By Madden H.B. No. 3221 77R5639 PAM-F A BILL TO BE ENTITLED 1-1 AN ACT 1-2 relating to requirements for providing voting systems accessible to 1-3 persons with physical disabilities. 1-4 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: 1-5 SECTION 1. Title 8, Election Code, is amended by adding 1-6 Chapter 129 to read as follows: 1-7 CHAPTER 129. VOTING SYSTEMS ACCESSIBLE TO PERSONS WITH PHYSICAL 1-8 DISABILITIES 1-9 SUBCHAPTER A. GENERAL PROVISIONS 1-10 Sec. 129.001. APPLICABILITY. (a) This chapter applies if a 1-11 political subdivision: 1-12 (1) acquires a new voting system by lease or purchase; 1-13 or 1-14 (2) substantially modifies an existing voting system 1-15 in a manner that changes the manner in which voters interact with 1-16 the ballot at the polling place. 1-17 (b) This section does not apply if a change made to a voting 1-18 system at a central counting station or at the early voting ballot 1-19 board does not directly affect voters. 1-20 Sec. 129.002. ACCESSIBILITY; SECRET BALLOT. If a political 1-21 subdivision acquires a new voting system, the system must: 1-22 (1) be accessible to persons with physical 1-23 disabilities; and 1-24 (2) provide the voter with a practical and effective 2-1 means to cast an independent and secret ballot. 2-2 Sec. 129.003. MULTIPLE VOTING SYSTEMS PERMITTED IN CERTAIN 2-3 CIRCUMSTANCES. A political subdivision may use more than one type 2-4 of voting system in a single polling place only to provide to a 2-5 person with a physical disability a method of casting an 2-6 independent and secret ballot. 2-7 Sec. 129.004. SCOPE OF REQUIREMENT. (a) A newly acquired 2-8 voting system must be accessible in each polling place where the 2-9 system is used. 2-10 (b) This section does not require a political subdivision to 2-11 place a newly acquired voting system in each polling place in the 2-12 political subdivision. 2-13 (Sections 129.005-129.020 reserved for expansion 2-14 SUBCHAPTER B. ALTERNATIVE METHODS FOR PROVIDING A 2-15 SECRET BALLOT TO PERSONS WITH PHYSICAL DISABILITIES 2-16 Sec. 129.021. ALTERNATIVE METHODS AUTHORIZED. In addition to 2-17 the procedures provided by Subchapter B, Chapter 64, a political 2-18 subdivision may use any of the methods described by this subchapter 2-19 to provide an independent and secret ballot to a person with a 2-20 physical disability. 2-21 Sec. 129.022. PAPER OR OPTICAL SCAN BALLOT WITH TEMPLATE AND 2-22 TELEPHONE OR AUDIOTAPE SYSTEM. (a) A political subdivision may 2-23 create a ballot template, which is a precinct-specific tactile 2-24 ballot cover or overlay that is used to allow visually- or 2-25 reading-impaired voters to vote independently through the use of 2-26 touch. The ballot template must be in the form of a folder or other 2-27 overlay into which the voter's ballot is inserted. A binder clip 3-1 or similar fastener must be attached to keep the ballot in place. 3-2 The ballot template must have raised lines on the template to guide 3-3 a voter to the appropriate voting locations on the ballot and must 3-4 have holes punched in the template to allow the voter to mark the 3-5 actual ballot. The lines may be created with velcro strips, fabric 3-6 glue, caulk, or any other substance that will provide tactile 3-7 guidance to the layout of the ballot. The lines must be designed to 3-8 divide the races or issues on the ballot. Each race or issue may 3-9 be numbered by writing a number with the substance used to mark the 3-10 template. The numbers may also be printed in Braille. If a vendor 3-11 provides a ballot template with holes punched to correspond to each 3-12 oval on an optical scan ballot, the authority conducting the 3-13 election shall make that template precinct-specific by dividing the 3-14 ballot into the appropriate precinct races by using raised lines 3-15 and covering the holes so that the voter may not make a mark. The 3-16 material used to cover the holes must be self-adhesive and thick 3-17 enough to alert the voter that a mark should not be made in that 3-18 hole. 3-19 (b) When a voter with a visual or reading disability arrives 3-20 at a polling place and requests to vote using the method described 3-21 by Subsection (a), an election officer must verify the voter's 3-22 eligibility to vote. An eligible voter may select a ballot from the 3-23 official precinct ballot stock. After the voter selects a ballot, 3-24 an election officer shall insert the ballot into the template and 3-25 give the ballot with the template to the voter. One corner of the 3-26 ballot template must be cut at an angle that corresponds to a 3-27 similar cut on the ballot to allow the election officer and voter 4-1 to confirm that the ballot is correctly aligned and facing the 4-2 correct direction in the ballot cover. The voter may choose to 4-3 insert the ballot into the ballot cover rather than requiring an 4-4 election officer to perform this function. 4-5 (c) If a telephone system is used, an election officer shall 4-6 then make a telephone call to a designated telephone number. After 4-7 the person assigned to read the ballot in English or Spanish to the 4-8 voter answers the telephone, the election officer may disclose only 4-9 the precinct number to the reader. The election officer may not 4-10 disclose the name of the voter to the reader. The election officer 4-11 shall give the voter the telephone. The assigned reader shall 4-12 provide the voter with instructions for reading the ballot template 4-13 and marking the ballot. After the assigned reader confirms that the 4-14 voter understands the procedures and the layout of the ballot 4-15 template, the reader shall read the first race and candidates' 4-16 names or propositions. After the voter marks the ballot, the 4-17 reader shall instruct the voter to move to the next section on the 4-18 ballot template to vote on the next race or issue. The reader must 4-19 have a copy of the template that the voter is using so that the 4-20 reader may instruct the voter accurately on the races and issues on 4-21 which the voter is eligible to vote. After the voter completes the 4-22 ballot, the ballot shall be deposited in the ballot box, and the 4-23 ballot cover shall be returned to the election officer. 4-24 (d) If an audiotape system is used, an election officer 4-25 shall give the voter the appropriate audiotape, the audiotape 4-26 player, and a set of headphones. If the voter does not understand 4-27 the instructions for reading and marking the ballot after listening 5-1 to the audiotape, the voter may request instructions from the 5-2 election officer. The voter must be able to stop the audiotape as 5-3 necessary to mark the ballot. After the voter has completed the 5-4 ballot, the ballot shall be deposited in the ballot box and the 5-5 ballot cover, audiotape, audiotape player, and headphones shall be 5-6 returned to the election officer. 5-7 (e) The alternative system described by this section does 5-8 not permit a voter with a physical disability to vote for a 5-9 write-in candidate without assistance. 5-10 Sec. 129.023. PUNCH-CARD OR LEVER MACHINE WITH AUDIOTAPE OR 5-11 TELEPHONE SYSTEM. (a) A political subdivision using a punch-card 5-12 or lever machine system may use either a telephone or audiotape to 5-13 instruct voters on the procedures for reading and marking ballots. 5-14 (b) If a telephone system is used, an election officer shall 5-15 make a telephone call to a designated telephone number. After the 5-16 person assigned to read the ballot in English or Spanish to the 5-17 voter answers the telephone, the election officer may disclose only 5-18 the precinct number to the reader. The election officer may not 5-19 disclose the name of the voter to the reader. The election officer 5-20 shall give the voter the telephone. The assigned reader shall 5-21 provide the voter with instructions for voting with a punch-card or 5-22 lever machine, as applicable. After the assigned reader confirms 5-23 that the voter understands the procedures, the reader shall read 5-24 the first race and candidates' names or propositions. After the 5-25 voter votes, the reader shall instruct the voter to move to the 5-26 next section on the ballot to vote on the next race or issue. After 5-27 the voter has cast the ballot, the voter shall return the telephone 6-1 to the election officer. 6-2 (c) If an audiotape system is used, an election officer 6-3 shall give the voter the appropriate audiotape, the audiotape 6-4 player, and a set of headphones. If the voter does not understand 6-5 the instructions for voting with a punch-card or lever machine 6-6 after listening to the audiotape to receive instructions, the voter 6-7 may request instructions from the election officer. The voter must 6-8 be able to stop the audiotape as necessary to mark the ballot. 6-9 After the voter has cast the ballot, the audiotape, audiotape 6-10 player, and headphones shall be returned to the election officer. 6-11 Sec. 129.024. REQUIREMENTS FOR USE OF TELEPHONES WITH VOTING 6-12 SYSTEMS. Telephones used with alternative voting systems described 6-13 by this subchapter must be equipped with headsets rather than 6-14 handsets to allow voters to have their hands free to hold the 6-15 ballot and template steady and accurately mark the ballot through 6-16 the template. 6-17 Sec. 129.025. LOCATION OF VOTING BOOTHS. Election officers 6-18 must locate voting booths using alternative voting systems 6-19 described by this subchapter in a manner that will ensure the 6-20 maximum possible privacy for voters and the minimum possible noise. 6-21 Sec. 129.026. VARIATIONS OF VOTING SYSTEMS APPROVED BY 6-22 SECRETARY OF STATE. The secretary of state may adopt procedures to 6-23 provide for the approval of minor variations of the alternative 6-24 voting systems described by this subchapter. 6-25 (Sections 129.027-129.040 reserved for expansion 6-26 SUBCHAPTER C. STANDARDS FOR VOTING SYSTEM ACCESSIBILITY 6-27 Sec. 129.041. DEFINITIONS. In this subchapter: 7-1 (1) "Federal accessibility requirements" means the 7-2 Americans with Disabilities Act accessibility guidelines as written 7-3 by the Access Board, a group formed by the Department of Justice. 7-4 (2) "Low vision" means visual acuity between 20/70 and 7-5 20/200 or 30 degree or greater visual-field loss. 7-6 (3) "Physical disability" includes no vision, low 7-7 vision, no hearing, low hearing, limited manual dexterity, limited 7-8 reach, limited strength, no mobility, low mobility, or any 7-9 combination of those disabilities, excluding a combination of no 7-10 hearing and no vision. 7-11 Sec. 129.042. STANDARDS FOR ACCESSIBILITY. (a) A political 7-12 subdivision shall make a voting system accessible to voters with 7-13 physical disabilities in accordance with the standards described by 7-14 this section. 7-15 (b) A voting system shall provide: 7-16 (1) a tactile-input or speech-input device, or both; 7-17 (2) a method for a voter to confirm any tactile or 7-18 audio input with audio output that uses synthetic or recorded human 7-19 speech that is reasonably phonetically accurate; and 7-20 (3) a means for a voter to change the voter's 7-21 selection before the voter casts the ballot. 7-22 (c) A voter without vision must be able to locate by touch 7-23 any operable controls on an input device of a voting system without 7-24 having to initiate any keys on the system. 7-25 (d) Any audio and non-audio access approaches on a voting 7-26 system must be able to work both separately and simultaneously. 7-27 (e) If a non-audio access approach is provided, a voting 8-1 system may not require color perception and shall use black text or 8-2 graphics, or both, on white background or white text or graphics, 8-3 or both, on black background, unless the secretary of state 8-4 approves another high-contrast color combination that does not 8-5 require color perception. 8-6 (f) A voting system that requires any visual perception must 8-7 allow the election officer who programs the system, before the 8-8 system is sent to the polling place, the capability to set the font 8-9 size to a level that can be read by voters with low vision. 8-10 (g) A voting system shall provide: 8-11 (1) audio information, including any audio output 8-12 using synthetic or recorded human speech or any auditory feedback 8-13 tones that are important for the use of the audio approach, through 8-14 at least one mode, including by handset or headset, in an increased 8-15 amplification; and 8-16 (2) incremental volume control with output 8-17 amplification up to a level of at least 97 dB SPL, with at least 8-18 one intermediate step of 89 dB SPL. 8-19 (h) For transmitted voice signals, a voting system shall 8-20 provide a gain adjustable up to a minimum of 20 dB with at least 8-21 one intermediate step of 12 dB of gain. 8-22 (i) If a voting system has the possibility of exceeding 120 8-23 dB SPL, a mechanism shall be included to reset the volume 8-24 automatically to a safe level after each use but not before. 8-25 (j) If sound cues and audible information are used on a 8-26 voting system, simultaneous corresponding visual cues and 8-27 information shall be included. 9-1 (k) If a non-audio approach is used in conjunction with an 9-2 audio counterpart on a voting system, any spoken text shall also be 9-3 presented on screen, except that any auditory confirmation of a 9-4 voter's selection may not be printed in text on the screen. 9-5 (l) All controls and operable mechanisms on a voting system 9-6 must be operable: 9-7 (1) with one hand, including with a closed fist; and 9-8 (2) without tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of 9-9 the wrist. 9-10 (m) The force required to operate or activate the controls 9-11 on a voting system may not be greater than five pounds per square 9-12 foot. 9-13 (n) If a forward approach by a person in a wheelchair to a 9-14 voting system is necessary, the maximum high-forward reach allowed 9-15 is 48 inches and the minimum low-forward reach allowed is 15 9-16 inches. If the high-forward reach is over an obstruction, reach and 9-17 clearances shall be provided as prescribed by the secretary of 9-18 state or otherwise in accordance with federal accessibility 9-19 standards as written at the time the system is certified for use in 9-20 this state. 9-21 (o) If a side or parallel approach by a person in a 9-22 wheelchair to a voting system is necessary, the maximum side reach 9-23 allowed is 54 inches and the low side reach may not be less than 9 9-24 inches above the floor. If the side reach is over an obstruction, 9-25 reach and clearances shall be provided as prescribed by the 9-26 secretary of state or otherwise in accordance with federal 9-27 accessibility standards as written at the time the system is 10-1 certified for use in this state. 10-2 (p) The highest operable part of controls, dispensers, 10-3 receptacles, and other operable equipment on a voting system shall 10-4 be placed within at least one of the reach ranges prescribed by 10-5 Subsection (n) or (o). 10-6 (q) A voting system may be considered accessible and in 10-7 compliance with state law without allowing voters with a 10-8 combination of no hearing and no vision to cast an independent and 10-9 secret ballot. 10-10 SECTION 2. This Act takes effect September 1, 2001.