LEGISLATIVE BUDGET BOARD Austin, Texas FISCAL NOTE, 77th Regular Session February 12, 2001 TO: Honorable John T. Smithee, Chair, House Committee on Insurance FROM: John Keel, Director, Legislative Budget Board IN RE: HB765 by Chavez (Relating to motor vehicle insurance coverage requirements for operation of certain motor vehicles; providing a penalty.), As Introduced ************************************************************************** * Estimated Two-year Net Impact to General Revenue Related Funds for * * HB765, As Introduced: negative impact of $(26,014,593) through * * the biennium ending August 31, 2003. * * * * The bill would make no appropriation but could provide the legal * * basis for an appropriation of funds to implement the provisions of * * the bill. * ************************************************************************** General Revenue-Related Funds, Five-Year Impact: **************************************************** * Fiscal Year Probable Net Positive/(Negative) * * Impact to General Revenue Related * * Funds * * 2002 $(16,092,604) * * 2003 (9,921,989) * * 2004 (9,667,935) * * 2005 (9,957,534) * * 2006 (9,945,213) * **************************************************** All Funds, Five-Year Impact: *********************************************************************** *Fiscal Probable Probable Probable Probable Change in * * Year Revenue Savings/ Savings/ Revenue Number of * * Gain/(Loss) (Cost) from (Cost) from Gain/(Loss) State * * from General Texas from Texas Employees * * General Revenue Department Department from FY 2001 * * Revenue Fund of of * * Fund 0001 Insurance Insurance * * 0001 Operating Operating * * Fund Fund * * Account/ Account/ * * GR- GR- * * Dedicated Dedicated * * 0036 0036 * * 2002 $(267,852) $267,852 83.0 * * $(6,200,030)$(9,892,574) * * 2003 (6,200,030) (3,721,959) (245,677) 245,677 83.0 * * 2004 (6,200,030) (3,467,905) (245,677) 245,677 83.0 * * 2005 (6,200,030) (3,757,504) (245,677) 245,677 83.0 * * 2006 (6,200,030) (3,745,183) (245,677) 245,677 83.0 * *********************************************************************** Technology Impact It is estimated that the technology impact would be $1,871,375 for fiscal year 2002 and $332,369 for each year thereafter. Fiscal Analysis The bill amends Chapter 5 of the Insurance Code and adds Chapter 28. The bill adopts a new regulatory process for mandatory auto liability insurance including adoption by the Texas Department of Insurance of a passenger vehicle liability insurance policy with fixed rates and guaranteed issue. According to the Department of Public Safety (DPS), the bill would require the creation of a database for passenger vehicle liability insurance policies by having all companies that write such policies in Texas provide information to DPS regarding the issuance of policies, the termination of policies, and the claims made under those policies. The bill prescribes conditions, time limits, and procedures for the suspension (including hearing and appeal) of drivers' licenses for persons failing to comply with the new statutes. The bill would take effect September 1, 2001. Methodology The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) estimates that it would require four additional Full-time Equivalent (FTE) positions to implement the provisions of the bill. Passage of the bill would result in one rate hearing by TDI per year to set benchmark rates for passenger vehicle liability. It is anticipated that TDI would be involved in four more contested case hearings involving individual rate filing, form filings, market conduct, solvency or other regulatory matters relating to rates. This would require TDI to hire expert witnesses for the rate hearing and for consultation during the hearing process. It is assumed that TDI would adjust its fees and/or rate on assessments to cover the agency's costs from Fund 36. Department of Public Safety (DPS) accident records indicate that approximately 18.65 percent of the 14 million licensed drivers in Texas are uninsured. Therefore, it is estimated that the DPS would be required to take action against 2.6 million licensees. Those drivers would come to the attention of DPS when required to purchase liability insurance in order to renew a driver's license. Texas drivers' licenses are issued for 6 years. Thus it is estimated that one-sixth of the estimated 2.6 million uninsured drivers would renew a license each year, resulting in 437,000 suspension notices annually that the DPS Driver Improvement Bureau (DIB) would have to process. DPS would also need additional FTEs in its (1) Safety Responsibility Bureau to receive and evaluate 437,000 policies annually as part of the license suspension clearance procedure; (2) Driver Records Bureau to provide data entry and microfilming for the 437,000 actions; and (3) Customer Service Bureau to receive 36,440 additional telephone calls each year from affected licensees. DPS estimates the bill would result in 44,000 additional administrative hearings per year. Including case preparation, review of files to return to DIB, and actual time for hearings, the DPS would need additional Examiners. DPS would need additional personnel for processing paperwork setting cases for hearings. It is estimated that the total number of additional FTEs that DPS would need to implement the bill is 79. New programming would be needed to create a database to store information and DPS would incur contract programming costs at an estimated $950,400. An additional $920,975 would be needed for equipment and computer hardware and software. These costs would occur in fiscal year 2002 only. In addition, in FY 2000 DPS collected approximately $6.2 million in reinstatement fees in compliance with the Safety Responsibility Act. DPS expects that with the exclusion of "passenger vehicles" from Safety Responsibility sanctions, there would no longer be an incentive for operators of "passenger vehicles" to comply and pay associated fees, resulting in an estimated loss of $6.2 million per year. Local Government Impact Reclassifying the offense of Failure to Maintain Liability Insurance from a Class C misdemeanor to a Class A, and subsequent violations of the same offense to a State Jail Felony would result in shifting the cases from municipal and justice of the peace (JP) courts to county courts at law and district courts. Additionally, instead of writing a citation, a Class A misdemeanor and a State Jail Felony offense require an arrest. Municipal and JP courts would experience a revenue loss because of the loss of fines, fees, and court costs that are generated by cases. Some of the revenue loss would be offset by a savings created by reduced workload. It is anticipated that the cost of arresting and detaining defendants would reduce the savings. Conversely, county courts at law and district courts would gain revenue from fines, fees, and court costs received that would offset the increase in cases heard. The counties could also incur some additional costs from confining offenders. Amounts of gains, losses, costs, and savings would vary and be largely dependent on the number of cases as well as the level of fines levied and successfully collected. Source Agencies: 302 Office of the Attorney General, 405 Texas Department of Public Safety, 454 Texas Department of Insurance LBB Staff: JK, JO, DB, DE, DG