, or other individual 4-23 associated with a school district to personal liability. 4-24 SECTION 2. This Act takes effect September 1, 1999, and 4-25 authorizes a claim against a school district only in connection 4-26 with an assessment instrument administered under Subchapter B, 4-27 Chapter 39, Education Code, on or after that date. 5-1 SECTION 3. The importance of this legislation and the 5-2 crowded condition of the calendars in both houses create an 5-3 emergency and an imperative public necessity that the 5-4 constitutional rule requiring bills to be read on three several 5-5 days in each house be suspended, and this rule is hereby suspended.