By: Shapiro, Lucio  S.B. No. 2083
         (In the Senate - Filed March 13, 2009; March 31, 2009, read
  first time and referred to Committee on Education; May 1, 2009,
  reported adversely, with favorable Committee Substitute by the
  following vote:  Yeas 6, Nays 0; May 1, 2009, sent to printer.)
 
  COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR S.B. No. 2083 By:  Shapiro
 
 
A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
 
AN ACT
 
  relating to outcome measurement and reporting concerning school
  district and open-enrollment charter school special education
  programs and grants to public school entities that perform well on
  the measurements.
         BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:
         SECTION 1.  Subchapter A, Chapter 29, Education Code, is
  amended by adding Sections 29.022 through 29.030 to read as
  follows:
         Sec. 29.022.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SURVEYS:  DEVELOPMENT AND
  DESIGN OF DATA COLLECTION PLATFORM AND FLOWCHART. (a)  The agency
  shall develop an Internet-based data collection platform that, in
  accordance with Section 29.023:
               (1)  each school district and open-enrollment charter
  school shall use to coordinate the completion of surveys concerning
  each student participating in the district's or school's special
  education program; and
               (2)  the agency shall use to survey:
                     (A)  each student who has participated in a school
  district's or open-enrollment charter school's special education
  program and has graduated from a district or school high school or
  the parent of or person standing in parental relation to such a
  student; and
                     (B)  each student who has withdrawn from a school
  district's or open-enrollment charter school's special education
  program or the parent of or person standing in parental relation to
  such a student.
         (b)  The agency shall develop a survey question flowchart for
  each survey required under Subsection (a) so that each survey is
  designed to be completed in 15 minutes or less. In developing each
  survey flowchart, the agency shall:
               (1)  to the extent practicable, consult with one or
  more national organizations with expertise in postsecondary
  education, employment, or life skills for persons with
  disabilities; and
               (2)  consult with:
                     (A)  parents of students eligible under Section
  29.003 to participate in a district or school special education
  program;
                     (B)  teachers who teach special education
  students;
                     (C)  school administrators, including
  superintendents, principals, and special education administrators;
                     (D)  other persons with significant interest or
  expertise in special education, including:
                           (i)  one person appointed by the presiding
  officer of the standing committee in the senate with primary
  jurisdiction over public education; and
                           (ii)  one person appointed by the presiding
  officer of the standing committee in the house of representatives
  with primary jurisdiction over public education; and
                     (E)  persons who perform research at institutions
  of higher education and have expertise concerning the design of
  statistically valid, accurate, and objective data collection
  methods.
         (c)  A survey under this section shall be, as applicable:
               (1)  designed to determine, among other information,
  whether the person completing the survey:
                     (A)  perceives that the student is appropriately
  progressing toward each of the following:
                           (i)  attending postsecondary education;
                           (ii)  living independently; and
                           (iii)  being employed;
                     (B)  has, as appropriate based on the person
  completing the survey, an understanding of the educational rights
  under federal law of a student with a disability; and
                     (C)  is satisfied with admission, review, and
  dismissal committee meetings, conflict resolution procedures and
  outcomes, the level of due process provided in the special
  education program, the amount and type of teacher training, teacher
  retention, and, as applicable, the availability of student and
  parent contact information;
               (2)  disaggregated by type of disability and by
  preschool, including early childhood, or primary or secondary
  school grade-level or age of the student; and
               (3)  designed, to the extent practicable, through the
  use of multiple languages or other accommodations determined by the
  agency, to be completed without assistance from school district
  personnel.
         (d)  A survey under Subsection (a)(2)(A) shall be designed to
  determine, among other information, whether the student is:
               (1)  attending a postsecondary educational institution
  and, if so, the type of institution;
               (2)  living independently; and
               (3)  employed and, if so, the type of employment.
         (e)  A survey under Subsection (a)(2)(B) shall be designed to
  determine, among other information, the reason for the student's
  withdrawal from the special education program, such as a change of
  residence or a decision to educate the student at home or in a
  private setting.
         Sec. 29.023.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SURVEYS:  ADMINISTRATION AND
  RESULTS.  (a)  The agency shall conduct the surveys described by
  Section 29.022 as follows:
               (1)  for a survey under Section 29.022(a)(1), once
  during each of the following periods during which a student is
  enrolled in a special education program:
                     (A)  during the period the student is at least
  three years of age and younger than six years of age;
                     (B)  during the period the student is at least six
  years of age and younger than 11 years of age;
                     (C)  during the period the student is at least 11
  years of age and younger than 15 years of age; and
                     (D)  during the period the student is at least 15
  years of age and younger than 22 years of age;
               (2)  for a survey under Section 29.022(a)(2)(A),
  approximately 12 months and again approximately 60 months after the
  date of a student's graduation; and
               (3)  for a survey under Section 29.022(a)(2)(B), as
  soon as practicable after the student withdraws from the district's
  or school's special education program.
         (b)  For a survey under Section 29.022(a)(1), a school
  district or open-enrollment charter school shall coordinate the
  completion of separate surveys of:
               (1)  the parent of or person standing in parental
  relation to a student participating in the district's or school's
  special education program;
               (2)  the special education teacher of the student or,
  if the student is in general education classes only, a teacher of
  the student in a course in the foundation curriculum under Section
  28.002(a)(1);
               (3)  if applicable, the primary paraprofessional
  working with the student; and
               (4)  if the student participates in admission, review,
  and dismissal committee meetings, the student.
         (c)  For a survey under Section 29.022(a)(2)(A) or (B), the
  agency shall complete a survey of:
               (1)  the parent of or person standing in parental
  relation to each student who has participated in the district's or
  school's special education program; or
               (2)  to the extent practicable, each student.
         (d)  The agency shall develop a statewide Internet-based
  information reporting system that the agency posts on the agency's
  Internet website and that provides current and historical special
  education snapshot results for each school district, campus, and
  open-enrollment charter school that are disaggregated by students'
  type of disability and by students' preschool or grade-level range
  or age. In addition, the information system must provide relative
  performance statistics for districts, campuses, and schools among,
  as determined by the agency, peer institutions in this state and, if
  practicable, nationally, based on:
               (1)  outcomes by students and interim outcome progress
  indicators, as indicated by the surveys conducted under this
  section; and
               (2)  other indicators established by law and rules, as
  determined appropriate by the agency, including the indicator under
  Section 39.051(b)(12) and the districts', campuses', or schools'
  current special education compliance status with the agency.
         Sec. 29.024.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SNAPSHOT.  (a)  The agency
  shall develop and each school district or open-enrollment charter
  school shall provide to the parent of or person standing in parental
  relation to each student participating in the district's or
  school's special education program, once each school year before
  the first admission, review, and dismissal committee meeting, a
  special education snapshot. The snapshot must be designed to be
  easily understood by parents and persons standing in parental
  relation and must indicate the discrete and relative performance,
  disaggregated by students' type of disability and by students' 
  preschool or grade-level range or age, of the district and campus or
  school on:
               (1)  issues surveyed under Sections 29.022 and 29.023;
  and
               (2)  other indicators established by law and rules, as
  determined appropriate by the agency, including the indicator under
  Section 39.051(b)(12) and the district's and campus's or school's
  current special education compliance status with the agency.
         (b)  In a case in which disaggregation of data as reported in
  the snapshot would, because of the survey sample size, create a
  violation under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act of
  1974 (20 U.S.C. Section 1232g), the agency shall increase the
  grouping sample size used for snapshot purposes by adding age
  ranges or historical results to the extent necessary to comply with
  that law.
         (c)  In a case in which disaggregation of data as reported in
  the snapshot would, because of the small survey sample size, create
  among peers relative performance statistics that are not
  statistically sound, the agency shall increase the grouping sample
  size used for snapshot purposes by adding age ranges or historical
  results to create statistically valid relative performance
  statistics.  The discrete survey results shall be disaggregated to
  the fullest extent possible.
         Sec. 29.025.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SUCCESS GRANTS FOR PUBLIC
  SCHOOLS.  (a)  To the extent funds are available, the agency shall
  award grants to school districts, campuses, and open-enrollment
  charter schools with high relative performance statistics for
  students with a specific disability, as indicated by the snapshot
  information under Section 29.023(d).
         (b)  The commissioner shall by rule adopt criteria on which
  to base a grant award under this section, for grouping districts,
  campuses, and open-enrollment charter schools based on the number
  of students enrolled in the program and other factors, and for
  distinguishing among districts, campuses, and schools and among
  types of disabilities. The rule must require a district, campus, or
  school, before receiving an award, to provide a detailed, written
  description on a form adopted by the commissioner under Subsection
  (d) of the award-winning special education program, especially the
  aspects of the program that have led to student success. The agency
  shall post each description on the agency's Internet website and
  shall provide copies to school districts, open-enrollment charter
  schools, and regional education service centers and, on request, to
  members of the public.
         (c)  The total amount of grant awards under this section may
  not exceed $2 million per year.
         (d)  The commissioner by rule shall adopt a written
  description form for purposes of Subsection (b). To enable another
  school district, campus, or open-enrollment charter school to
  understand and implement a special education program similar to the
  program for which a grant has been awarded under this section, the
  form must require a program description that describes, among any
  other aspects of the program as determined by the commissioner:
               (1)  program methodologies and practices;
               (2)  lessons learned from program implementation;
               (3)  staff qualification requirements;
               (4)  staff-to-student ratios across placements;
               (5)  staff training, development, and retention
  strategies, including methods and measures used to support staff;
               (6)  unique, creative, or advanced program elements;
               (7)  significant challenges faced and any solutions
  found; and
               (8)  approximate budget information, with major
  program expenditures specified.
         Sec. 29.026.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SURVEYS:  ANALYSIS.  
  (a)  The agency shall periodically perform a statistical analysis
  to isolate particular results of surveys conducted under Sections
  29.022 and 29.023 that predict student success.
         (b)  The agency shall post the results of the analysis under
  Subsection (a), with any personally identifiable student
  information removed, on the agency's Internet website and shall
  provide copies of the results to school districts, open-enrollment
  charter schools, and regional education service centers and, on
  request, to members of the public. In addition, on request, the
  agency shall make the data on which the analysis is based available,
  with any personally identifiable student information removed, to
  persons providing research, members of special education advocacy
  groups, and other interested persons.  The agency may require a
  person to whom that data is made available to execute a
  nondisclosure agreement as the agency determines necessary to
  ensure that the person releases to the public only summary results
  of the person's research and does not release to the public
  information or a form of information that reveals personally
  identifiable student information.
         Sec. 29.027.  PARENT AND TEACHER CONTACT INFORMATION.  The
  agency shall provide a method during the survey by which parents and
  teachers of students who have participated in a special education
  program and completed a survey under Section 29.023 may, through
  the agency, provide contact information to persons who provide
  training, advocacy, or other targeted assistance in creating
  academic success for students in special education programs.
         Sec. 29.028.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SURVEYS:  CONFIDENTIALITY OF
  INFORMATION.  (a)  Notwithstanding any other provision of this
  subchapter, the results of a special education survey under this
  subchapter are not considered public information under Chapter 552,
  Government Code.
         (b)  The agency shall take measures to ensure
  confidentiality of individual survey results so that parents of or
  persons standing in parental relation to students of school
  districts or open-enrollment charter schools and employees of the
  districts or schools are not subject to consequences as a result of
  their answers to survey questions.
         Sec. 29.029.  RULES.  The commissioner shall adopt rules as
  necessary to administer Sections 29.022-29.028.
         Sec. 29.030.  SPECIAL EDUCATION SURVEYS:  IMPLEMENTATION
  PLAN.  (a)  Not later than March 1, 2010, the agency shall submit to
  the governor, lieutenant governor, speaker of the house of
  representatives, and presiding officer of the standing committee of
  each house of the legislature with primary jurisdiction over public
  education a plan for implementing the requirements of Sections
  29.022-29.028.
         (b)  The implementation plan must include the
  confidentiality measures required by Section 29.028(b).
         (c)  Not later than September 1, 2010, school districts and
  open-enrollment charter schools shall begin conducting surveys
  under Sections 29.022 and 29.023. This section expires September
  30, 2010.
         SECTION 2.  This Act takes effect immediately if it receives
  a vote of two-thirds of all the members elected to each house, as
  provided by Section 39, Article III, Texas Constitution.  If this
  Act does not receive the vote necessary for immediate effect, this
  Act takes effect September 1, 2009.
 
  * * * * *