1-1 By: Wentworth S.B. No. 1272 1-2 (In the Senate - Filed March 11, 1999; March 11, 1999, read 1-3 first time and referred to Committee on Natural Resources; 1-4 April 14, 1999, reported adversely, with favorable Committee 1-5 Substitute by the following vote: Yeas 5, Nays 0; April 14, 1999, 1-6 sent to printer.) 1-7 COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR S.B. No. 1272 By: Armbrister A BILL TO BE ENTITLED 1-8 AN ACT 1-9 relating to the authority of a political subdivision to prepare and 1-10 implement a regional habitat conservation plan or habitat 1-11 conservation plan or to enter into a conservation agreement. 1-12 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-13 SECTION 1. Chapter 83, Parks and Wildlife Code, is amended 1-14 by designating Sections 83.001 through 83.004 as Subchapter A and 1-15 adding a heading to Subchapter A to read as follows: 1-16 SUBCHAPTER A. FEDERAL-STATE AGREEMENTS 1-17 SECTION 2. Subchapter A, Chapter 83, Parks and Wildlife 1-18 Code, as designated by this Act, is amended by adding Section 1-19 83.005 to read as follows: 1-20 Sec. 83.005. CONSERVATION AGREEMENTS FOR PROTECTION OF 1-21 SPECIES. (a) Any conservation agreement between a political 1-22 subdivision of the state and the United States Department of the 1-23 Interior must be developed in consultation with the Parks and 1-24 Wildlife Department. 1-25 (b) In this section, "conservation agreement" includes an 1-26 agreement between the state or a political subdivision of the state 1-27 and the United States Department of the Interior under the federal 1-28 act that does not relate to a federal permit as defined by Section 1-29 83.011. 1-30 SECTION 3. Chapter 83, Parks and Wildlife Code, is amended 1-31 by adding Subchapter B to read as follows: 1-32 SUBCHAPTER B. HABITAT PROTECTION BY POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS 1-33 Sec. 83.011. DEFINITIONS. In this chapter: 1-34 (1) "Biological advisory team" means three or more 1-35 professional biologists retained to provide biological guidance to 1-36 plan participants. 1-37 (2) "Endangered species" means a species listed by the 1-38 United States Department of the Interior as endangered or 1-39 threatened under the federal act. 1-40 (3) "Federal act" means the federal Endangered Species 1-41 Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Section 1531 et seq.), as amended. 1-42 (4) "Federal permit" means a permit issued under 1-43 Section 7 or 10(a) of the federal act. 1-44 (5) "Governmental entity" means a political 1-45 subdivision of the state, including: 1-46 (A) a municipality; and 1-47 (B) a county. 1-48 (6) "Habitat conservation plan" means a plan or 1-49 program to protect endangered species by habitat preserves or other 1-50 protection strategies developed in order to obtain a federal 1-51 permit: 1-52 (A) that does not require the regulation of 1-53 non-habitat preserve land; and 1-54 (B) for which the land to be used as habitat 1-55 preserves, at the time of application for the federal permit: 1-56 (i) is owned by a plan participant; or 1-57 (ii) is subject to a contract agreed to by 1-58 each owner of land in the habitat preserve or proposed habitat 1-59 preserve providing that all or part of the owner's land be used or 1-60 managed as a habitat preserve. 1-61 (7) "Habitat preserve" means land set aside or managed 1-62 for the protection of endangered species under a federal permit. 1-63 (8) "Harm" means significant habitat modification or 1-64 degradation that, by significantly impairing essential behavioral 2-1 patterns, including breeding, feeding, sheltering, or migrating, is 2-2 the proximate cause of: 2-3 (A) the death of a member of an endangered 2-4 species; or 2-5 (B) the physical injury of a member of an 2-6 endangered species. 2-7 (9) "Land development standards" means rules or 2-8 ordinances regulating the development of land, including impervious 2-9 cover limitations, building setbacks, zoning, floor-to-area ratios, 2-10 building coverage, water quality controls and regulations, 2-11 landscaping, building height, development setbacks, compatibility 2-12 standards, traffic analyses, driveway cuts, impact fees, and 2-13 transfer of development rights. The term does not include fire or 2-14 building codes or restrictions on the withdrawal of groundwater. 2-15 (10) "Mitigation fee" means a charge or in-kind 2-16 contribution that is based on the amount of harm and is paid or 2-17 provided to a plan participant in exchange for mitigation credit to 2-18 be used to comply with the federal act. 2-19 (11) "Plan participant" means a governmental entity 2-20 that develops, attempts to develop, adopts, approves, or 2-21 participates in a regional habitat conservation plan or habitat 2-22 conservation plan. 2-23 (12) "Regional habitat conservation plan" means a plan 2-24 or program to protect endangered species by habitat preserves or 2-25 other protection strategies developed in order to obtain a federal 2-26 permit that requires the acquisition or regulation of land or 2-27 interests in land not owned by a plan participant at the time of 2-28 application for a federal permit. 2-29 Sec. 83.012. PURPOSE. The purpose of this subchapter is to: 2-30 (1) establish the requirements for and authority of a 2-31 governmental entity to regulate wildlife through the development, 2-32 financing, and implementation of a regional habitat conservation 2-33 plan or a habitat conservation plan; 2-34 (2) encourage governmental entities to use the 2-35 authority under this subchapter to develop and implement habitat 2-36 conservation plans instead of regional habitat conservation plans; 2-37 (3) coordinate, to the greatest extent practicable, 2-38 habitat preserves with lands set aside or to be set aside under 2-39 local, state, or federal laws or regulations; 2-40 (4) prohibit plan participants from devaluing land 2-41 containing endangered species or endangered species habitat through 2-42 plan participant actions; and 2-43 (5) require plan participants of existing regional 2-44 habitat conservation plans to comply with the requirements of this 2-45 subchapter so that existing regional habitat conservation plans 2-46 become habitat conservation plans as quickly as possible. 2-47 Sec. 83.013. AUTHORITY OF DEPARTMENT OR POLITICAL 2-48 SUBDIVISION. (a) The department or a political subdivision may 2-49 participate in the study and preparation for and creation of a 2-50 habitat conservation plan. 2-51 (b) Subject to this subchapter, the department or a 2-52 political subdivision may participate in the study and preparation 2-53 for and creation of a regional habitat conservation plan. 2-54 (c) Subject to this subchapter, a political subdivision, 2-55 including a municipality acting within its corporate limits or its 2-56 extraterritorial jurisdiction, in order to facilitate the creation 2-57 of a habitat preserve and the setting aside of land to protect a 2-58 species protected under a conservation agreement, may: 2-59 (1) purchase land, easements, or leases; and 2-60 (2) enter into an agreement with a landowner to 2-61 establish alternative land development standards for a tract of 2-62 land. 2-63 (d) A plan participant may apply for a federal permit in 2-64 conjunction with a regional habitat conservation plan only if the 2-65 qualified voters of a plan participant have authorized the issuance 2-66 of bonds or other debt financing in an amount equal to the 2-67 estimated cost of acquiring all land for habitat preserves within 2-68 the time required by this subchapter or the plan participant has 2-69 demonstrated that adequate sources of funding exist to acquire all 3-1 land for habitat preserves within the time required by this 3-2 subchapter. 3-3 (e) A governmental entity may not implement a regional 3-4 habitat conservation plan or apply for a federal permit in 3-5 conjunction with a regional habitat conservation plan if: 3-6 (1) the federal act is repealed; or 3-7 (2) the endangered species that are subject to 3-8 conservation and protection under the federal permit cease to be 3-9 listed as endangered by the United States Department of the 3-10 Interior. 3-11 Sec. 83.014. LIMITATION OF POWERS. (a) A governmental 3-12 entity may not impose a regulation, rule, or ordinance related to 3-13 endangered species unless the regulation, rule, or ordinance 3-14 relates to the operation or management of a habitat preserve owned 3-15 by or on behalf of a plan participant. 3-16 (b) A governmental entity may not discriminate against a 3-17 permit application, permit approval, or the provision of utility 3-18 service for land that: 3-19 (1) is or has been designated as habitat preserve or 3-20 potential habitat preserve in a regional habitat conservation plan 3-21 or habitat conservation plan; 3-22 (2) is designated as critical habitat under the 3-23 federal act; or 3-24 (3) has endangered species or endangered species 3-25 habitat. 3-26 (c) A governmental entity may not deny or limit available 3-27 water or wastewater service to land in the service area of the 3-28 governmental entity that has been designated as habitat preserve or 3-29 potential habitat preserve in a regional habitat conservation plan 3-30 or in a habitat conservation plan. For purposes of this 3-31 subsection, a governmental entity may not remove land from its 3-32 water or wastewater utility service areas after the date 3-33 established under Section 83.018(b). 3-34 (d) A governmental entity may not, as a condition for the 3-35 issuance of a permit, approval, or service, require a person to: 3-36 (1) pay a mitigation fee to a plan participant; 3-37 (2) set aside, lease, or convey land as habitat 3-38 preserve; or 3-39 (3) pay a mitigation fee for land set aside or 3-40 restricted from development under local, state, or federal law or 3-41 regulation. 3-42 Sec. 83.015. BIOLOGICAL REVIEW; CRITERIA. (a) A regional 3-43 habitat conservation plan, including any mitigation fee, shall be 3-44 based on the amount of harm to each endangered species to be 3-45 protected under the regional habitat conservation plan. 3-46 (b) The size of proposed habitat preserves shall be based 3-47 solely on the amount of harm to the endangered species to be 3-48 protected in the regional habitat conservation plan. 3-49 (c) The plan participants, together with the commission and 3-50 the landowner members of the citizens advisory committee, shall 3-51 appoint a biological advisory team. At least one member shall be 3-52 appointed by the commission and one member by the landowner members 3-53 of the citizens advisory committee. The member appointed by the 3-54 commission serves as presiding officer of the team. The team shall 3-55 assist in: 3-56 (1) the calculation of harm to the endangered species; 3-57 and 3-58 (2) the sizing and configuring of the habitat 3-59 preserves. 3-60 (d) Meetings of the biological advisory team are subject to 3-61 the open meetings law, Chapter 551, Government Code, and all work 3-62 product of the biological advisory team is subject to the open 3-63 records law, Chapter 552, Government Code. 3-64 Sec. 83.016. CITIZENS ADVISORY COMMITTEE. (a) The plan 3-65 participants shall appoint a citizens advisory committee to assist 3-66 in preparing the regional habitat conservation plan and the 3-67 application for a federal permit. 3-68 (b) At least four members or 33 percent of the citizens 3-69 advisory committee, whichever is greater in number, must own 4-1 undeveloped land or land in agricultural use in the regional 4-2 habitat conservation plan area. A landowner member may not be an 4-3 employee or elected official of a plan participant or any other 4-4 local, state, or federal governmental entity. 4-5 (c) Not later than the 90th day after the initial 4-6 identification of the proposed preserve system for the regional 4-7 habitat conservation plan, the plan participants shall appoint one 4-8 additional landowner, who owns land within the proposed habitat 4-9 preserve system, to the citizens advisory committee. The 4-10 additional landowner member must comply with Subsection (b). 4-11 (d) The commission shall appoint one representative to the 4-12 citizens advisory committee. The commission's representative is a 4-13 voting member of the committee. 4-14 Sec. 83.017. DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL HABITAT CONSERVATION 4-15 PLAN. (a) Meetings of the citizens advisory committee and 4-16 meetings of the plan participants regarding planning, development, 4-17 and implementation of the regional habitat conservation plan are 4-18 subject to the open meetings law, Chapter 551, Government Code. 4-19 (b) All data, reports, and other information regarding the 4-20 regional habitat conservation plan, including field notes, lab 4-21 notes, and any other information relied on by the biological 4-22 advisory team, are subject to the open records law, Chapter 552, 4-23 Government Code. 4-24 (c) Not later than the 60th day after the initial 4-25 identification of the proposed habitat preserve system for the 4-26 federal permit, the plan participants shall notify in writing each 4-27 owner of land identified by the plan participants as habitat 4-28 preserve or potential habitat preserve. The plan participants 4-29 shall use the county tax rolls to identify the owners of land 4-30 identified as habitat preserve or potential habitat preserve. The 4-31 written notice must include at least the following information: 4-32 (1) the tax identification and parcel numbers; 4-33 (2) the owner's name and address; 4-34 (3) an explanation of the designation or possible 4-35 designation of the tract as habitat preserve or potential habitat 4-36 preserve under the regional habitat conservation plan; 4-37 (4) identification of the citizens advisory committee 4-38 members, including telephone numbers, addresses, and the group that 4-39 each committee member represents; 4-40 (5) identification of employees or agents of plan 4-41 participants who can provide information about the regional habitat 4-42 conservation plan; 4-43 (6) the date of the next citizens advisory committee 4-44 meeting or plan participant meeting regarding the regional habitat 4-45 conservation plan; and 4-46 (7) a description of the status of the regional 4-47 habitat conservation plan. 4-48 Sec. 83.018. PRESERVE ACQUISITION. (a) The designation of 4-49 a tract of land as habitat preserve or potential habitat preserve 4-50 or the presence of endangered species or endangered species habitat 4-51 may not be considered in determining the fair market value of the 4-52 property for acquisition as a habitat preserve. 4-53 (b) A change to plan participant rules and regulations, 4-54 including land development standards, that occurs after the 4-55 earliest date that the biological advisory team, citizens advisory 4-56 committee, or plan participant initially identifies a tract of land 4-57 as habitat preserve or potential habitat preserve may not be 4-58 considered in determining the fair market value of the land for 4-59 acquisition as a habitat preserve. 4-60 (c) The plan participants shall make offers based on fair 4-61 market value to the landowners for the acquisition of fee simple or 4-62 other interest in land designated in the regional habitat 4-63 conservation plan as habitat preserve not later than two years 4-64 after the issuance of the federal permit or three years after the 4-65 initial application for the federal permit, whichever is earlier. 4-66 Acquisition of all habitat preserves must be completed not later 4-67 than the fourth anniversary of the date on which the federal permit 4-68 was issued. A plan participant subject to this subsection who does 4-69 not meet an applicable deadline shall file an application to amend 5-1 the federal permit to remove the nonacquired habitat preserve land 5-2 from the regional habitat conservation plan as a habitat preserve 5-3 not later than the 60th day after the fourth anniversary of the 5-4 date on which the federal permit was issued. 5-5 Sec. 83.019. NOTICE AND HEARING REQUIREMENTS. (a) A plan 5-6 participant must comply with the notice and hearing requirements of 5-7 this section before adopting any regional habitat conservation 5-8 plan, plan amendment, ordinance, budget, fee schedule, rule, 5-9 regulation, or order to implement this subchapter. 5-10 (b) The plan participant, individually or through interlocal 5-11 contract, shall publish a notice, including a brief description of 5-12 the proposed action and the time and place of a public hearing on 5-13 the proposed action, not later than the 30th day before the public 5-14 hearing in the newspaper of largest general circulation in the 5-15 county in which the plan participant proposing the action is 5-16 located. 5-17 (c) A public hearing on the proposed action shall be held at 5-18 the time and place specified in the notice. 5-19 Sec. 83.020. GRIEVANCE WITH DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL HABITAT 5-20 CONSERVATION PLAN. (a) An individual appointed to a citizens 5-21 advisory committee under Section 83.016(b) may file a grievance 5-22 with the commission regarding the development of a regional habitat 5-23 conservation plan under this subchapter if the individual believes 5-24 that the plan is being developed in violation of this subchapter. 5-25 The individual filing the grievance must have been a member of the 5-26 citizens advisory committee for the plan named in the grievance. 5-27 (b) A grievance must be filed under this section not later 5-28 than the 60th day after the date the plan is approved by the plan 5-29 participants. The grievance must cite each provision of this 5-30 subchapter alleged to have been violated during the development of 5-31 the plan and must describe each act alleged to have violated this 5-32 subchapter. 5-33 (c) The commission shall review a grievance filed under this 5-34 section to determine whether the plan is being developed in 5-35 compliance with this subchapter. If after reviewing the grievance 5-36 the commission finds that the grievance has no merit, the 5-37 commission may dismiss the grievance. If the commission finds that 5-38 the grievance does have merit, the commission must hold a public 5-39 hearing in accordance with Chapter 551, Government Code. The 5-40 commission shall take testimony from each plan participant and 5-41 from the individual filing the grievance. On conclusion of 5-42 testimony, the commission shall vote on whether to approve or 5-43 dismiss the grievance or to schedule a public hearing not later 5-44 than the 30th day after the conclusion of the initial public 5-45 hearing and to vote after the conclusion of that hearing whether to 5-46 approve or dismiss the grievance. 5-47 (d) If the commission approves the grievance, the commission 5-48 shall instruct the plan participant or participants to amend the 5-49 plan so that it will comply with this subchapter. The plan 5-50 participant may not submit an application for a federal permit 5-51 until the commission is satisfied that its instructions to amend 5-52 the plan to comply with this subchapter have been carried out. 5-53 (e) A plan participant in a plan that is the subject of a 5-54 grievance filed with the commission may not submit an application 5-55 for a federal permit before the commission: 5-56 (1) has dismissed the grievance; or 5-57 (2) if the commission approves the grievance, has 5-58 determined that the commission's recommended amendments to the plan 5-59 have been made. 5-60 (f) If an individual files a grievance under this section, 5-61 that individual may not file a subsequent grievance. 5-62 SECTION 4. Section 83.006, Parks and Wildlife Code, is 5-63 repealed. 5-64 SECTION 5. (a) Except as provided by Subsection (b) of this 5-65 section, this Act applies only to a regional habitat conservation 5-66 plan for which an application for a federal permit was submitted on 5-67 or after January 1, 1999. 5-68 (b) Subsections (a) and (b), Section 83.018, Parks and 5-69 Wildlife Code, as added by this Act, apply to the acquisition of 6-1 land by a regional habitat conservation plan for which a federal 6-2 permit was issued before September 1, 1999, regardless of the date 6-3 the application was submitted. 6-4 SECTION 6. This Act takes effect September 1, 1999. 6-5 * * * * *