BILL ANALYSIS |
C.S.H.B. 2913 |
By: Thompson, Senfronia |
Judiciary & Civil Jurisprudence |
Committee Report (Substituted) |
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE
Interested parties, such as the Real Estate, Probate, and Trust Law Section of the State Bar of Texas, have noted several issues in Property Code and Tax Code provisions relating to trusts that need to be more fully addressed and clarified. C.S.H.B. 2913 seeks to address those issues.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
RULEMAKING AUTHORITY
It is the committee's opinion that this bill does not expressly grant any additional rulemaking authority to a state officer, department, agency, or institution.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
ANALYSIS
C.S.H.B. 2913 amends the Property Code to clarify that the definition of "property," for purposes of the Texas Trust Code, includes property held in any digital or electronic medium. The bill establishes that a settlor, or a person who creates a trust or contributes property to a trustee of a trust, is not considered a beneficiary of a trust solely because the settlor's interest in the trust was created by the exercise of a power of appointment by a third party. The bill establishes that for the purposes of statutory provisions governing spendthrift trusts, property contributed to certain irrevocable inter vivos marital trusts, irrevocable inter vivos trusts for the settlor's spouse, or irrevocable trusts for the benefit of a person is not considered to have been contributed by the settlor. The bill prohibits a person who would otherwise be treated as a settlor or a deemed settlor of such trusts from being treated as a settlor. The bill establishes that for such purposes, a person is a beneficiary whether named a beneficiary under the initial trust instrument or through the exercise of a limited or general power of appointment by that person's spouse or another person.
C.S.H.B. 2913 authorizes an authorized trustee who has the full discretion to distribute the principal of a trust to distribute all or part of that trust's principal in favor of a trustee of a second trust for the benefit of one or more current beneficiaries of the first trust who are eligible to receive income or principal from the trust and for the benefit of one or more successor or presumptive remainder beneficiaries of the first trust who are eligible to receive income or principal from the trust. The bill authorizes the authorized trustee, in connection with the exercise of such a power of distribution, to grant a power of appointment, including a currently exercisable power of appointment, in the second trust to one or more of the first trust's current beneficiaries who, at the time the power of appointment is granted, is eligible to receive the principal outright under the terms of the first trust. The bill authorizes the class of permissible appointees in whose favor the beneficiary may appoint under that power to be broader or different than the current, successor, and presumptive remainder beneficiaries of the first trust. The bill authorizes the beneficiaries of the second trust, if the beneficiaries of the first trust are described as a class of persons, to include one or more persons who become members of that class after the distribution to the second trust. The bill requires the authorized trustee to exercise such a distribution power in good faith, in accordance with the terms and purposes of the trust, and in the interests of the beneficiaries.
C.S.H.B. 2913 authorizes an authorized trustee who has limited discretion to distribute the principal of a trust to distribute all or part of the principal of that trust in favor of a trustee of a second trust in the manner described by the bill's provisions. The bill requires the current beneficiaries of the second trust to be the same as the current beneficiaries of the first trust and requires the successor and presumptive remainder beneficiaries of the second trust to be the same as the successor and presumptive remainder beneficiaries of the first trust. The bill requires the second trust to include the same language authorizing the trustee to distribute the income or principal of the trust that was included in the first trust. The bill requires the beneficiaries of the second trust, if the beneficiaries of the first trust are described as a class of persons, to include all persons who become members of that class after the distribution to the second trust. The bill requires the second trust, if the first trust grants a power of appointment to a beneficiary of the trust, to grant the power of appointment to the beneficiary in the second trust and requires the class of permissible appointees under that power to be the same as the class of permissible appointees under the power granted by the first trust. The bill requires the authorized trustee to exercise such a distribution power in good faith, in accordance with the terms and purposes of the trust, and in the interests of the beneficiaries.
C.S.H.B. 2913 authorizes an authorized trustee to exercise a power of distribution to a second trust without the consent of the settlor or beneficiaries of the first trust and without court approval if the trustee provides to all of the current beneficiaries and presumptive remainder beneficiaries written notice of the trustee's decision to exercise the power. The bill establishes that, for the purpose of determining who is a current beneficiary or presumptive remainder beneficiary entitled to the notice, a beneficiary is determined as of the date the notice is sent. The bill specifies that a beneficiary includes a person entitled to receive property under the terms of the first trust. The bill requires an authorized trustee to also give written notice of the trustee's decision to the attorney general if a charity is entitled to notice, if a charity so entitled no longer exists, or if the trustee is authorized to distribute trust assets to one or more charities or for charitable purposes but no such charities are named in the trust instruments or as beneficiaries for that purpose. The bill requires an authorized trustee, if a beneficiary has a court-appointed guardian or conservator, to give the required notice to that guardian or conservator or, if the beneficiary is a minor for whom no guardian or conservator has been appointed, to a parent of the minor. The bill specifies that a trustee is not required to provide notice to a beneficiary who is known to the trustee and cannot be located by the trustee after reasonable diligence, who is not known to the trustee, who waives the requirement of the notice, or who is a descendent of a beneficiary to whom the trustee has given notice if the beneficiary and the beneficiary's ancestor have similar interests in the trust and no apparent conflict of interest exists between them. The bill sets out the required content of the notice.
C.S.H.B. 2913 requires a distribution to a second trust by an authorized trustee to be made by a written instrument that is signed and acknowledged by the authorized trustee and filed with the records of the first and second trusts. The bill establishes that a reference to the governing instrument or terms of the governing instrument of a trust includes the terms of a second trust to which that trust's principal was distributed.
C.S.H.B. 2913 establishes that the settlor of a first trust is considered to be the settlor of a second trust and provides that if a settlor of a first trust is not also the settlor of a second trust into which principal of that first trust is distributed, the settlor of the first trust is considered the settlor of the portion of the second trust distributed to the second trust from that first trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 authorizes an authorized trustee to petition a court to order a distribution of trust principal into a second trust. The bill authorizes an authorized trustee or beneficiary to petition a court to approve, modify, or deny the exercise of the trustee's power to make a distribution of trust principal to a second trust if the trustee receives a written objection to the distribution from a beneficiary before the proposed effective date of the distribution specified in the notice provided to the beneficiary. The bill prohibits an authorized trustee from making a distribution to a second trust without petitioning a court to approve or modify the exercise of the trustee's power to make such a distribution if the trustee receives a written objection to the distribution from the attorney general not later than the 30th day after the date notice of the distribution was received by the attorney general. The bill provides that the trustee has the burden of proving that the proposed distribution furthers the purposes of the trust, is in accordance with the terms of the trust, and is in the interests of the beneficiaries, and authorizes the trustee to present the trustee's reasons for supporting or opposing a proposed distribution in the judicial proceeding.
C.S.H.B. 2913 establishes that, if an authorized trustee has full discretion to distribute the principal of a trust and another trustee has limited discretion to distribute principal under the trust instrument, the authorized trustee with full discretion is authorized to exercise the power to distribute the trust's principal into a second trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 establishes that, to the extent the authorized trustee does not provide otherwise, the distribution of all of the principal of a first trust to a second trust includes subsequently discovered assets otherwise belonging to the first trust and principal paid to or acquired by the first trust after the distribution of the first trust's principal to the second trust. The bill also establishes that, to the extent the authorized trustee does not provide otherwise, the distribution of part of the principal of a first trust to a second trust does not include subsequently discovered assets belonging to the first trust or principal paid to or acquired by the first trust after the distribution of principal from the first trust to the second trust, and those assets or that principal remain the assets or principal of the first trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 prohibits the bill's provisions relating to the distribution of trust principal in a second trust from being construed to limit the power of an authorized trustee to distribute property in further trust under the terms of the governing instrument of a trust, other law, or a court order. The bill authorizes an authorized trustee to exercise the power to distribute principal to a second trust regardless of whether there is a current need to distribute principal under the terms of the first trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 establishes that the bill's provisions relating to the distribution of trust principal in a second trust do not create or imply a duty for an authorized trustee to exercise a power to distribute principal and prohibits the inference of impropriety as a result of the trustee not exercising such a power of distribution. The bill establishes that an authorized trustee does not have a duty to inform beneficiaries about the availability of such authority or a duty to review the trust to determine whether any action should be taken under the bill's provisions relating to second trusts.
C.S.H.B. 2913 prohibits an authorized trustee from exercising a power to distribute principal of a trust to a second trust otherwise provided under the bill's provisions if the distribution is expressly prohibited by the terms of the governing instrument of the trust. The bill establishes that a general prohibition of the amendment or revocation of a trust or a provision that constitutes a spendthrift clause does not preclude the exercise of a power to distribute principal of a trust into a second trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 prohibits an authorized trustee from exercising a power to distribute the principal of a trust into a second trust to reduce, limit, or modify specified current, vested rights of a beneficiary; to materially impair the rights of any beneficiary of the trust; to materially limit a trustee's fiduciary duty under the trust or as described by specified statutory provisions; to decrease or indemnify against a trustee's liability or exonerate a trustee from liability for failure to exercise reasonable care, diligence, and prudence; to eliminate a provision granting another person the right to remove or replace the authorized trustee exercising such power; or to reduce, limit, or modify in the second trust a perpetuities provision included in the first trust, unless expressly permitted by the terms of the first trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 prohibits the authorized trustee from distributing the principal of a trust in a second trust in a manner that would prevent a contribution to that trust from qualifying for or that would reduce the exclusion, deduction, or other federal tax benefit that was originally claimed for that contribution, including certain specified exclusions, deductions, and benefits. The bill authorizes an authorized trustee to distribute the principal of a first trust to a second trust regardless of whether the settlor is treated as the owner of either or both trusts under federal law. The bill prohibits an authorized trustee, if S corporation stock is held in trust, from distributing all or part of that stock to a second trust that is not a permitted shareholder under federal law. The bill prohibits an authorized trustee, if an interest in property that is subject to the minimum distribution rules of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is held in trust, from distributing the trust's interest in the property to a second trust if the distribution would shorten the minimum distribution period applicable to the property.
C.S.H.B. 2913 prohibits an authorized trustee from exercising a power to distribute trust principal in a second trust solely to change trust provisions regarding the determination of the compensation of any trustee unless a court, on application of the trustee, directs otherwise, but authorizes an authorized trustee to bring the trustee's compensation into conformance with reasonable limits authorized by state law in connection with the exercise of a power to distribute trust principal in a second trust for another valid and reasonable purpose. The bill authorizes the compensation payable to an authorized trustee of the first trust to continue to be paid to the trustee of the second trust during the term of the second trust and to be determined in the same manner as the compensation would have been determined in the first trust. The bill prohibits an authorized trustee from receiving a commission or other compensation for the distribution of a particular asset from a first trust to a second trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 makes a statutory provision relating to the exercise of power by a person, other than a settlor, who is a beneficiary and trustee of a trust that confers on the trustee a power to make discretionary distributions to or for the trustee's personal benefit applicable to a person who is a beneficiary and a trustee affiliate of a trust and a person who is a beneficiary and discretionary power holder of a trust.
C.S.H.B. 2913 establishes the option for an action concerning a trust that has multiple noncorporate trustees to be brought in a Texas county in which the trustees maintain a principal office or, if the trustees do not maintain a principal office in Texas, in the county in which any trustee resides or has resided at any time during the four-year period preceding the date the action is filed as an alternative to bringing the action in the county in which the situs of administration of the trust is maintained at any time during the four-year period preceding the date the action is filed. The bill clarifies that an action concerning a trust that has one or more corporate trustees may be brought in the county in which any corporate trustee maintains its principal office in Texas.
C.S.H.B. 2913 amends the Tax Code, for the purposes of the residence homestead tax exemption, to redefine "residence homestead," with respect to property owned through a beneficial interest in a qualifying trust, to include property occupied as a principal residence by a beneficiary of the trust who qualifies for the exemption. The bill redefines "trustor" to mean a person who transfers an interest in real or personal property to a qualifying trust, whether during the person's lifetime or at death, or the person's spouse, rather than a person who transfers an interest in residential property to a qualifying trust, whether by deed or by will, or the person's spouse. The bill redefines "qualifying trust" to include trusts in which an instrument transferring property to the trust or any other agreement that is binding on the trustee provides that the trustor of the trust or a beneficiary of the trust has the right to use and occupy as the trustor's or beneficiary's principal residence rent free, subject to certain conditions. The bill removes the condition that a qualifying trust providing such a right to a beneficiary be created by court order and removes the condition that the instrument of title under which a qualifying trust acquires property be executed by the trustor or the personal representative of the trustor if the trust is not created by court order.
C.S.H.B. 2913 imposes the motor vehicle gift tax on a person who receives a motor vehicle from a trust subject to the Texas Trust Code that was or is revocable or jointly revocable by the following: by a decedent or by a decedent and the decedent's spouse; by the person receiving the motor vehicle or by the recipient and the recipient's spouse; or by the transferor of the motor vehicle or by the transferor and the transferor's spouse.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
EFFECTIVE DATE
September 1, 2013.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
COMPARISON OF ORIGINAL AND SUBSTITUTE
While C.S.H.B. 2913 may differ from the original in minor or nonsubstantive ways, the following comparison is organized and highlighted in a manner that indicates the substantial differences between the introduced and committee substitute versions of the bill.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|