By Ehrhardt H.B. No. 2441 Line and page numbers may not match official copy. Bill not drafted by TLC or Senate E&E. A BILL TO BE ENTITLED 1-1 AN ACT 1-2 relating to the administration of the low-income housing tax credit 1-3 program by the Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs. 1-4 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-5 SECTION 1. Modify Section 2306, Government Code by striking 1-6 the existing language in Subchapter DD and replacing it with the 1-7 following: 1-8 SUBCHAPTER DD. LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM 1-9 Sec. 2306.671. DEFINITIONS. (a) APPLICANT. For purposes 1-10 of this subchapter the term "Applicant" shall mean any person and 1-11 any affiliate of such person, corporation, partnership, joint 1-12 venture, association, or other entity that submits an Application 1-13 to the Department requesting a Housing Tax Credit allocation. 1-14 (b) APPLICATION. For purposes of this subchapter the term 1-15 "Application" shall mean an application in the form prescribed by 1-16 the Department, including any required exhibits or other supporting 1-17 materials, filed with the Department by an Applicant requesting 1-18 Housing Tax Credits from the Department. 1-19 (c) APPLICATION LOG. For purposes of this subchapter the 1-20 term "Application Log" shall mean a form prescribed by the 1-21 Department that contains, at a minimum the following information: 1-22 (1) the names of the Applicant and Related Parties; 2-1 (2) the physical location of the proposed Development; 2-2 (3) the amount of Housing Tax Credits requested; 2-3 (4) the region of the state in which the proposed 2-4 development is located; 2-5 (5) the Set-Aside category the application is made 2-6 under, if any; 2-7 (6) the score of the Application under each scoring 2-8 category adopted by the Department under the Qualified Allocation 2-9 Plan; 2-10 (7) the identity of the Department staff who scored 2-11 the Application; 2-12 (8) the Department's determination whether the 2-13 Application met the Department's underwriting Threshold Criteria; 2-14 (9) the identity of the Department staff who 2-15 underwrote the Application; 2-16 (10) the Board decision on the Application; and 2-17 (11) the amount of Housing Tax Credits awarded by the 2-18 Department to the Application. 2-19 (d) APPLICATION ROUND. For purposes of this subchapter the 2-20 term "Application Round" shall mean the period beginning with the 2-21 date the Department begins accepting Applications for Housing Tax 2-22 Credits and lasting until such time as all available Housing Tax 2-23 Credits are allocated, provided that the Application Round not 2-24 extend beyond the last day of the calendar year. 2-25 (e) AT RISK DEVELOPMENT. For purposes of this subchapter 2-26 the term "At Risk Development" shall mean a housing development 3-1 that receives the benefit of a subsidy in the form of below-market 3-2 interest rates under Section 221(d)(3) and (5), interest reduction 3-3 payments under Section 236 of the National Housing Act, or below 3-4 market interest rate direct loans under Section 202 of the Housing 3-5 Act of 1959, including housing developments that receive the 3-6 benefit of a rental subsidy in the form of rent supplement payments 3-7 under Section 101 of the Housing and Urban Development Act of 1965 3-8 or housing assistance payments through Section 8 in connection with 3-9 Section 202 Loans for Housing for the Elderly or Handicapped, the 3-10 Section 8 Additional Assistance Program for housing developments 3-11 with HUD-Insured and HUD-Held Mortgages or the Section 8 Housing 3-12 Assistance Program for the Disposition of HUD-Owned Projects and 3-13 Sections 514, 515 and 516 Rural Rental Housing, including Rural 3-14 Rental Housing receiving rental assistance payments or Section 8 3-15 subsidies. 3-16 (f) DEVELOPMENT. For purposes of this subchapter the term 3-17 "Development" shall mean an activity defined by the United States 3-18 Internal Revenue Code Section 42(g)(1), one or more buildings that 3-19 contain rental Units, financed under a common plan, and owned by 3-20 the same person for federal tax purposes. Buildings that are part 3-21 of a scattered site Development may be treated as part of a single 3-22 Development if they meet these requirements, and if all of the 3-23 dwelling Units in the buildings are rent-restricted residential 3-24 rental Units. 3-25 (g) HOUSING DEVELOPMENT OWNER. For purposes of this 3-26 subchapter the term "Housing Development Owner" shall mean any 4-1 person or affiliate thereof that owns or proposes to develop the 4-2 housing Development or expects to acquire control of the housing 4-3 Development pursuant to a purchase contract satisfactory to the 4-4 Department. 4-5 (h) HOUSING TAX CREDITS. For purposes of this subchapter 4-6 the term "Housing Tax Credits" shall mean credits against federal 4-7 income taxes awarded to owners of qualified low-income rental 4-8 housing developments pursuant to the United States Internal Revenue 4-9 Code of 1986, Section 42, as amended. 4-10 (i) LAND USE RESTRICTION AGREEMENT. For purposes of this 4-11 subchapter the term "Land Use Restriction Agreement" shall mean an 4-12 agreement between the Department, the Housing Development Owner and 4-13 all successors in interest in the Housing Development Owner which 4-14 encumbers the housing Development with respect to provisions 4-15 stipulated in the United States Internal Revenue Code, Section 42, 4-16 and this subchapter, and the Texas Government Code, Chapter 2306 as 4-17 may be amended from time to time. 4-18 (j) QUALIFIED ALLOCATION PLAN. For purposes of this 4-19 subchapter the term "Qualified Allocation Plan" shall mean any 4-20 plan: 4-21 (1) that sets forth underwriting, selection and 4-22 scoring criteria to be used to determine housing priorities of the 4-23 Department which are appropriate to local conditions. 4-24 (2) that also gives preference in allocation of 4-25 housing credit dollar amounts among selected Developments to- 4-26 (i) Developments serving the lowest income 5-1 tenants; and 5-2 (ii) Developments obligated to serve 5-3 qualified tenants for the longest periods of time; and 5-4 (3) which provides a procedure for the Department, the 5-5 Department's agent or other private contractor of the Department to 5-6 follow for monitoring of compliance with the provisions of the 5-7 Qualified Allocation Plan and this subchapter. 5-8 (k) RELATED PARTY. For purposes of this subchapter the term 5-9 "Related Party" shall mean: 5-10 (1) within the third degree of consanguinity, as 5-11 determined by Chapter 573, Government Code, the brothers, sisters, 5-12 spouse, ancestors, and direct descendants of a person; 5-13 (2) a person and corporation where that person owns 5-14 more than 50% in value of the outstanding stock of that 5-15 corporation; 5-16 (3) two (2) or more corporations that are connected 5-17 through stock ownership with a common parent with stock possessing: 5-18 (i) at least fifty percent (50%) of the 5-19 total combined voting power of all classes that can vote, or 5-20 (ii) at least fifty percent (50%) of the 5-21 total value of shares of all classes of stock of each of the 5-22 corporations, or 5-23 (iii) at least fifty percent (50%) of the 5-24 total value of shares of all classes of stock of at least one of 5-25 the other corporations, excluding, in computing that voting power 5-26 or value, stock owned directly by that other corporation, 6-1 (4) a grantor and fiduciary of any trust; 6-2 (5) a fiduciary of one trust and a fiduciary of 6-3 another trust, if the same person is a grantor of both trusts; 6-4 (6) a fiduciary of a trust and a beneficiary of that 6-5 trust; 6-6 (7) a fiduciary of a trust and a corporation where 6-7 more than fifty percent (50%) in value of the outstanding stock is 6-8 owned by or for the trust or by or for a person who is a grantor of 6-9 the trust; 6-10 (8) a person or organization and an organization that 6-11 is tax-exempt under Subsection 501 (a) of the United States 6-12 Internal Revenue Code and that is controlled by that person or the 6-13 person's family members or by that organization; 6-14 (9) a corporation and a partnership or joint venture 6-15 if the same persons own more than: 6-16 (i) fifty percent (50%) in value of the 6-17 outstanding stock of the corporation; and 6-18 (ii) fifty percent (50%) of the capital 6-19 interest or the profits' interest, in the partnership or joint 6-20 venture; 6-21 (10) one S corporation and another S corporation if 6-22 the same persons own more than fifty percent (50%) in value of the 6-23 outstanding stock of each corporation; 6-24 (11) a S corporation and a C corporation, if the same 6-25 persons own more than fifty percent (50%) in value of the 6-26 outstanding stock of each corporation; 7-1 (12) a partnership and a person or organization owning 7-2 more than fifty percent (50%) of the capital interest, or the 7-3 profits' interest in that partnership; or 7-4 (13) two partnerships where the same person or 7-5 organization owns more than fifty percent (50%) of the capital 7-6 interests or profits' interests. 7-7 For purposes of the previous subsections, the constructive 7-8 ownership provisions of the United States Internal Revenue Code 7-9 Subsection 267 shall apply. 7-10 (l) RURAL AREA. For purposes of this subchapter the term 7-11 "Rural Area" shall mean an area that: 7-12 (1) is outside the boundaries of a Primary 7-13 Metropolitan Statistical Area (PMSA) or a Metropolitan Statistical 7-14 Area (MSA); or 7-15 (2) is within the boundaries of a PMSA or MSA, but has 7-16 a population of not more than twenty thousand (20,000) and does not 7-17 share boundaries with an urbanized area; or 7-18 (3) is located in an area that is eligible for funding 7-19 by Texas Rural Development Office of the United States Department 7-20 of Agriculture. 7-21 (n) RURAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY. For purposes of this 7-22 subchapter the term "Rural Development Agency" shall mean the 7-23 agency or Department designated by the Legislature as principally 7-24 responsible for Rural Area development in the state. 7-25 (o) SET-ASIDE. For purposes of this subchapter the term 7-26 "Set-Aside" shall mean a reservation of a portion of the available 8-1 Housing Tax Credits for purposes of funding housing of a certain 8-2 type, geographic location or serving a specific housing consumer on 8-3 a priority basis as designed in the Qualified Allocation Plan. 8-4 (p) THRESHOLD CRITERIA. For purposes of this subchapter the 8-5 term "Threshold Criteria" shall mean criteria used to determine 8-6 that the Development's score and financial feasibility (as 8-7 determined by development underwriting) meet the minimum level of 8-8 acceptability for consideration established in the Department's 8-9 Qualified Allocation Plan. 8-10 (q) UNIT. For purposes of this subchapter the term "Unit" 8-11 shall mean any residential rental unit in a housing development 8-12 consisting of an accommodation containing separate and complete 8-13 physical facilities and fixtures for living, sleeping, eating, 8-14 cooking and sanitation. The term "Unit" may also include a single 8-15 room occupancy housing unit used on a non-transient basis so long 8-16 as separate facilities exist as above described. 8-17 Sec. 2306.672. PURPOSE. The Department shall administer the 8-18 Housing Tax Credit program for the following purposes: 8-19 (a) to produce the highest quality housing that serves the 8-20 lowest income tenants for the longest period of time; 8-21 (b) to maximize the number of affordable rental housing 8-22 Units added to the state's existing housing stock; 8-23 (c) to encourage development and preservation of appropriate 8-24 rental housing types for households which have difficulty finding 8-25 suitable and affordable rental housing in the private marketplace; 8-26 (d) to enable substantial rehabilitation of existing rental 9-1 housing in order to prevent losses to the existing supply of 9-2 affordable apartments; 9-3 (e) to prevent losses from the existing stock of low-income 9-4 rental housing of those At-Risk apartments under expiring contracts 9-5 with federal agencies or subject to prepayment which, without the 9-6 allocation of tax credits, would be converted to market rate 9-7 apartments; 9-8 (f) to maximize the term of affordability of the housing 9-9 created; 9-10 (g) to provide an equitable distribution of tax credits 9-11 across the state including small cities and Rural Areas. 9-12 Sec. 2306.673. ELIGIBILITY. (a) An Application will be 9-13 ineligible if the Applicant or a Related Party has been or is a 9-14 member of the Board, executive director, deputy director of housing 9-15 programs or tax credit manager that was employed by the Department 9-16 during any part of the five (5) years prior to the allocation 9-17 round. 9-18 (b) An Application will be ineligible if it requests an 9-19 annual allocation of Housing Tax Credits greater than $5,500 per 9-20 Housing Tax Credit restricted Unit. Developments in Rural Areas or 9-21 Developments located in counties designated as Economically 9-22 Distressed Areas as defined in Subchapter J, Chapter 16, Water Code 9-23 and Subchapter K, Chapter 17, Water Code may receive up to $6,500 9-24 per Housing Tax Credit restricted Unit in annual Housing Tax 9-25 Credits. 9-26 (c) Applications will be ineligible if submitted by an 10-1 Applicant requesting more than $1.6 million per Housing Tax Credit 10-2 Application Round. This limitation will apply to all Related 10-3 Parties. 10-4 (d) An Application for a Development comprising more than 10-5 100 residential dwelling Units will be ineligible. 10-6 Sec. 2306.674. APPLICATION. (a) Pre-application process. 10-7 The Department shall establish, by rule, a pre-application process 10-8 and shall provide an incentive through the award of points in the 10-9 scoring process as an incentive for Applicants to participate in 10-10 this process. The purpose of the pre-application process shall be 10-11 to allow the Department and Applicants to assess the viability and 10-12 eligibility of proposed Applications prior to the Applicant 10-13 incurring the costs of submission of a full Application. 10-14 Pre-applications that fail to score above a minimum Threshold 10-15 Criteria set by the Board in the Qualified Allocation Plan shall be 10-16 rejected by the Department and returned to the Applicant. 10-17 (b) Required elements of the Application. 10-18 (1) An Application for Housing Tax Credits shall 10-19 contain such elements as the board shall designate through the 10-20 Qualified Allocation Plan. The Application shall also contain the 10-21 following: 10-22 (i) Financing plan. A detailed 10-23 description of the financing plan, and proposed sources and uses of 10-24 funds, to include construction, permanent and bridge loan sources, 10-25 and other funding sources including rent or operating subsidies and 10-26 reserves. The commitment status of all fund sources shall be 11-1 described and non-traditional financing arrangements shall be 11-2 explained. 11-3 (ii) Justification of syndication costs in 11-4 basis. If syndication costs are included in eligible basis, a 11-5 justification from a tax attorney or tax accountant shall be 11-6 provided for each cost category. 11-7 (iii) Terms of syndication agreement. 11-8 Written estimate from syndicators or the financial consultant of 11-9 equity dollars expected to be raised for the proposed Development 11-10 from the amount of Housing Tax Credits requested, including pay-in 11-11 schedules, syndication costs, including syndicator consulting fees, 11-12 and an estimated tax credit factor. 11-13 (iv) Description of subsidies. If rental 11-14 assistance, operating subsidies or annuities are proposed, the 11-15 Applicant shall furnish in the Application all related contracts 11-16 and agreements that secure said funds and identify the source, 11-17 annual amount, term, number of Units receiving assistance, and 11-18 expiration date of contracts and agreements. 11-19 (v) Evidence of zoning. If the 11-20 Development is located within a political subdivision with a zoning 11-21 ordinance, the Applicant shall provide written evidence in the form 11-22 of a letter from the chief executive officer of the appropriate 11-23 political jurisdiction or the Department director with jurisdiction 11-24 over zoning matters stating that the proposed Development is 11-25 permitted under current zoning ordinances applicable to the 11-26 property where the Development is to be located. 12-1 (vi) Tenant relocation plan. Applicants 12-2 proposing rehabilitation of an existing occupied rental housing 12-3 Development shall provide an explanation of the process used to 12-4 notify and consult with tenants in the preparation of the 12-5 Application, relocation requirements, a detailed relocation plan 12-6 including a budget with an identified funding source, and, where 12-7 applicable, evidence that the relocation plan has been submitted to 12-8 the appropriate local agency. 12-9 (vii) Nonprofit Set-Aside Application. 12-10 Applicants requesting Housing Tax Credits from the nonprofit 12-11 Set-Aside, as defined by the United States Internal Revenue Code 12-12 Section 42(h)(5), shall provide the following documentation with 12-13 respect to each developer and general partner of the proposed 12-14 Development Owner: 12-15 (A) IRS documentation of designation as a 12-16 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) corporation; 12-17 (B) proof that one of the exempt purposes of the 12-18 corporation is to provide low-income housing; 12-19 (C) a detailed description of the nonprofit 12-20 participation in the Development and ongoing operations of the 12-21 proposed Development; 12-22 (D) proof that the corporation prohibits members 12-23 of its board of directors, other than the chief staff member, if a 12-24 board member, from receiving material compensation for their 12-25 services as board members, 12-26 (E) a third party legal opinion that the 13-1 nonprofit organization is not affiliated with or controlled by a 13-2 for-profit organization, and the basis for said determination; 13-3 (F) a copy of the nonprofit corporation's last 13-4 audited financial statement; 13-5 (G) a list with home addresses of members of the 13-6 board of directors of the nonprofit corporation; 13-7 (H) a third party legal opinion stating that the 13-8 Applicant is eligible for the nonprofit Set-Aside pursuant to the 13-9 United States Internal Revenue Code Section 42(h)(5); 13-10 (I) evidence that fifty-one percent (51%) of the 13-11 board of directors of the nonprofit corporation principally reside 13-12 in the community in which the Development is to be constructed. 13-13 For purposes of this section "community" shall be defined as in an 13-14 area not more than ninety (90) miles from the site of the proposed 13-15 Development except in cases where the proposed Development is to be 13-16 located in a Rural Area as defined in this subchapter. A nonprofit 13-17 corporation proposing a Development in a Rural Area shall provide 13-18 evidence that fifty-one percent (51%) of the board of directors of 13-19 the nonprofit corporation principally reside in the state of Texas. 13-20 (viii) To be eligible for the nonprofit 13-21 Set-Aside, a nonprofit corporation must control no less than 13-22 fifty-one percent (51%) of the Development and must be the managing 13-23 general partner if the Application is submitted on behalf of a 13-24 limited partnership. 13-25 (c) Application changes. An Application may not be changed 13-26 subsequent to the Application filing deadline nor may any 14-1 supplemental information considered in the awarding of points or 14-2 meeting of Threshold Criteria be submitted. 14-3 (d) Identities of interest disclosed. The Applicant shall 14-4 disclose the identity of any persons or entities (including 14-5 affiliated entities and Related Parties) that will provide 14-6 development or operational services to the proposed Development. 14-7 These persons or entities shall include but are not limited to: 14-8 (1) developer; 14-9 (2) architect; 14-10 (3) attorney; 14-11 (4) tax professional; 14-12 (5) property management company; 14-13 (6) consultant; 14-14 (7) market analyst; 14-15 (8) tenant services provider; 14-16 (9) syndicator; 14-17 (10) real estate broker and agent or a person or 14-18 corporation receiving a fee in connection with any services usually 14-19 provided by a real estate broker or agent; and 14-20 (11) owners of the property on which the Development 14-21 is to be located. 14-22 For all of these parties the Application shall disclose, if 14-23 applicable, the company name and contact person, address and 14-24 telephone number. 14-25 (e) Processing Applications. 14-26 (1) The Department shall process Applications in a 15-1 manner that maintains the integrity of the Application, fully 15-2 documents Department decisions relative to the Application, and 15-3 makes available to the public accurate and timely information 15-4 concerning all Applications and Department decisions. 15-5 (2) The complete Application, all supporting documents 15-6 and exhibits, Application Logs, scoring sheets and all other 15-7 documents related to the processing of the Application shall be 15-8 available to the public through the Department's Website at least 15-9 thirty (30) days prior to any Board decision to award tax credits. 15-10 (3) The Department's certification, scoring, and 15-11 underwriting decisions regarding an Application shall be documented 15-12 on the Application Log. 15-13 (4) The Application Log shall document all contacts 15-14 between the Department staff, the Board and the Applicant and any 15-15 Related Parties and contain a summary of the nature of these 15-16 contacts. 15-17 (5) The Application Log sheet shall contain a list of 15-18 staff and Board decisions relative to the Application. The 15-19 identity of the staff member making the relevant decision 15-20 concerning the Application shall appear on an Application Log next 15-21 to the decision. 15-22 (6) Notwithstanding any other provision herein, the 15-23 financial statements of any individual making Application for tax 15-24 credits may be regarded by the Department as confidential and not 15-25 disclosed to the public. 15-26 (f) Application scoring. 16-1 (1) In awarding Applications for tax credits the 16-2 Department shall follow the following process: 16-3 (i) The Department shall first score each 16-4 Application received. Any Application not meeting Threshold 16-5 Criteria set out in the Qualified Allocation Plan shall be rejected 16-6 and returned to the Applicant. 16-7 (ii) The Department will then underwrite 16-8 Applications, beginning with the Application with the highest score 16-9 within each region established in Section 2306.111(d) and within 16-10 each Set-Aside category established in the Qualified Allocation 16-11 Plan. The Department will underwrite Applications until a 16-12 sufficient number of Applications that meet the Department's 16-13 underwriting standards have been processed to award all available 16-14 tax credits consistent with the regional allocation goals and the 16-15 Set-Aside categories. The Department shall underwrite additional 16-16 Applications in order to establish a waiting list of Applications 16-17 of a number determined by the Board to be adequate to ensure that 16-18 all of the available Housing Tax Credits can be awarded within the 16-19 time period provided by state and federal law. 16-20 (2) In allocating Housing Tax Credits, the Department 16-21 shall score each Application using a point system based on criteria 16-22 adopted by the Department. The Department shall publish in the 16-23 Qualified Allocation Plan details of the scoring system that the 16-24 Department will use in scoring an Application. 16-25 (3) The Department shall adopt a scoring system that 16-26 considers: 17-1 (i) the income levels of tenants that will 17-2 be housed; 17-3 (ii) the rent levels of the Units; 17-4 (iii) the period of guaranteed 17-5 affordability for low income tenants; 17-6 (iv) the cost per square foot of the 17-7 Development; 17-8 (v) the size, quality and amenities of the 17-9 Units; 17-10 (vi) the services to be provided at the 17-11 Development to tenants; 17-12 (vii) local market conditions; 17-13 (viii) the commitment of funding to the 17-14 Development from local units of government; 17-15 (ix) the level of community support for 17-16 the Application; 17-17 (4) In developing scoring factors to rank Housing Tax 17-18 Credit Applications the Department shall adopt as the most 17-19 important scoring criteria such factors and scoring weights as will 17-20 result in the award of tax credits to Developments serving the 17-21 lowest income tenants and produce the highest quality Units that 17-22 commit to remain affordable to qualified tenants for the longest 17-23 periods of time. 17-24 (5) The Department will adopt underwriting standards 17-25 that are consistent with the selection criteria in section (4). 17-26 (6) The Department shall measure community support for 18-1 a Development through the written statements of support from local 18-2 and state elected officials. 18-3 (7) The Department shall publish on the Department's 18-4 Website the details of the score for each Application at least 18-5 thirty (30) days before awards are made. 18-6 (g) Modification of Application by Applicant subsequent to 18-7 award by the Board 18-8 (1) Any Application for which Development 18-9 modifications are proposed that would materially alter the original 18-10 approved Development shall be subject to following procedure: 18-11 (2) The Department shall require the Applicant to file 18-12 a formal written amendment to the Housing Tax Credit Application on 18-13 forms designed by the Department; 18-14 (3) The executive director will provide an evaluation 18-15 and recommendation in writing to the Board; 18-16 (4) Notice of the amendment and the staff 18-17 recommendation on the amendment will be posted on the Department's 18-18 Website at least fifteen (15) days prior to Board action on the 18-19 amendment; 18-20 (5) The amendment must be approved by vote of the 18-21 Board. The Board may reject any proposed amendment and may rescind 18-22 an award and reallocate credits to other Applicants on the waiting 18-23 list set out in 2306.674(j) if, in the judgment of the Board, the 18-24 amendment materially negatively affects the proposed Development or 18-25 would have affected the selection of the Application in the 18-26 Application Round; 19-1 (6) A material alteration of an Application shall 19-2 include such modifications as the Board may determine are of 19-3 significance, including, but not limited to the following: 19-4 (i) a significant change in the site plan; 19-5 (ii) an alteration of the number of Units 19-6 or bedroom mix of Units; 19-7 (iii) a substantive modification of the 19-8 scope of tenant services; 19-9 (iv) a reduction in the square footage of 19-10 the Units or common areas of three percent (3%) or more; 19-11 (v) a significant modification of the 19-12 architectural design of the Development; 19-13 (vi) a change in the residential density 19-14 of the Development of plus or minus five percent (5%). 19-15 (7) Credit and ownership transfers. No allocation of 19-16 Housing Tax Credits, or ownership of a Development funded with 19-17 Housing Tax Credits, may be transferred by an Applicant unless 19-18 written approval of the executive director is obtained prior to the 19-19 proposed transfer. Approvals shall not be unreasonably withheld. 19-20 (8) Any transfer of Development ownership or 19-21 allocation of Housing Tax Credits shall be evidenced by written 19-22 agreement between the parties to the transfer, including agreements 19-23 entered into by the transferee and the Department. 19-24 (9) The owner of the property shall furnish the 19-25 executive director certification that the tenants in the 19-26 Development have been notified in writing of the proposed sale or 20-1 transfer at least thirty (30) days prior to the submission of the 20-2 request to the Department for approval of the transfer. 20-3 (10) The entity acquiring ownership or Housing Tax 20-4 Credits shall be subject to a "qualifications review" by the 20-5 Department to determine past compliance with Housing Tax Credits 20-6 Land Use Restriction Agreements and if sufficient housing 20-7 development and management experience is present for owning and 20-8 operating a Housing Tax Credit Development. Information regarding 20-9 the names of the purchasers or transferees and Related Parties, and 20-10 detailed information describing the experience and financial 20-11 capacity of said persons, shall be provided to the Department upon 20-12 request. 20-13 (h) Deadlines for allocation of Housing Tax Credits. 20-14 (1) Not later than November 15 of each year, the 20-15 Department shall prepare and submit to the Board for adoption the 20-16 Qualified Allocation Plan required by federal law for use by the 20-17 Department in setting criteria and priorities for the allocation of 20-18 Housing Tax Credits and Set-Asides under the Housing Tax Credit 20-19 program. 20-20 (2) The Board shall adopt and submit to the Governor 20-21 the Qualified Allocation Plan not later than January 31. 20-22 (3) The Governor shall approve, reject, or modify and 20-23 approve the Qualified Allocation Plan not later than February 28. 20-24 (4) An Applicant for Housing Tax Credits to be issued 20-25 a commitment during the initial allocation cycle in a calendar year 20-26 must submit an Application to the Department not later than May 15. 21-1 (5) The Board shall issue a commitment for allocation 21-2 for the initial cycle of Housing Tax Credits each year in 21-3 accordance with the Qualified Allocation Plan not later than July 21-4 31. 21-5 (i) The executive director shall provide the Application 21-6 scores to the Board no less than thirty (30) days before the Board 21-7 makes a decision relating to the allocation of Housing Tax Credits. 21-8 (j) Not later than the deadline specified in Section 21-9 2306.674(h)(5), the Board shall issue a commitment for Housing Tax 21-10 Credits available to the Department based on the awards process set 21-11 out in Section 2306.674(f)(1). Concurrently with the issuance of a 21-12 commitment for the initial Housing Tax Credits, the Board shall 21-13 establish a waiting list of additional Applications, ranked in 21-14 descending order of priority based on the Set-Aside category, 21-15 Application score and regional allocation requirements of Section 21-16 2306.111, to be issued a commitment for Housing Tax Credits if 21-17 additional Housing Tax Credits become available. 21-18 (k) At-Risk Development Set-Aside. Twenty percent (20%) of 21-19 the Housing Tax Credits for any calendar year shall be Set-Aside 21-20 for Developments that qualify as At-Risk pursuant to this 21-21 subchapter. Any amount of Housing Tax Credits Set-Aside under this 21-22 section remaining after the reservation of Housing Tax Credits 21-23 shall be available for allocation to any eligible Development. 21-24 (l) Ex parte communication prohibited. Neither the Applicant 21-25 nor any person, general partner, contractor or their respective 21-26 principals or affiliates active in the ownership or control of the 22-1 proposed Development or any person employed as a lobbyist by the 22-2 Applicant or Related Party shall communicate with any Board member 22-3 expect at a Board meeting or a public hearing with respect to the 22-4 Application during the period of time an Application is submitted 22-5 until that time Housing Tax Credits are approved by the Board. 22-6 Sec. 2306.675. APPEALS. (a) AVAILABILITY. An Applicant may 22-7 file an appeal of a Department evaluation and scoring, limited to: 22-8 (1) determination of the Application score; 22-9 (2) qualification in meeting Threshold Criteria; 22-10 (3) determination that the Development meets the 22-11 Department's Threshold Criteria for underwriting standards and, 22-12 (4) determination of the credit amount. 22-13 No applicant may appeal the Department's evaluation of another 22-14 Applicant's Application. 22-15 (b) TIMING. The appeal shall be submitted in writing in a 22-16 format prescribed by the Department in the Qualified Allocation 22-17 Plan and be received by the Department not later than seven (7) 22-18 calendar days following the publication of the Department's scoring 22-19 of Applications and underwriting. The appeal shall identify 22-20 specifically, based upon documentation furnished with the original 22-21 Application, the Applicant's grounds for the appeal. 22-22 (c) REVIEW. The executive director shall respond in writing 22-23 to the appeal within fourteen (14) days, and if the Applicant is 22-24 not satisfied with that response, the Applicant shall be permitted 22-25 to appeal in writing to the Board, provided that the appeal is 22-26 received at least seven (7) days before the Board meeting at which 23-1 decisions are expected to be made, or, if the determination of the 23-2 appeal to the executive director is made less than seven (7) days 23-3 prior to the Board meeting, at least three days before the Board 23-4 meeting. The appeal review shall be based upon the existing 23-5 documentation submitted by the Applicant when the Application was 23-6 filed. No information not submitted with the original application 23-7 shall be submitted. The decision of the Board is final. 23-8 (d) The appeal and all documents in the appeals process are 23-9 public records and shall be made available through the Department's 23-10 Website. 23-11 Sec. 2306.676. FEES. (a) A fee charged by the Department 23-12 to an Applicant for filing a Housing Tax Credit Application may not 23-13 be excessive and must reflect the Department's actual costs in 23-14 processing Applications, providing copies of documents in 23-15 connection with the allocation process and making the information 23-16 about the Application and scoring available to the public through 23-17 the Department's Website. 23-18 (b) The Department shall publish not later that July 1 a 23-19 schedule of Application fees, detailing the amount of fees to be 23-20 charged Applicants at each stage of the Application process. These 23-21 fees shall be based on the Department's actual costs of processing 23-22 the Applications. The Department shall refund within thirty (30) 23-23 days the balance of any fees collected from an Applicant for an 23-24 application that was withdrawn or not fully processed by the 23-25 Department in accordance with the Department's published schedule 23-26 of Application fees. 24-1 (c) The Department shall develop a sliding scale fee 24-2 schedule for the Housing Tax Credit Applications that encourages 24-3 increased participation by nonprofit community housing development 24-4 organizations (CHDOs). 24-5 Sec. 2306.677. PUBLIC INFORMATION AND HEARINGS. (a) The 24-6 Department shall provide information regarding the Housing Tax 24-7 Credit program, including notices of public hearings, meetings, and 24-8 opening and closing dates for Applications for Housing Tax Credits, 24-9 to local housing departments, newspapers, nonprofit organizations, 24-10 on-site property managers of occupied developments that are the 24-11 subject of Housing Tax Credit Applications for posting in prominent 24-12 locations at those developments, and other interested persons and 24-13 community groups who request the information. 24-14 (b) The Department shall hold at least three (3) public 24-15 hearings in different regions of the state to receive public 24-16 comments on Housing Tax Credit Applications. 24-17 (c) Within five (5) working days following submission of a 24-18 Housing Tax Credit Application, the Department shall make available 24-19 to the public a full and complete copy of the Application and all 24-20 attachments and exhibits through the Department's Website. 24-21 (d) The Department will provide to the public through the 24-22 Department's Website within three (3) working days the results of 24-23 each phase of the Application scoring, underwriting and awards 24-24 process. 24-25 (e) The Department shall provide written notification that 24-26 an Application has been filed to the following elected 25-1 representatives of the government jurisdictions where the proposed 25-2 Development is to be located: member of the Texas Senate; member 25-3 of the Texas House of Representatives; and the chief executive 25-4 officer (e.g., city manager, county judge) of the local 25-5 jurisdiction within which the proposed Development is located. The 25-6 Department shall provide elected officials an opportunity to 25-7 comment on the proposed Development prior to any award of Housing 25-8 Tax Credits and shall consider these comments as provided in 25-9 Section 2306.674(f)(4). 25-10 (f) A state senator or a state representative representing 25-11 the area where a housing Development would be located may hold a 25-12 community meeting at which the Department shall provide appropriate 25-13 representation. 25-14 (g) When the Department receives written notification from 25-15 the mayor or county judge of an affected city or county opposing an 25-16 Application, the Department must contact the mayor or county judge 25-17 and offer to conduct a physical inspection of the site and 25-18 consultation with the mayor or county judge before the Application 25-19 is scored. 25-20 Sec. 2306.678. MONITORING AND COMPLIANCE. (a) The 25-21 Department shall assign staff, independent of Housing Tax Credit 25-22 division staff, or shall contract with an outside independent third 25-23 party to oversee and monitor Housing Tax Credit Developments during 25-24 construction for compliance with all Application commitments. 25-25 These monitors shall supply the Board with an analysis and 25-26 recommendation concerning any proposed substantive modification to 26-1 a funded Housing Tax Credit Application prior to Board 26-2 consideration of a request for approval of such a modification. 26-3 (b) In monitoring compliance during the operation of Housing 26-4 Tax Credit Developments as residential rental property, the 26-5 Department may contract with an outside, independent third party to 26-6 conduct compliance monitoring. 26-7 (c) The Department shall utilize fair housing and housing 26-8 compliance testers to ensure that Housing Tax Credit Developments 26-9 are in compliance with all agreements and restrictions imposed by 26-10 the Department. 26-11 (d) All representations made by an Applicant for an 26-12 allocation are enforceable by the Department and the tenants of the 26-13 Development. 26-14 Sec. 2306.679. OTHER PROVISIONS. (a) Debarment from 26-15 participation. 26-16 (1) Individuals and corporations may be barred from 26-17 submission of Applications for Housing Tax Credits on the basis of 26-18 past failure to adhere to the terms and conditions imposed by the 26-19 Department in the award of Housing Tax Credits. 26-20 (2) The board shall adopt a debarment policy by rule. 26-21 Debarment from participation shall occur when a corporation or an 26-22 individual shall have materially violated the terms and conditions 26-23 set out by the Department for the award of Housing Tax Credits, 26-24 shall have been debarred from participation in federal housing 26-25 programs by the United States Department of Housing and Urban 26-26 Development, or shall have been found to have been in material 27-1 noncompliance with a Land Use Restriction Agreement on a 27-2 development funded by the Department. Evidence of repeated 27-3 violations of the Land Use Restriction Agreement shall constitute 27-4 sufficient basis for debarment from the Housing Tax Credit program. 27-5 (3) An individual or corporation debarred for 27-6 participation in the program may appeal their debarment to the 27-7 Board. 27-8 (b) Accessibility to people with disabilities. 27-9 (1) Any Development funded with Housing Tax Credits 27-10 shall comply with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 27-11 design standards. 27-12 (c) Discrimination against persons receiving federal housing 27-13 assistance prohibited. 27-14 (1) The Department shall prohibit Housing Tax Credit 27-15 Developments from excluding an individual or family from: 27-16 (i) admission to any Development funded 27-17 under this program because the individual or family participates in 27-18 the housing choice voucher program under Section 8, United States 27-19 Housing Act of 1937 (42 U.S.C. Section 1437f), as amended; and 27-20 (ii) using a financial or minimum income 27-21 standard for an individual or family participating in the voucher 27-22 program described in Subdivision (i) that requires the individual 27-23 or family to have a monthly income of more than two and one-half 27-24 (2-1/2) times the individual's or family's share of the total 27-25 monthly rent payable to the owner of the Housing Tax Credit Unit. 27-26 (d) Coordination with state agency for Rural Area 28-1 development. The Department shall jointly administer with the 28-2 state Rural Development Agency that portion of the Housing Tax 28-3 Credit program Set-Aside for Rural Areas. 28-4 (1) The purpose of this joint administration shall be 28-5 to assure maximum utilization and optimum geographic distribution 28-6 of Housing Tax Credits in Rural Areas, provide for sharing of 28-7 information, efficient procedures, and fulfillment of Development 28-8 compliance requirements in Rural Areas of the state. 28-9 (2) The Rural Development Agency shall participate in 28-10 development of all scoring and underwriting criteria applied to 28-11 Applications within any Housing Tax Credit Set-Aside for Rural 28-12 Areas. The Rural Development Agency shall approve all scoring and 28-13 underwriting criteria developed by the Department for Housing Tax 28-14 Credit Applications within any Housing Tax Credit Set-Aside for 28-15 Rural Areas. 28-16 (3) The Rural Development Agency shall participate 28-17 jointly with the Department in the review and scoring of 28-18 Applications made under any Housing Tax Credit Set-Aside for Rural 28-19 Areas. 28-20 (4) The Department shall fund and jointly carry out 28-21 with the Rural Development Agency outreach, training and Rural Area 28-22 capacity building efforts as directed by the Rural Development 28-23 Agency to ensure that the Housing Tax Credit Set-Aside for Rural 28-24 Areas receives a sufficient volume of qualifying Applications. 28-25 (5) To maximize the utilization of appropriate housing 28-26 resources to meet the housing needs of different regions of the 29-1 state the Department and the Rural Development Agency shall jointly 29-2 adjust the regional allocation of tax credits provided under 29-3 Section 2306.111 in order to offset for the under and over 29-4 utilization of multifamily private activity bonds and other housing 29-5 resources between different regions of the state. 29-6 (6) The Department shall reimburse the Rural 29-7 Development Agency from Housing Tax Credit Application fees the 29-8 Department collects for costs that the Rural Development Agency 29-9 incurs in carrying out these functions. 29-10 SECTION 2. This Act takes effect immediately if it receives 29-11 a vote of two-thirds of all the members elected to each house, as 29-12 provided by Section 39, Article III, Texas Constitution. If this 29-13 Act does not receive the vote necessary for immediate effect, this 29-14 Act takes effect September 1, 2001.