|
|
|
A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
|
|
AN ACT
|
|
relating to child custody evaluations and adoption evaluations |
|
conducted and testimony provided in certain suits affecting the |
|
parent-child relationship; providing penalties; authorizing fees. |
|
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: |
|
ARTICLE 1. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION |
|
SECTION 1.01. Chapter 107, Family Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subchapter E to read as follows: |
|
SUBCHAPTER E. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION |
|
Sec. 107.101. DEFINITIONS. (a) In this subchapter: |
|
(1) "Child custody evaluation" means an evaluative |
|
process ordered by a court in a suit through which information, |
|
opinions, recommendations, and answers to specific questions asked |
|
by the court are: |
|
(A) made regarding: |
|
(i) the conservatorship of a child, |
|
including the terms and conditions of the conservatorship; |
|
(ii) the possession of or access to a child, |
|
including the terms and conditions of possession or access; |
|
(iii) recommendations for therapeutic |
|
services; or |
|
(iv) any other issue affecting the best |
|
interest of a child; and |
|
(B) provided to: |
|
(i) the court; |
|
(ii) the parties to the suit; |
|
(iii) the parties' attorneys; and |
|
(iv) any other person appointed under this |
|
chapter by the court in the suit. |
|
(2) "Child custody evaluator" means a person who |
|
conducts a child custody evaluation under this subchapter. The term |
|
includes a private child custody evaluator. |
|
(3) "Department" means the Department of Family and |
|
Protective Services. |
|
(4) "Private child custody evaluator" means a person |
|
conducting a child custody evaluation who is not conducting the |
|
evaluation as an employee of or contractor with a domestic |
|
relations office. |
|
(5) "Supervision" means the regular review of and |
|
consultation with a person. Supervision does not require the |
|
constant physical presence of the person providing supervision. |
|
(b) For purposes of this subchapter, a child custody |
|
evaluation does not include services provided in accordance with |
|
the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children adopted under |
|
Subchapter B, Chapter 162, or an evaluation conducted in accordance |
|
with Section 262.114 by an employee of or contractor with the |
|
department. |
|
Sec. 107.102. ORDER FOR CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION. (a) The |
|
court may order in a suit the preparation of a child custody |
|
evaluation concerning: |
|
(1) a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(2) a party to the suit; |
|
(3) the home of any person requesting conservatorship |
|
of, possession of, or access to a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
or |
|
(4) any issue or question relating to the suit and |
|
requested by the court or agreed to by the parties to the suit |
|
before or during the evaluation process. |
|
(b) An order for a child custody evaluation must include: |
|
(1) the name of each person who will conduct the |
|
evaluation; |
|
(2) the purpose of the evaluation; and |
|
(3) the specific issues or questions to be addressed |
|
in the evaluation. |
|
(c) Except as provided by Section 107.105, each person who |
|
conducts a child custody evaluation must be qualified under Section |
|
107.104. |
|
(d) The department may not conduct a child custody |
|
evaluation. |
|
Sec. 107.103. REQUIREMENTS OF CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION. |
|
(a) A child custody evaluator shall: |
|
(1) review relevant information obtained from |
|
collateral sources; |
|
(2) review relevant school records; |
|
(3) review relevant physical and mental health records |
|
of each party to the suit and each child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(4) review relevant records of the department, |
|
including those maintained as part of the central registry |
|
established under Section 261.002, and law enforcement agencies |
|
relating to each child who is at issue in the suit, each party to the |
|
suit, and each person who lives with a party to the suit; |
|
(5) interview each adult living in the home that is the |
|
subject of the evaluation, if applicable; |
|
(6) interview, in a developmentally appropriate |
|
manner, each child who is at issue in the suit and who is at least |
|
four years old; |
|
(7) observe each child who is at issue in the suit, |
|
regardless of the age of the child; |
|
(8) observe each party to the suit with each child at |
|
issue in the suit, including, as appropriate, during supervised |
|
visitation, unless contact between a party and a child is |
|
prohibited by court order or the person conducting the evaluation |
|
has good cause for not making the observation and states the good |
|
cause in writing provided to the parties to the suit before the |
|
completion of the evaluation; |
|
(9) assess the relationship between each child at |
|
issue in the suit and each party seeking possession of or access to |
|
the child, if applicable; and |
|
(10) complete any other tasks ordered by the court or |
|
agreed to by the parties. |
|
(b) In addition to the requirements of a child custody |
|
evaluation in Subsection (a), a court issuing an order for an |
|
evaluation may order the child custody evaluator to: |
|
(1) visit the home of a party to the suit; |
|
(2) conduct a joint interview of the parties to the |
|
suit; |
|
(3) observe a child who is at issue in the suit with |
|
each adult who lives in the home that is the subject of the |
|
evaluation; |
|
(4) interview or observe a child who is not at issue in |
|
the suit but who lives on a full-time or part-time basis in the home |
|
that is the subject of the evaluation; |
|
(5) conduct valid and reliable psychological testing; |
|
or |
|
(6) review any other information that the court |
|
determines is relevant. |
|
Sec. 107.104. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATOR: MINIMUM |
|
QUALIFICATIONS. (a) In this section: |
|
(1) "Full-time experience" means a period during which |
|
a person works at least 30 hours per week. |
|
(2) "Human services field of study" means a field of |
|
study designed to prepare a person in the disciplined application |
|
of counseling, family therapy, psychology, or social work values, |
|
principles, and methods. |
|
(b) To be qualified to conduct a child custody evaluation, a |
|
person must: |
|
(1) have at least a master's degree from an accredited |
|
college or university in a human services field of study and a |
|
license to practice in this state as a social worker, professional |
|
counselor, marriage and family therapist, or psychologist and: |
|
(A) after completing the degree required under |
|
this subdivision, have two years of full-time experience or |
|
equivalent part-time experience under professional supervision |
|
during which the person performed functions involving the |
|
evaluation of physical, intellectual, social, and psychological |
|
functioning and needs and the potential of the social and physical |
|
environment, both present and prospective, to meet those needs; and |
|
(B) after obtaining the license required under |
|
this subdivision, have participated in the performance of at least |
|
10 court-ordered child custody evaluations under the supervision of |
|
a person qualified under this section; |
|
(2) have graduated medical school and be licensed to |
|
practice medicine in this state and board certified in psychiatry |
|
and: |
|
(A) after completing medical school, have two |
|
years of full-time experience or equivalent part-time experience |
|
under professional supervision during which the person performed |
|
functions involving the evaluation of physical, intellectual, |
|
social, and psychological functioning and needs and the potential |
|
of the social and physical environment, both present and |
|
prospective, to meet those needs; and |
|
(B) after obtaining the license and |
|
certification required under this subdivision, have participated |
|
in the performance of at least 10 court-ordered child custody |
|
evaluations under the supervision of a person qualified under this |
|
section; |
|
(3) meet the requirements of Subdivision (1)(A) or |
|
(2)(A) and be practicing under the direct supervision of a person |
|
qualified under this section to complete at least 10 court-ordered |
|
child custody evaluations under supervision; or |
|
(4) be employed by or under contract with a domestic |
|
relations office, provided that the person conducts child custody |
|
evaluations relating only to families ordered to participate in |
|
child custody evaluations conducted by that office. |
|
(c) In addition to the other qualifications prescribed by |
|
this section, a person must complete at least eight hours of family |
|
violence dynamics training provided by a family violence service |
|
provider to be qualified to conduct a child custody evaluation. |
|
(d) In addition to the other qualifications prescribed by |
|
this section, a person who conducts a child custody evaluation as an |
|
employee of or contractor with a domestic relations office must |
|
meet any qualifications required by that office. |
|
Sec. 107.105. EXCEPTION TO QUALIFICATIONS REQUIRED TO |
|
CONDUCT CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION. In a county with a population of |
|
less than 500,000, if a court finds that a qualified person is not |
|
available to conduct a child custody evaluation in a timely manner, |
|
the court may authorize a person the court determines to be |
|
otherwise qualified to conduct the evaluation if the parties to the |
|
suit agree to the appointment in writing. |
|
Sec. 107.106. PRIVATE CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATOR: SPECIALIZED |
|
KNOWLEDGE. A private child custody evaluator must demonstrate to |
|
the court that the evaluator has sufficient specialized knowledge, |
|
education, and training to conduct a child custody evaluation. In |
|
making that demonstration, the evaluator must demonstrate that the |
|
evaluator has completed at least 40 hours of education and training |
|
on the following topics: |
|
(1) the psychological and developmental needs of a |
|
child, specifically as those needs relate to decisions about |
|
conservatorship of, possession of, and access to the child; |
|
(2) family dynamics, including parent-child |
|
relationships, blended families, and extended family |
|
relationships; |
|
(3) the effects of divorce, domestic violence, abuse |
|
and neglect, substance abuse, and parental conflict on the |
|
psychological and developmental needs of a child; |
|
(4) interviewing and assessing adults, children, and |
|
infants; |
|
(5) gathering information from collateral sources; |
|
(6) collecting and assessing data; |
|
(7) recognizing the limits of the reliability and |
|
validity of data; |
|
(8) addressing issues relating to mental health, |
|
medication use, and physical and learning disabilities; |
|
(9) applying to all parties comparable interview, |
|
assessment, and testing procedures that meet generally accepted |
|
clinical, diagnostic, forensic, scientific, and professional |
|
standards; |
|
(10) consulting with additional experts as needed; |
|
(11) assessing parenting capacity and constructing |
|
effective parenting plans; |
|
(12) ethical standards relating to a child custody |
|
evaluator's professional license and other applicable professional |
|
guidelines; |
|
(13) the legal standards and processes applicable in a |
|
suit; |
|
(14) understanding the distinctions in the roles of |
|
evaluator, mediator, therapist, consulting expert, testifying |
|
expert, parenting coordinator, and parenting facilitator; |
|
(15) writing reports and making recommendations; |
|
(16) mandatory reporting requirements and limitations |
|
on confidentiality; |
|
(17) preparing for and testifying at a court |
|
proceeding; |
|
(18) maintaining professional neutrality and |
|
objectivity when conducting a child custody evaluation; and |
|
(19) the importance of assessing the health, safety, |
|
welfare, and best interest of a child. |
|
Sec. 107.107. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATOR: CONFLICTS OF |
|
INTEREST AND BIAS. (a) Before accepting appointment as a child |
|
custody evaluator in a suit, a person must disclose to the court, |
|
each attorney for a party to the suit, any attorney for a child who |
|
is at issue in the suit, and any party to the suit who does not have |
|
an attorney: |
|
(1) any conflict of interest that the person believes |
|
that the person has with a party to the suit or a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit; |
|
(2) any previous knowledge that the person has of a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(3) any pecuniary relationship that the person |
|
believes that the person has with an attorney in the suit; |
|
(4) any relationship of confidence or trust that the |
|
person believes that the person has with an attorney in the suit; |
|
and |
|
(5) any other information relating to the person's |
|
relationship with an attorney in the suit that a reasonable, |
|
prudent person would believe would affect the ability of the person |
|
to act impartially in conducting a child custody evaluation. |
|
(b) The court may not appoint a person as a child custody |
|
evaluator in a suit if the person makes any of the disclosures in |
|
Subsection (a) unless: |
|
(1) the court finds that: |
|
(A) the person has no conflict of interest with a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(B) the person's previous knowledge of a party to |
|
the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit is not relevant; |
|
(C) the person does not have a pecuniary |
|
relationship with an attorney in the suit; and |
|
(D) the person does not have a relationship of |
|
trust or confidence with an attorney in the suit; or |
|
(2) the parties and any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit agree in writing to the person's appointment as |
|
the child custody evaluator. |
|
(c) After being appointed as a child custody evaluator in a |
|
suit, a person shall immediately disclose to the court, each |
|
attorney for a party to the suit, any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit, and any party to the suit who does not have an |
|
attorney any discovery of: |
|
(1) a conflict of interest that the person believes |
|
that the person has with a party to the suit or a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit; and |
|
(2) previous knowledge that the person has of a party |
|
to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit. |
|
(d) An person shall resign from the person's appointment as |
|
a child custody evaluator in a suit if the person makes any of the |
|
disclosures in Subsection (c) unless: |
|
(1) the court finds that: |
|
(A) the person has no conflict of interest with a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; and |
|
(B) the person's previous knowledge of a party to |
|
the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit is not relevant; or |
|
(2) the parties and any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit agree in writing to the person's continued |
|
appointment as the child custody evaluator. |
|
(e) A person may not be appointed as a child custody |
|
evaluator in a suit if the person has worked in a professional |
|
capacity with a party to the suit, a child who is at issue in the |
|
suit, or a member of the party's or child's family who is involved in |
|
the suit. This subsection does not apply to a person who has worked |
|
in a professional capacity with a party, a child, or a member of the |
|
party's or child's family only as a teacher of parenting skills in a |
|
group setting. For purposes of this subsection, "family" has the |
|
meaning assigned by Section 71.003. |
|
Sec. 107.108. COMMUNICATIONS AND RECORDKEEPING OF CHILD |
|
CUSTODY EVALUATOR. (a) Notwithstanding any rule, standard of |
|
care, or privilege applicable to the professional license held by a |
|
child custody evaluator, a communication made by a participant in a |
|
child custody evaluation is subject to disclosure and may be |
|
offered in any judicial or administrative proceeding, if otherwise |
|
admissible under the rules of evidence. |
|
(b) A child custody evaluator shall keep a detailed record |
|
regarding interviews that the evaluator conducts, observations |
|
that the evaluator makes, and substantive interactions that the |
|
evaluator has as part of a child custody evaluation. |
|
(c) Except for information the disclosure of which is |
|
governed by Section 261.201(f-2) or the disclosure of which is |
|
prohibited by a court order, a private child custody evaluator |
|
shall, after completion of an evaluation, make available in a |
|
reasonable time the evaluator's records relating to the evaluation |
|
on the written request of an attorney for a party, a party who does |
|
not have an attorney, or any other person appointed by the court |
|
under this chapter in the suit in which the evaluator conducted the |
|
evaluation. |
|
(d) Except for information the disclosure of which is |
|
governed by Section 261.201(f-2), a child custody evaluator who |
|
conducted a child custody evaluation as an employee of or |
|
contractor with a domestic relations office shall, after completion |
|
of the evaluation, make available the evaluator's records to the |
|
persons described in Subsection (c) on written request according to |
|
the rules and policies of the office. |
|
(e) A person maintaining records subject to disclosure |
|
under this section may charge a reasonable fee for producing copies |
|
of the records. |
|
(f) A private child custody evaluator shall retain records |
|
relating to a child custody evaluation conducted by the evaluator |
|
until the later of the seventh anniversary of the date the evaluator |
|
filed the evaluator's report on the evaluation with the court or the |
|
ending date of the retention period established by the licensing |
|
authority that issues the professional license held by the |
|
evaluator. |
|
(g) A domestic relations office shall retain records |
|
relating to a child custody evaluation conducted by a child custody |
|
evaluator acting as an employee of or contractor with the office for |
|
the retention period established by the office. |
|
Sec. 107.109. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION REPORT REQUIRED. |
|
(a) For each child custody evaluation, the child custody evaluator |
|
who conducted the evaluation shall prepare a report containing the |
|
evaluator's findings, opinions, recommendations, and answers to |
|
specific questions asked by the court relating to the evaluation. |
|
(b) A report prepared under this section must include the |
|
name, license number, and basis for qualification of each child |
|
custody evaluator who conducted any portion of the evaluation. |
|
Sec. 107.110. GENERAL PROVISIONS APPLICABLE TO CONDUCT OF |
|
CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATOR AND PREPARATION OF REPORT. (a) Unless |
|
otherwise directed by a court or prescribed by this subchapter, a |
|
child custody evaluator's actions in conducting a child custody |
|
evaluation must be in conformance with the professional standard of |
|
care applicable to the evaluator's licensure and any administrative |
|
rules, ethical standards, or guidelines adopted by the licensing |
|
authority that licenses the evaluator. |
|
(b) In addition to the requirements prescribed by this |
|
subchapter, a court may impose requirements or adopt local rules |
|
applicable to a child custody evaluation or a child custody |
|
evaluator. |
|
(c) A child custody evaluator shall follow evidence-based |
|
practice methods and make use of current best evidence in making |
|
assessments and recommendations. |
|
(d) A child custody evaluator shall disclose to each |
|
attorney of record any communication regarding a substantive issue |
|
between the evaluator and an attorney of record representing a |
|
party in a disputed suit. This subsection does not apply to a |
|
communication between a child custody evaluator and an amicus |
|
attorney. |
|
(e) To the extent possible, a child custody evaluator shall |
|
conduct interviews and make observations in a balanced manner so |
|
that if the evaluator interviews and observes a child at issue in |
|
the suit while in the care of one party to the suit, the evaluator |
|
also interviews and observes the child while in the care of the |
|
other parties to the suit. |
|
(f) To the extent possible, a child custody evaluator shall |
|
verify each statement of fact pertinent to a child custody |
|
evaluation and shall note the sources of verification and |
|
information in the child custody evaluation report prepared under |
|
Section 107.109. |
|
(g) A child custody evaluator shall state the basis for and |
|
the sources of the evaluator's conclusions or recommendations in |
|
the child custody evaluation report prepared under Section 107.109. |
|
(h) A child custody evaluation must be conducted in |
|
compliance with this subchapter, regardless of whether the |
|
evaluation is conducted by a single child custody evaluator or |
|
multiple evaluators working separately or together. |
|
Sec. 107.111. INTRODUCTION AND PROVISION OF CHILD CUSTODY |
|
EVALUATION REPORT. (a) Disclosure to the court or jury of the |
|
contents of a child custody evaluation report prepared under |
|
Section 107.109 is subject to the rules of evidence. |
|
(b) Unless the court has issued an order restricting |
|
disclosure, a private child custody evaluator shall provide to the |
|
attorneys of the parties to a suit, any party who does not have an |
|
attorney, and any other person appointed by the court under this |
|
chapter in the suit a copy of the child custody evaluation report |
|
before the earlier of: |
|
(1) the seventh day after the date the child custody |
|
report is completed; or |
|
(2) the 30th day before the date of the commencement of |
|
the trial, if applicable. |
|
(c) A child custody evaluator who conducts a child custody |
|
evaluation as an employee of or contractor with a domestic |
|
relations office shall provide to the attorneys of the parties to a |
|
suit and any other person appointed by the court in the suit under |
|
this chapter a copy of the child custody evaluation report in the |
|
manner provided by Subsection (b). The evaluator shall provide a |
|
copy of the report to a party to the suit as provided by the rules |
|
and policies of the office or by a court order. |
|
(d) A trial in a suit in which a child custody evaluation is |
|
conducted may not begin before the 30th day after the date the child |
|
custody evaluator provides copies of the child custody evaluation |
|
report as provided by this section unless the parties to the suit |
|
agree to an earlier date. |
|
Sec. 107.112. CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATION FEE. If the court |
|
orders a child custody evaluation to be conducted, the court shall |
|
award the child custody evaluator a reasonable fee for the |
|
performance of the evaluation that shall be imposed in the form of a |
|
money judgment and paid directly to the evaluator. The evaluator |
|
may enforce the judgment for the fee by any means available under |
|
law for civil judgments. |
|
Sec. 107.113. ACCESS TO RECORDS; OFFENSE. (a) A child |
|
custody evaluator is entitled to obtain from the department any |
|
report, record, working paper, or other information in the |
|
possession, custody, or control of the department, including |
|
information that is confidential under Section 40.005, Human |
|
Resources Code, or other law, that pertains to an individual who is |
|
a subject of the evaluation. |
|
(b) Any confidential information obtained by a child |
|
custody evaluator under this section remains confidential, subject |
|
to Subsection (c), and is not subject to disclosure under Chapter |
|
552, Government Code, or to subpoena or discovery. |
|
(c) A child custody evaluator may disclose confidential |
|
information obtained under this section in a child custody |
|
evaluation report prepared under Section 107.109 only to the extent |
|
that the evaluator determines that the information is relevant to |
|
the evaluator's recommendations in the report. |
|
(d) Except as provided by Subsection (c) or by an order of |
|
the court that appointed the child custody evaluator, a child |
|
custody evaluator commits an offense if the evaluator releases or |
|
discloses confidential information obtained from the department |
|
under this section. An offense under this section is a Class A |
|
misdemeanor. |
|
ARTICLE 2. ADOPTION EVALUATION |
|
SECTION 2.01. Chapter 107, Family Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subchapter F to read as follows: |
|
SUBCHAPTER F. ADOPTION EVALUATION |
|
Sec. 107.151. DEFINITIONS. In this subchapter: |
|
(1) "Adoption evaluation" means a pre-placement or |
|
post-placement evaluative process through which information and |
|
recommendations regarding adoption of a child may be made to the |
|
court, the parties, and the parties' attorneys. The term does not |
|
include services provided in accordance with the Interstate Compact |
|
on the Placement of Children adopted under Subchapter B, Chapter |
|
162, or an evaluation conducted in accordance with Section 262.114 |
|
by an employee of or contractor with the department. |
|
(2) "Adoption evaluator" means a person who conducts |
|
an adoption evaluation under this subchapter. |
|
(3) "Department" means the Department of Family and |
|
Protective Services. |
|
(4) "Supervision" means the regular review of and |
|
consultation with a person. Supervision does not require the |
|
constant physical presence of the person providing supervision. |
|
Sec. 107.152. ORDER FOR ADOPTION EVALUATION. (a) The court |
|
shall order the performance of an adoption evaluation to evaluate |
|
each party who requests termination of the parent-child |
|
relationship or an adoption in a suit for: |
|
(1) termination of the parent-child relationship in |
|
which a person other than a parent may be appointed managing |
|
conservator of a child; or |
|
(2) an adoption. |
|
(b) The adoption evaluation required under Subsection (a) |
|
must include an evaluation of the circumstances and the condition |
|
of the home and social environment of any person requesting to adopt |
|
a child who is at issue in the suit. |
|
(c) If the department is not a party to the suit, the court |
|
may appoint a qualified individual, a qualified private entity, or |
|
a domestic relations office to conduct the adoption evaluation. If |
|
the department is a party to the suit, the court may also appoint a |
|
state agency, including the department, to conduct the adoption |
|
evaluation. |
|
(d) Except as provided by Section 107.156, a person who |
|
conducts an adoption evaluation must be qualified under Section |
|
107.155. |
|
Sec. 107.153. REQUIREMENTS FOR PRE-PLACEMENT PART OF |
|
ADOPTION EVALUATION. (a) This section does not apply to the |
|
pre-placement part of an adoption evaluation conducted by a |
|
licensed child-placing agency or the department. The pre-placement |
|
part of an adoption evaluation conducted by a licensed |
|
child-placing agency or the department is governed by rules adopted |
|
by the executive commissioner of the Health and Human Services |
|
Commission, including rules adopted under Chapter 42, Human |
|
Resources Code. |
|
(b) Except as provided by Subsection (f), a person who |
|
conducts an adoption evaluation must file with the court a report |
|
containing the person's findings and conclusions made before a |
|
child who is at issue in the suit to which the subject of the |
|
evaluation is a party begins residence in a prospective adoptive |
|
home. |
|
(c) The report required under Subsection (b) must be filed |
|
with the court before the court renders a final order for |
|
termination of the parent-child relationship. |
|
(d) The costs of the pre-placement part of an adoption |
|
evaluation in a suit for adoption must be paid by the prospective |
|
adoptive parent. |
|
(e) Unless otherwise agreed to by the court, the |
|
pre-placement part of an adoption evaluation must comply with the |
|
minimum requirements for the pre-placement part of an adoption |
|
evaluation under rules adopted by the executive commissioner of the |
|
Health and Human Services Commission. |
|
(f) In a suit filed after a child who is at issue in the suit |
|
begins residence in a prospective adoptive home, the report |
|
required under this section and the report required under Section |
|
107.154 may be combined in a single report. |
|
Sec. 107.154. REQUIREMENTS FOR POST-PLACEMENT PART OF |
|
ADOPTION EVALUATION. (a) An adoption evaluator shall file with the |
|
court a report containing the person's findings and conclusions |
|
made after a child who is at issue in the suit to which the subject |
|
of the evaluation is a party begins residence in a prospective |
|
adoptive home. |
|
(b) The report required under Subsection (a) must be filed |
|
with the court before the court renders a final order of adoption. |
|
(c) Unless otherwise agreed to by the court, the |
|
post-placement part of an adoption evaluation must comply with the |
|
minimum requirements for the post-placement part of an adoption |
|
evaluation under rules adopted by the executive commissioner of the |
|
Health and Human Services Commission. |
|
Sec. 107.155. ADOPTION EVALUATOR: MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS. |
|
(a) In this section: |
|
(1) "Full-time experience" means a period during which |
|
a person works at least 30 hours per week. |
|
(2) "Human services field of study" means a field of |
|
study designed to prepare a person in the disciplined application |
|
of counseling, family therapy, psychology, or social work values, |
|
principles, and methods. |
|
(b) To be qualified to conduct an adoption evaluation, a |
|
person must: |
|
(1) have a degree from an accredited college or |
|
university in a human services field of study and a license to |
|
practice in this state as a social worker, professional counselor, |
|
marriage and family therapist, or psychologist and: |
|
(A) be qualified as a child custody evaluator |
|
under Section 107.104; |
|
(B) have one year of full-time experience working |
|
at a child-placing agency conducting child-placing activities; or |
|
(C) be practicing under the direct supervision of |
|
a person qualified under this section to conduct adoption |
|
evaluations; or |
|
(2) be employed by a domestic relations office, |
|
provided that the person conducts adoption evaluations relating |
|
only to families ordered to participate in adoption evaluations |
|
conducted by the office. |
|
(c) In addition to the other qualifications prescribed by |
|
this section, a person must complete at least eight hours of family |
|
violence dynamics training provided by a family violence service |
|
provider to be qualified to conduct an adoption evaluation. |
|
Sec. 107.156. EXCEPTION TO QUALIFICATIONS REQUIRED TO |
|
CONDUCT ADOPTION EVALUATION. If a court finds that a qualified |
|
person is not available to conduct an adoption evaluation in the |
|
county in which the court presides, the court may authorize a person |
|
the court determines to be otherwise qualified to conduct the |
|
evaluation. |
|
Sec. 107.157. ADOPTION EVALUATOR: CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AND |
|
BIAS. (a) Before accepting appointment as an adoption evaluator in |
|
a suit, a person must disclose to the court, each attorney for a |
|
party to the suit, any attorney for a child who is at issue in the |
|
suit, and any party to the suit who does not have an attorney: |
|
(1) any conflict of interest that the person believes |
|
that the person has with a party to the suit or a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit; |
|
(2) any previous knowledge that the person has of a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(3) any pecuniary relationship that the person |
|
believes that the person has with an attorney in the suit; |
|
(4) any relationship of confidence or trust that the |
|
person believes that the person has with an attorney in the suit; |
|
and |
|
(5) any other information relating to the person's |
|
relationship with an attorney in the suit that a reasonable, |
|
prudent person would believe would affect the ability of the person |
|
to act impartially in conducting an adoption evaluation. |
|
(b) The court may not appoint a person as an adoption |
|
evaluator in a suit if the person makes any of the disclosures in |
|
Subsection (a) unless: |
|
(1) the court finds that: |
|
(A) the person has no conflict of interest with a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; |
|
(B) the person's previous knowledge of a party to |
|
the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit is not relevant; |
|
(C) the person does not have a pecuniary |
|
relationship with an attorney in the suit; and |
|
(D) the person does not have a relationship of |
|
trust or confidence with an attorney in the suit; or |
|
(2) the parties and any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit agree in writing to the person's appointment as |
|
the adoption evaluator. |
|
(c) After being appointed as an adoption evaluator in a |
|
suit, a person shall immediately disclose to the court, each |
|
attorney for a party to the suit, any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit, and any party to the suit who does not have an |
|
attorney any discovery of: |
|
(1) a conflict of interest that the person believes |
|
that the person has with a party to the suit or a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit; and |
|
(2) previous knowledge that the person has of a party |
|
to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit. |
|
(d) A person shall resign from the person's appointment as |
|
an adoption evaluator in a suit if the person makes any of the |
|
disclosures in Subsection (c) unless: |
|
(1) the court finds that: |
|
(A) the person has no conflict of interest with a |
|
party to the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit; and |
|
(B) the person's previous knowledge of a party to |
|
the suit or a child who is at issue in the suit is not relevant; or |
|
(2) the parties and any attorney for a child who is at |
|
issue in the suit agree in writing to the person's continued |
|
appointment as the adoption evaluator. |
|
(e) A person may not be appointed as an adoption evaluator |
|
in a suit if the person has worked in a professional capacity with a |
|
party to the suit, a child who is at issue in the suit, or a member |
|
of the party's or child's family who is involved in the suit. This |
|
subsection does not apply to a person who has worked in a |
|
professional capacity with a party, a child, or a member of the |
|
party's or child's family only as a teacher of parenting skills in a |
|
group setting. For purposes of this subsection, family has the |
|
meaning assigned by Section 71.003. |
|
Sec. 107.158. GENERAL PROVISIONS APPLICABLE TO CONDUCT OF |
|
ADOPTION EVALUATOR AND PREPARATION OF REPORTS. (a) Unless |
|
otherwise directed by a court or prescribed by this subchapter, an |
|
adoption evaluator's actions in conducting an adoption evaluation |
|
must be in conformance with the professional standard of care |
|
applicable to the evaluator's licensure and any administrative |
|
rules, ethical standards, or guidelines adopted by the licensing |
|
authority that licenses the evaluator. |
|
(b) In addition to the requirements prescribed by this |
|
subchapter, a court may impose requirements or adopt local rules |
|
applicable to an adoption evaluation or an adoption evaluator. |
|
(c) An adoption evaluator shall follow evidence-based |
|
practice methods and make use of current best evidence in making |
|
assessments and recommendations. |
|
(d) An adoption evaluator shall disclose to each attorney of |
|
record any communication regarding a substantive issue between the |
|
evaluator and an attorney of record representing a party in a |
|
disputed suit. This subsection does not apply to a communication |
|
between an adoption evaluator and an amicus attorney. |
|
(e) To the extent possible, an adoption evaluator shall |
|
verify each statement of fact pertinent to an adoption evaluation |
|
and shall note the sources of verification and information in any |
|
report prepared on the evaluation. |
|
(f) An adoption evaluator shall state the basis for the |
|
evaluator's conclusions or recommendations in any report prepared |
|
on the evaluation. |
|
(g) Any report prepared on an adoption evaluation must |
|
include the name, license number, and basis for qualification of |
|
each adoption evaluator who conducted any portion of the |
|
evaluation. |
|
Sec. 107.159. REPORTING CERTAIN PLACEMENTS FOR ADOPTION. |
|
An adoption evaluator shall report to the department any adoptive |
|
placement that appears to have been made by someone other than a |
|
licensed child-placing agency or a child's parent or managing |
|
conservator. |
|
Sec. 107.160. ADOPTION EVALUATION REPORT REQUIRED. An |
|
adoption evaluator shall file with the court on a date set by the |
|
court a report containing the evaluator's findings and conclusions |
|
relating to the evaluation. The report shall be made a part of the |
|
record of the suit. |
|
Sec. 107.161. PROSPECTIVE ADOPTIVE PARENTS ENTITLED TO |
|
RECEIVE COPY OF ADOPTION EVALUATION REPORT. In a suit for adoption, |
|
a copy of the report prepared under Section 107.160 must be made |
|
available to the prospective adoptive parents before the court |
|
renders a final order of adoption. |
|
Sec. 107.162. INTRODUCTION AND PROVISION OF ADOPTION |
|
EVALUATION REPORT AND TESTIMONY RELATING TO ADOPTION EVALUATION. |
|
(a) Disclosure to the jury of the contents of an adoption |
|
evaluation report prepared under Section 107.160 is subject to the |
|
rules of evidence. |
|
(b) An adoption evaluator shall provide to the attorneys of |
|
the parties to a suit and any other person appointed by the court |
|
under this chapter in the suit a copy of the report prepared under |
|
Section 107.160 before the earlier of: |
|
(1) the seventh day after the date the adoption |
|
evaluation report is completed; or |
|
(2) the 30th day before the date of the commencement of |
|
the trial, if applicable. |
|
(c) The court may compel the attendance of witnesses |
|
necessary for the proper disposition of a suit, including a |
|
representative of an agency that conducts an adoption evaluation, |
|
who may be compelled to testify. |
|
Sec. 107.163. ADOPTION EVALUATION FEE. If the court orders |
|
an adoption evaluation to be conducted, the court shall award the |
|
adoption evaluator a reasonable fee for the performance of the |
|
evaluation that shall be imposed in the form of a money judgment and |
|
paid directly to the evaluator. The evaluator may enforce the |
|
judgment for the fee by any means available under law for civil |
|
judgments. |
|
Sec. 107.164. ACCESS TO RECORDS; OFFENSE. (a) An adoption |
|
evaluator is entitled to obtain from the department any report, |
|
record, working paper, or other information in the possession, |
|
custody, or control of the department, including information that |
|
is confidential under Section 40.005, Human Resources Code, or |
|
other law, that pertains to a person who is a subject of the |
|
evaluation. |
|
(b) Any confidential information obtained by an adoption |
|
evaluator under this section remains confidential, subject to |
|
Subsection (c), and is not subject to disclosure under Chapter 552, |
|
Government Code, or to subpoena or discovery. |
|
(c) An adoption evaluator may disclose confidential |
|
information obtained under this section in a report prepared on the |
|
evaluation only to the extent that the evaluator determines that |
|
the information is relevant to the evaluator's recommendations in |
|
the report. |
|
(d) Except as provided by Subsection (c) or by an order of |
|
the court that appointed the adoption evaluator, an adoption |
|
evaluator commits an offense if the evaluator releases or discloses |
|
confidential information obtained from the department under this |
|
section. An offense under this section is a Class A misdemeanor. |
|
ARTICLE 3. TESTIMONY IN SUITS AFFECTING THE PARENT-CHILD |
|
RELATIONSHIP |
|
SECTION 3.01. Chapter 104, Family Code, is amended by |
|
adding Section 104.008 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 104.008. CERTAIN TESTIMONY PROHIBITED. (a) A person |
|
may not offer an expert opinion relating to the conservatorship of |
|
or possession of or access to a child at issue in a suit unless the |
|
person: |
|
(1) is appointed as the child's guardian ad litem under |
|
Subchapter A, Chapter 107; or |
|
(2) has conducted a child custody evaluation relating |
|
to the child under Subchapter E, Chapter 107. |
|
(b) In a disputed suit, a mental health professional may not |
|
make a recommendation regarding the conservatorship of or |
|
possession of or access to a child at issue in the suit unless the |
|
mental health professional: |
|
(1) is appointed as the child's guardian ad litem under |
|
Subchapter A, Chapter 107; or |
|
(2) has conducted a child custody evaluation relating |
|
to the child under Subchapter E, Chapter 107, and has evaluated all |
|
of the parties to the suit. |
|
(c) Subsection (b) does not apply to a mental health |
|
professional who is providing other relevant information and |
|
opinions relating to any party that the mental health professional |
|
has evaluated. |
|
ARTICLE 4. CONFORMING AMENDMENTS RELATING TO CHILD CUSTODY |
|
EVALUATIONS AND ADOPTION EVALUATIONS |
|
SECTION 4.01. The heading to Chapter 107, Family Code, is |
|
amended to read as follows: |
|
CHAPTER 107. SPECIAL APPOINTMENTS, CHILD CUSTODY EVALUATIONS, AND |
|
ADOPTION EVALUATIONS [AND SOCIAL STUDIES] |
|
SECTION 4.02. Section 153.605(d), Family Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
(d) An individual appointed as a parenting coordinator may |
|
not serve in any nonconfidential capacity in the same case, |
|
including serving as an amicus attorney, guardian ad litem, child |
|
custody [or social study] evaluator, or adoption evaluator under |
|
Chapter 107, as a friend of the court under Chapter 202, or as a |
|
parenting facilitator under this subchapter. |
|
SECTION 4.03. Section 162.0025, Family Code, is amended to |
|
read as follows: |
|
Sec. 162.0025. ADOPTION SOUGHT BY MILITARY SERVICE MEMBER. |
|
In a suit for adoption, the fact that a petitioner is a member of the |
|
armed forces of the United States, a member of the Texas National |
|
Guard or the National Guard of another state, or a member of a |
|
reserve component of the armed forces of the United States may not |
|
be considered by the court, or any person performing an adoption |
|
evaluation [a social study] or home screening, as a negative factor |
|
in determining whether the adoption is in the best interest of the |
|
child or whether the petitioner would be a suitable parent. |
|
SECTION 4.04. Section 162.003, Family Code, is amended to |
|
read as follows: |
|
Sec. 162.003. ADOPTION EVALUATION [PRE-ADOPTIVE AND
|
|
POST-PLACEMENT SOCIAL STUDIES]. In a suit for adoption, an |
|
adoption evaluation [pre-adoptive and post-placement social
|
|
studies] must be conducted as provided in Chapter 107. |
|
SECTION 4.05. Section 162.0045, Family Code, is amended to |
|
read as follows: |
|
Sec. 162.0045. PREFERENTIAL SETTING. The court shall grant |
|
a motion for a preferential setting for a final hearing on an |
|
adoption and shall give precedence to that hearing over all other |
|
civil cases not given preference by other law if the adoption |
|
evaluation [social study] has been filed and the criminal history |
|
for the person seeking to adopt the child has been obtained. |
|
SECTION 4.06. Section 203.004(a), Family Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
(a) A domestic relations office may: |
|
(1) collect and disburse child support payments that |
|
are ordered by a court to be paid through a domestic relations |
|
registry; |
|
(2) maintain records of payments and disbursements |
|
made under Subdivision (1); |
|
(3) file a suit, including a suit to: |
|
(A) establish paternity; |
|
(B) enforce a court order for child support or |
|
for possession of and access to a child; and |
|
(C) modify or clarify an existing child support |
|
order; |
|
(4) provide an informal forum in which alternative |
|
dispute resolution is used to resolve disputes under this code; |
|
(5) prepare a court-ordered child custody evaluation |
|
or adoption evaluation [social study] under Chapter 107; |
|
(6) represent a child as an amicus attorney, an |
|
attorney ad litem, or a guardian ad litem in a suit in which: |
|
(A) termination of the parent-child relationship |
|
is sought; or |
|
(B) conservatorship of or access to a child is |
|
contested; |
|
(7) serve as a friend of the court; |
|
(8) provide predivorce counseling ordered by a court; |
|
(9) provide community supervision services under |
|
Chapter 157; |
|
(10) provide information to assist a party in |
|
understanding, complying with, or enforcing the party's duties and |
|
obligations under Subdivision (3); |
|
(11) provide, directly or through a contract, |
|
visitation services, including supervision of court-ordered |
|
visitation, visitation exchange, or other similar services; |
|
(12) issue an administrative writ of withholding under |
|
Subchapter F, Chapter 158; and |
|
(13) provide parenting coordinator services under |
|
Chapter 153. |
|
SECTION 4.07. Section 203.005(a), Family Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
(a) The administering entity may authorize a domestic |
|
relations office to assess and collect: |
|
(1) an initial operations fee not to exceed $15 to be |
|
paid to the domestic relations office on each filing of an original |
|
suit, motion for modification, or motion for enforcement; |
|
(2) in a county that has a child support enforcement |
|
cooperative agreement with the Title IV-D agency, an initial child |
|
support service fee not to exceed $36 to be paid to the domestic |
|
relations office on the filing of an original suit; |
|
(3) a reasonable application fee to be paid by an |
|
applicant requesting services from the office; |
|
(4) a reasonable attorney's fee and court costs |
|
incurred or ordered by the court; |
|
(5) a monthly service fee not to exceed $3 to be paid |
|
annually in advance by a managing conservator and possessory |
|
conservator for whom the domestic relations office provides child |
|
support services; |
|
(6) community supervision fees as provided by Chapter |
|
157 if community supervision officers are employed by the domestic |
|
relations office; |
|
(7) a reasonable fee for preparation of a |
|
court-ordered child custody evaluation or adoption evaluation |
|
[social study]; |
|
(8) in a county that provides visitation services |
|
under Sections 153.014 and 203.004 a reasonable fee to be paid to |
|
the domestic relations office at the time the visitation services |
|
are provided; |
|
(9) a fee to reimburse the domestic relations office |
|
for a fee required to be paid under Section 158.503(d) for filing an |
|
administrative writ of withholding; |
|
(10) a reasonable fee for parenting coordinator |
|
services; and |
|
(11) a reasonable fee for alternative dispute |
|
resolution services. |
|
SECTION 4.08. Section 261.201, Family Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subsection (f-2) to read as follows: |
|
(f-2) Not later than the 31st day after the date the person |
|
makes a request for information, the department shall provide to a |
|
child custody evaluator or adoption evaluator appointed under |
|
Chapter 107 any report, record, working paper, or other information |
|
in the possession, custody, or control of the department that |
|
pertains to an individual who is a subject of the evaluation. |
|
Confidential information provided under this subsection remains |
|
confidential, and the evaluator may disclose the information only |
|
as provided by Section 107.113 or 107.164 or by an order of the |
|
court that appointed the evaluator. |
|
SECTION 4.09. Section 411.1285(c), Government Code, is |
|
amended to read as follows: |
|
(c) Criminal history record information requested under |
|
this section, including information included in a report of a child |
|
custody evaluation or adoption evaluation [social study] filed |
|
under Chapter 107 [Section 107.054], Family Code, may not be |
|
released or disclosed by a domestic relations office to a person |
|
other than the court ordering the child custody evaluation or |
|
adoption evaluation [social study] except on court order or with |
|
the consent of the person who is the subject of the criminal history |
|
record information. |
|
SECTION 4.10. Section 152.06331(f), Human Resources Code, |
|
is amended to read as follows: |
|
(f) Fees for the preparation of a court-ordered child |
|
custody evaluation or adoption evaluation [social study] or any |
|
other services provided by the domestic relations office, other |
|
than services related to the collection of child support, must be |
|
reasonable and imposed on a sliding scale according to the |
|
financial resources of the parties using the services. |
|
ARTICLE 5. REPEALER |
|
SECTION 5.01. Subchapter D, Chapter 107, Family Code, is |
|
repealed. |
|
ARTICLE 6. TRANSITION AND EFFECTIVE DATE |
|
SECTION 6.01. (a) Not later than September 1, 2014, the |
|
Texas State Board of Examiners of Psychologists, the Texas State |
|
Board of Examiners of Professional Counselors, the Texas State |
|
Board of Social Worker Examiners, the Texas State Board of |
|
Examiners of Marriage and Family Therapists, and the Texas Medical |
|
Board shall adopt any rules necessary for license holders to comply |
|
with the requirements of Subchapters E and F, Chapter 107, Family |
|
Code, as added by this Act, and specifying that a person licensed by |
|
any of the boards is subject to the rules of the board that licensed |
|
the person when appointed by a court to conduct a child custody |
|
evaluation or adoption evaluation under Subchapter E or F, Chapter |
|
107, Family Code, as added by this Act. |
|
(b) As soon as possible after the effective date of this |
|
Act, the Texas State Board of Examiners of Psychologists, the Texas |
|
State Board of Examiners of Professional Counselors, and the Texas |
|
State Board of Examiners of Marriage and Family Therapists shall |
|
adopt rules prohibiting a psychological associate, a licensed |
|
specialist in school psychology, a provisionally licensed |
|
psychologist, a licensed professional counselor intern, and a |
|
licensed marriage and family therapist associate from conducting a |
|
child custody evaluation under Subchapter E, Chapter 107, Family |
|
Code, as added by this Act, unless the person is otherwise qualified |
|
to conduct the evaluation. |
|
(c) As soon as possible after the effective date of this |
|
Act, the executive commissioner of the Health and Human Services |
|
Commission shall adopt rules prohibiting a licensed chemical |
|
dependency counselor from conducting a child custody evaluation as |
|
a child custody evaluator under Subchapter E, Chapter 107, Family |
|
Code, as added by this Act, unless the person is otherwise qualified |
|
to conduct the evaluation or is appointed by a court to conduct the |
|
evaluation under Section 107.105, Family Code, as added by this |
|
Act. |
|
(d) Not later than September 1, 2014, the executive |
|
commissioner of the Health and Human Services Commission shall |
|
adopt any rules necessary to implement Subchapters E and F, Chapter |
|
107, Family Code, as added by this Act, including rules that direct |
|
a person to report any complaints relating to the outcome of a child |
|
custody evaluation or adoption evaluation conducted under |
|
Subchapters E and F, Chapter 107, Family Code, as added by this Act, |
|
to the court that ordered the evaluation instead of to the licensing |
|
authority that issued a professional license to the person who |
|
conducted the evaluation. |
|
SECTION 6.02. The changes in law made by this Act apply to a |
|
suit affecting the parent-child relationship that is pending in a |
|
court on the effective date of this Act or that is filed on or after |
|
that date. |
|
SECTION 6.03. This Act takes effect September 1, 2013. |