|
|
|
A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
|
|
AN ACT
|
|
relating to the operation and administration of Medicaid, including |
|
the Medicaid managed care program. |
|
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: |
|
SECTION 1. Section 531.001, Government Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subdivision (4-c) to read as follows: |
|
(4-c) "Medicaid managed care organization" means a |
|
managed care organization as defined by Section 533.001 that |
|
contracts with the commission under Chapter 533 to provide health |
|
care services to Medicaid recipients. |
|
SECTION 2. Subchapter A, Chapter 531, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 531.0172 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 531.0172. OMBUDSMAN FOR MEDICAID PROVIDERS. (a) In |
|
this section, "office" means the office of ombudsman for Medicaid |
|
providers. |
|
(b) The office of ombudsman for Medicaid providers is |
|
established within the commission's Medicaid and CHIP services |
|
division to support Medicaid providers in resolving disputes, |
|
complaints, or other issues between the provider and the commission |
|
or a Medicaid managed care organization under a Medicaid managed |
|
care or fee-for-service delivery model. |
|
(c) The commission shall consider disputes, complaints, and |
|
other issues reported to the office in renewing a contract with a |
|
Medicaid managed care organization. |
|
(d) The office shall report issues regarding the Medicaid |
|
managed care program to the Medicaid director with timely |
|
information. |
|
(e) The office shall provide feedback to a person who files |
|
a grievance with the office, such as feedback concerning any |
|
investigation resulting from and the outcome of the grievance, in |
|
accordance with the no-wrong-door system established under Section |
|
533.027. |
|
(f) Data collected by the office must be collected and |
|
reported by provider type and population served. The office shall |
|
use the data to develop and make to the commission's Medicaid and |
|
CHIP services division recommendations for reforming providers' |
|
experiences with Medicaid, including Medicaid managed care. |
|
(g) The commission shall align the office's data collection |
|
practices with the data collection practices used by the |
|
commission's office of the ombudsman to facilitate comparisons. |
|
(h) The executive commissioner shall adopt rules as |
|
necessary to implement this section. |
|
SECTION 3. Subchapter B, Chapter 531, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 531.02133 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 531.02133. REQUESTING INFORMATION IN STAR HEALTH |
|
PROGRAM. The Department of Family and Protective Services shall |
|
provide clear guidance on the process for requesting and responding |
|
to requests for documents relating to and medical records of a |
|
recipient under the STAR Health program to: |
|
(1) a Medicaid managed care organization that provides |
|
health care services under that program; and |
|
(2) attorneys ad litem representing recipients under |
|
that program. |
|
SECTION 4. Section 531.02141, Government Code, is amended |
|
by adding Subsection (f) to read as follows: |
|
(f) For each hearing officer that conducts Medicaid fair |
|
hearings, the commission or the external medical reviewer described |
|
by Section 533.00715 annually shall collect data regarding the |
|
officer's decisions and rates of upholding or reversing decisions |
|
on appeal. The commission shall analyze the data to identify |
|
outliers. The commission shall provide corrective education to |
|
hearing officers whose decisions or rates are outliers. The |
|
commission shall document the outliers identified and the |
|
corrective education provided. |
|
SECTION 5. Section 531.02411, Government Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 531.02411. STREAMLINING ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESSES. |
|
(a) The commission shall make every effort using the commission's |
|
existing resources to reduce the paperwork and other administrative |
|
burdens placed on Medicaid recipients and providers and other |
|
participants in Medicaid and shall use technology and efficient |
|
business practices to decrease those burdens. In addition, the |
|
commission shall make every effort to improve the business |
|
practices associated with the administration of Medicaid by any |
|
method the commission determines is cost-effective, including: |
|
(1) expanding the utilization of the electronic claims |
|
payment system; |
|
(2) developing an Internet portal system for prior |
|
authorization requests; |
|
(3) encouraging Medicaid providers to submit their |
|
program participation applications electronically; |
|
(4) ensuring that the Medicaid provider application is |
|
easy to locate on the Internet so that providers may conveniently |
|
apply to the program; |
|
(5) working with federal partners to take advantage of |
|
every opportunity to maximize additional federal funding for |
|
technology in Medicaid; and |
|
(6) encouraging the increased use of medical |
|
technology by providers, including increasing their use of: |
|
(A) electronic communications between patients |
|
and their physicians or other health care providers; |
|
(B) electronic prescribing tools that provide |
|
up-to-date payer formulary information at the time a physician or |
|
other health care practitioner writes a prescription and that |
|
support the electronic transmission of a prescription; |
|
(C) ambulatory computerized order entry systems |
|
that facilitate physician and other health care practitioner orders |
|
at the point of care for medications and laboratory and |
|
radiological tests; |
|
(D) inpatient computerized order entry systems |
|
to reduce errors, improve health care quality, and lower costs in a |
|
hospital setting; |
|
(E) regional data-sharing to coordinate patient |
|
care across a community for patients who are treated by multiple |
|
providers; and |
|
(F) electronic intensive care unit technology to |
|
allow physicians to fully monitor hospital patients remotely. |
|
(b) The commission shall adopt and implement policies that |
|
encourage the use of electronic transactions in Medicaid. The |
|
policies must: |
|
(1) promote electronic payment systems for Medicaid |
|
providers, including electronic funds transfer or other electronic |
|
payment remittance and electronic payment status reports; and |
|
(2) encourage providers through the use of incentives |
|
to submit claims and prior authorization requests electronically to |
|
help promote faster response times and reduce the administrative |
|
costs related to paper claims processing. |
|
SECTION 6. Subchapter B, Chapter 531, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Sections 531.024162 and 531.024163 to read as |
|
follows: |
|
Sec. 531.024162. NOTICE REQUIREMENTS REGARDING MEDICAID |
|
COVERAGE OR PRIOR AUTHORIZATION DENIAL AND INCOMPLETE REQUESTS. |
|
(a) The commission shall ensure that notice sent by the commission |
|
or a Medicaid managed care organization to a Medicaid recipient or |
|
provider regarding the denial of coverage or prior authorization |
|
for a service includes: |
|
(1) information required by federal and state law; |
|
(2) for the recipient, a clear and easy-to-understand |
|
explanation of the reason for the denial; and |
|
(3) for the provider, a thorough and detailed clinical |
|
explanation of the reason for the denial, including, as applicable, |
|
information required under Subsection (b). |
|
(b) The commission or a Medicaid managed care organization |
|
that receives from a provider a coverage or prior authorization |
|
request that contains insufficient or inadequate documentation to |
|
approve the request shall issue a notice to the provider and the |
|
Medicaid recipient on whose behalf the request was submitted. The |
|
notice issued under this subsection must: |
|
(1) include a section specifically for the provider |
|
that contains: |
|
(A) a clear and specific list and description of |
|
the documentation necessary for the commission or organization to |
|
make a final determination on the request; |
|
(B) the applicable timeline, based on the |
|
requested service, for the provider to submit the documentation and |
|
a description of the reconsideration process described by Section |
|
533.00284, if applicable; and |
|
(C) information on the manner through which a |
|
provider may contact a Medicaid managed care organization or other |
|
entity as required by Section 531.024163; and |
|
(2) be sent to the provider: |
|
(A) using the provider's preferred method of |
|
contact most recently provided to the commission or the Medicaid |
|
managed care organization and using any alternative and known |
|
methods of contact; and |
|
(B) as applicable, through an electronic |
|
notification on an Internet portal. |
|
Sec. 531.024163. ACCESSIBILITY OF INFORMATION REGARDING |
|
MEDICAID PRIOR AUTHORIZATION REQUIREMENTS. (a) The executive |
|
commissioner by rule shall require each Medicaid managed care |
|
organization or other entity responsible for authorizing coverage |
|
for health care services under Medicaid to ensure that the |
|
organization or entity maintains on the organization's or entity's |
|
Internet website in an easily searchable and accessible format: |
|
(1) the applicable timelines for prior authorization |
|
requirements, including: |
|
(A) the time within which the organization or |
|
entity must make a determination on a prior authorization request; |
|
(B) a description of the communications the |
|
organization or entity provides to a provider and Medicaid |
|
recipient regarding the documentation required to complete a |
|
determination on a prior authorization request; and |
|
(C) the deadline by which the organization or |
|
entity is required to submit the communications described by |
|
Paragraph (B); and |
|
(2) an accurate and up-to-date catalogue of coverage |
|
criteria and prior authorization requirements, including: |
|
(A) for a prior authorization requirement first |
|
imposed on or after September 1, 2019, the effective date of the |
|
requirement; |
|
(B) a list or description of any necessary or |
|
supporting documentation necessary to obtain prior authorization |
|
for a specified service; and |
|
(C) the date and results of each review of the |
|
prior authorization requirement conducted under Section 533.00283, |
|
if applicable. |
|
(b) The executive commissioner by rule shall require each |
|
Medicaid managed care organization or other entity responsible for |
|
authorizing coverage for health care services under Medicaid to: |
|
(1) adopt and maintain a process for a provider or |
|
Medicaid recipient to contact the organization or entity to clarify |
|
prior authorization requirements or assist the provider or |
|
recipient in submitting a prior authorization request; and |
|
(2) ensure that the process described by Subdivision |
|
(1) is not arduous or overly burdensome to a provider or recipient. |
|
SECTION 7. Section 531.0317, Government Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subsections (c-1) and (c-2) to read as follows: |
|
(c-1) For the portion of the Internet site relating to |
|
Medicaid, the commission shall: |
|
(1) ensure the information is accessible and usable; |
|
(2) publish Medicaid managed care organization |
|
performance measures; and |
|
(3) organize and maintain that portion of the Internet |
|
site in a manner that serves Medicaid recipients, providers, and |
|
managed care organizations, stakeholders, and the public. |
|
(c-2) The commission shall establish and maintain an |
|
interactive public portal on the Internet site that incorporates |
|
data collected under Section 533.026 to allow Medicaid recipients |
|
to compare Medicaid managed care organizations within a service |
|
region. |
|
SECTION 8. Section 531.073, Government Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subsection (k) to read as follows: |
|
(k) The commission, in consultation with physicians and |
|
Medicaid managed care organizations, annually shall review prior |
|
authorization requirements in the Medicaid vendor drug program and |
|
determine whether to change, update, or delete any of the |
|
requirements based on publicly available, up-to-date, |
|
evidence-based, and peer-reviewed clinical criteria. |
|
SECTION 9. Section 531.076, Government Code, is amended by |
|
amending Subsection (b) and adding Subsections (c), (d), (e), (f), |
|
(g), (h), (i), (j), (k), (l), and (m) to read as follows: |
|
(b) The commission shall monitor Medicaid managed care |
|
organizations to ensure that the organizations: |
|
(1) are using prior authorization and utilization |
|
review processes to reduce authorizations of unnecessary services |
|
and inappropriate use of services; and |
|
(2) are not using prior authorization to negatively |
|
impact recipients' access to care. |
|
(c) The commission shall monitor whether a Medicaid managed |
|
care organization complies with applicable laws and rules in |
|
establishing prior authorization requirements. |
|
(d) The commission shall hold a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization accountable for services and coordination the |
|
organization is by contract required to provide. |
|
(e) The commission annually shall review a Medicaid managed |
|
care organization's prior authorization requirements and recommend |
|
whether the organization should change, update, or delete any of |
|
those requirements based on publicly available, up-to-date, |
|
evidence-based, and peer-reviewed clinical criteria. |
|
(f) To enable the commission to increase the commission's |
|
utilization review resources with respect to Medicaid managed care |
|
organization performance, the commission shall: |
|
(1) increase the sample size and types of services |
|
subject to utilization review to ensure an adequate and |
|
representative sample; |
|
(2) use a data-driven approach, including considering |
|
data on provider grievances filed with the office of ombudsman for |
|
Medicaid providers, to efficiently select cases for utilization |
|
review that aligns with the commission's priorities for improved |
|
outcomes; and |
|
(3) use additional national measures the commission |
|
considers appropriate. |
|
(g) Before posting on the commission's Internet website the |
|
findings of a Medicaid managed care organization's utilization |
|
review performance or assessing liquidated damages related to that |
|
performance, the commission shall allow the organization to review |
|
and dispute the findings and discuss concerns with the commission. |
|
The commission shall document comments from the organization not |
|
later than the 60th day after the date the comments are received. |
|
The commission shall post the comments along with the utilization |
|
review findings. |
|
(h) The commission shall request information regarding and |
|
review the outcomes and timeliness of a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's prior authorizations to determine for particular |
|
service requests: |
|
(1) the number of service hours and units requested, |
|
delivered, and billed; |
|
(2) whether the organization denied, approved, or |
|
amended the prior authorization request; and |
|
(3) whether a denied prior authorization request |
|
resulted in an internal appeal or a review by the external medical |
|
reviewer described by Section 533.00715 and the final decision in |
|
the appeal or review. |
|
(i) The executive commissioner by rule shall determine the |
|
frequency with which the commission may request information under |
|
Subsection (h). |
|
(j) The commission may: |
|
(1) require an assessment of a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's employee who conducts utilization review to ensure |
|
the employee's decisions and assessments are consistent with those |
|
of other employees, clinical criteria, and guidelines; |
|
(2) require the organization to provide a sample case |
|
to: |
|
(A) test how the organization conducts service |
|
planning and utilization review; and |
|
(B) determine whether the organization is |
|
following the organization's utilization management policies and |
|
procedures as expressed in the contract between the organization |
|
and the commission, the organization's patient handbook, and other |
|
publicly available written documents; and |
|
(3) randomly select an employee to test how the |
|
organization conducts service planning and utilization review, |
|
particularly in the: |
|
(A) STAR+PLUS Medicaid managed care program; |
|
(B) STAR Kids managed care program; and |
|
(C) STAR Health program. |
|
(k) To the extent feasible, the commission shall give |
|
guidance on aligning treatments and conditions subject to prior |
|
authorization to create uniformity among Medicaid managed care |
|
plans. The commission, in consultation with physicians, other |
|
relevant providers, and Medicaid managed care organizations, shall |
|
take into account differences in the region and recipient |
|
populations, including ages of those populations, served under a |
|
plan and other relevant factors. |
|
(l) The commission by rule shall require each Medicaid |
|
managed care organization to submit to the commission at least |
|
annually: |
|
(1) a list of the conditions and treatments subject to |
|
prior authorization under the managed care plan offered by the |
|
organization; |
|
(2) a specific description of the documentation the |
|
organization requires to approve a prior authorization request; |
|
(3) the effective date of each prior authorization |
|
requirement; |
|
(4) a description of the basis of each prior |
|
authorization requirement and the applicable medical screening |
|
criteria; and |
|
(5) the dates of each previous prior authorization |
|
review conducted under Subsection (e) and the results and findings |
|
of those reviews. |
|
(m) The commission shall develop a template for a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization to use to post prior authorization |
|
information on the organization's Internet website. |
|
SECTION 10. Section 533.00253, Government Code, is amended |
|
by adding Subsections (f), (g), and (h) to read as follows: |
|
(f) The commission shall ensure that the care coordinator |
|
for a Medicaid managed care organization under the STAR Kids |
|
managed care program offers a recipient's parent or legally |
|
authorized representative the opportunity to review the |
|
recipient's completed care needs assessment. The commission shall |
|
ensure the review does not delay the determination of the services |
|
to be provided to the recipient or the ability to authorize and |
|
initiate services. The commission shall require the parent's or |
|
representative's signature to verify the parent or representative |
|
received the opportunity to review the assessment with the care |
|
coordinator. A Medicaid managed care organization may not delay |
|
the delivery of care pending the signature. The commission shall |
|
provide a parent or representative who disagrees with a care needs |
|
assessment an opportunity to dispute the assessment with the |
|
commission through a peer-to-peer review with the treating |
|
physician of choice. |
|
(g) The commission, in consultation with stakeholders, |
|
shall redesign the care needs assessment used in the STAR Kids |
|
managed care program to ensure the assessment collects useable and |
|
actionable data pertinent to a child's physical, behavioral, and |
|
long-term care needs. This subsection expires September 1, 2021. |
|
(h) The advisory committee or a successor committee shall |
|
provide recommendations to the commission for the redesign of the |
|
private duty nursing assessment tools used in the STAR Kids managed |
|
care program based on observations from other states to be more |
|
comprehensive and allow for the streamlining of the documentation |
|
for prior authorization of private duty nursing. This subsection |
|
expires September 1, 2021. |
|
SECTION 11. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Sections 533.002533, 533.00271, 533.00282, |
|
533.00283, and 533.00284 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.002533. CONTINUATION OF STAR KIDS MANAGED CARE |
|
ADVISORY COMMITTEE. The commission shall periodically evaluate |
|
whether to continue the STAR Kids Managed Care Advisory Committee |
|
established under Section 531.012 as a forum to identify and make |
|
recommendations for resolving eligibility, clinical, and |
|
administrative issues with the STAR Kids managed care program. |
|
Sec. 533.00271. EXTERNAL QUALITY REVIEW ORGANIZATION: |
|
EVALUATION OF MEDICAID MANAGED CARE GENERALLY. (a) The commission |
|
annually shall identify and study areas of Medicaid managed care |
|
organization services for which the commission needs additional |
|
information. The external quality review organization annually |
|
shall study and report to the commission on at least three measures |
|
related to the identified areas and other measures the commission |
|
considers appropriate, which may include measures in the core set |
|
of children's health care quality measures or core set of adults' |
|
health care quality measures published by the United States |
|
Department of Health and Human Services. |
|
(b) The external quality review organization annually |
|
shall: |
|
(1) individually compare not-for-profit and |
|
for-profit managed care plans offered by Medicaid managed care |
|
organizations; and |
|
(2) report to the commission the comparison between |
|
those plans on the following under the plans: |
|
(A) rates of: |
|
(i) inquiries and complaints about access |
|
to a provider in an enrollee's local area; |
|
(ii) grievances, as defined by Section |
|
533.027, received by the commission; and |
|
(iii) service denials for Medicaid-covered |
|
services; |
|
(B) the number of Medicaid providers within a |
|
specific provider type in an enrollee's local area; |
|
(C) outcomes of internal appeals and external |
|
medical reviews, including the number of appeals reversed; |
|
(D) outcomes of fair hearing requests; |
|
(E) constituent complaints brought to the |
|
Medicaid managed care organization's attention by an individual or |
|
entity, including a state legislator or the commission; |
|
(F) provider opinions of the Medicaid managed |
|
care organization's quality; and |
|
(G) differences in Medicaid managed care |
|
business and operation practices that may contribute to differences |
|
in recipient medical acuity. |
|
(c) The commission shall require each Medicaid managed care |
|
organization to submit quarterly the information necessary to make |
|
the comparison described by Subsection (b). |
|
(d) The external quality review organization shall review |
|
aggregate denial data categorized by Medicaid managed care plan to |
|
identify trends and determine whether a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization is disproportionately denying prior authorization |
|
requests from a single provider or set of providers. |
|
(e) The external quality review organization shall conduct |
|
a study to determine whether Medicaid managed care organizations |
|
could provide care coordination remotely through technology, |
|
including synchronous audio-visual interaction. Not later than |
|
September 1, 2020, the external quality review organization shall |
|
prepare and submit a written report of the results of the study to |
|
the commission. This subsection expires September 1, 2021. |
|
Sec. 533.00282. UTILIZATION REVIEW AND PRIOR AUTHORIZATION |
|
PROCEDURES. In addition to the requirements of Section 533.005, a |
|
contract between a Medicaid managed care organization and the |
|
commission must require that: |
|
(1) before issuing an adverse determination on a prior |
|
authorization request, the organization provide the physician |
|
requesting the prior authorization with a reasonable opportunity to |
|
discuss the request with another physician who practices in the |
|
same or a similar specialty, but not necessarily the same |
|
subspecialty, and has experience in treating the same category of |
|
population as the recipient on whose behalf the request is |
|
submitted; |
|
(2) the organization review and issue determinations |
|
on prior authorization requests according to the following time |
|
frames: |
|
(A) with respect to a recipient who is |
|
hospitalized at the time of the request: |
|
(i) within one business day after receiving |
|
the request, except as provided by Subparagraphs (ii) and (iii); |
|
(ii) within 72 hours after receiving the |
|
request if the request is submitted by a provider of acute care |
|
inpatient services for services or equipment necessary to discharge |
|
the recipient from an inpatient facility; or |
|
(iii) within one hour after receiving the |
|
request if the request is related to poststabilization care or a |
|
life-threatening condition; or |
|
(B) with respect to a recipient who is not |
|
hospitalized at the time of the request, within three business days |
|
after receiving the request; and |
|
(3) the organization: |
|
(A) have appropriate personnel reasonably |
|
available at a toll-free telephone number to respond to a prior |
|
authorization request between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. central time Monday |
|
through Friday on each day that is not a legal holiday and between 9 |
|
a.m. and noon central time on Saturday, Sunday, and legal holidays; |
|
(B) have a telephone system capable of receiving |
|
and recording incoming telephone calls for prior authorization |
|
requests after 6 p.m. central time Monday through Friday and after |
|
noon central time on Saturday, Sunday, and legal holidays; and |
|
(C) have appropriate personnel to respond to each |
|
call described by Paragraph (B) not later than 24 hours after |
|
receiving the call. |
|
Sec. 533.00283. ANNUAL REVIEW OF PRIOR AUTHORIZATION |
|
REQUIREMENTS. (a) Each Medicaid managed care organization shall |
|
develop and implement a process to conduct an annual review of the |
|
organization's prior authorization requirements, other than a |
|
prior authorization requirement prescribed by or implemented under |
|
Section 531.073 for the vendor drug program. In conducting a |
|
review, the organization must: |
|
(1) solicit, receive, and consider input from |
|
providers in the organization's provider network; and |
|
(2) ensure that each prior authorization requirement |
|
is based on accurate, up-to-date, evidence-based, and |
|
peer-reviewed clinical criteria that distinguish, as appropriate, |
|
between categories, including age, of recipients for whom prior |
|
authorization requests are submitted. |
|
(b) A Medicaid managed care organization may not impose a |
|
prior authorization requirement, other than a prior authorization |
|
requirement prescribed by or implemented under Section 531.073 for |
|
the vendor drug program, unless the organization has reviewed the |
|
requirement during the most recent annual review required under |
|
this section. |
|
Sec. 533.00284. RECONSIDERATION FOLLOWING ADVERSE |
|
DETERMINATIONS ON CERTAIN PRIOR AUTHORIZATION REQUESTS. (a) In |
|
addition to the requirements of Section 533.005, a contract between |
|
a Medicaid managed care organization and the commission must |
|
include a requirement that the organization establish a process for |
|
reconsidering an adverse determination on a prior authorization |
|
request that resulted solely from the submission of insufficient or |
|
inadequate documentation. |
|
(b) The process for reconsidering an adverse determination |
|
on a prior authorization request under this section must: |
|
(1) allow a provider to, not later than the seventh |
|
business day following the date of the determination, submit any |
|
documentation that was identified as insufficient or inadequate in |
|
the notice provided under Section 531.024162; |
|
(2) allow the physician requesting the prior |
|
authorization to discuss the request with another physician who |
|
practices in the same or a similar specialty, but not necessarily |
|
the same subspecialty, and has experience in treating the same |
|
category of population as the recipient on whose behalf the request |
|
is submitted; and |
|
(3) require the Medicaid managed care organization to, |
|
not later than the first business day following the date the |
|
provider submits sufficient and adequate documentation under |
|
Subdivision (1), amend the determination to approve the prior |
|
authorization request. |
|
(c) An adverse determination on a prior authorization |
|
request is considered a denial of services in an evaluation of the |
|
Medicaid managed care organization only if the determination is not |
|
amended under Subsection (b)(3). |
|
(d) The process for reconsidering an adverse determination |
|
on a prior authorization request under this section does not |
|
affect: |
|
(1) any related timelines, including the timeline for |
|
an internal appeal, an external medical review, or a Medicaid fair |
|
hearing; or |
|
(2) any rights of a recipient to appeal a |
|
determination on a prior authorization request. |
|
SECTION 12. Section 533.005, Government Code, is amended by |
|
amending Subsection (a) and adding Subsection (g) to read as |
|
follows: |
|
(a) A contract between a managed care organization and the |
|
commission for the organization to provide health care services to |
|
recipients must contain: |
|
(1) procedures to ensure accountability to the state |
|
for the provision of health care services, including procedures for |
|
financial reporting, quality assurance, utilization review, and |
|
assurance of contract and subcontract compliance; |
|
(2) capitation rates that ensure the cost-effective |
|
provision of quality health care; |
|
(3) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
provide ready access to a person who assists recipients in |
|
resolving issues relating to enrollment, plan administration, |
|
education and training, access to services, and grievance |
|
procedures; |
|
(4) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
provide ready access to a person who assists providers in resolving |
|
issues relating to payment, plan administration, education and |
|
training, and grievance procedures; |
|
(5) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
provide information and referral about the availability of |
|
educational, social, and other community services that could |
|
benefit a recipient; |
|
(6) procedures for recipient outreach and education; |
|
(7) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
make payment to a physician or provider for health care services |
|
rendered to a recipient under a managed care plan on any claim for |
|
payment after receiving the claim and [that is received with] |
|
documentation reasonably necessary for the managed care |
|
organization to process the claim: |
|
(A) not later than: |
|
(i) the 10th day after the date the claim is |
|
received if the claim relates to services provided by a nursing |
|
facility, intermediate care facility, or group home; |
|
(ii) the 30th day after the date the claim |
|
is received if the claim relates to the provision of long-term |
|
services and supports not subject to Subparagraph (i); and |
|
(iii) the 45th day after the date the claim |
|
is received if the claim is not subject to Subparagraph (i) or (ii); |
|
or |
|
(B) within a period, not to exceed 60 days, |
|
specified by a written agreement between the physician or provider |
|
and the managed care organization; |
|
(7-a) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
demonstrate to the commission that the organization pays claims |
|
described by Subdivision (7)(A)(ii) on average not later than the |
|
21st day after the date the claim is received by the organization; |
|
(8) a requirement that the commission, on the date of a |
|
recipient's enrollment in a managed care plan issued by the managed |
|
care organization, inform the organization of the recipient's |
|
Medicaid certification date; |
|
(9) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
comply with Section 533.006 as a condition of contract retention |
|
and renewal; |
|
(10) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
provide the information required by Section 533.012 and otherwise |
|
comply and cooperate with the commission's office of inspector |
|
general and the office of the attorney general; |
|
(11) a requirement that the managed care |
|
organization's usages of out-of-network providers or groups of |
|
out-of-network providers may not exceed limits for those usages |
|
relating to total inpatient admissions, total outpatient services, |
|
and emergency room admissions determined by the commission; |
|
(12) if the commission finds that a managed care |
|
organization has violated Subdivision (11), a requirement that the |
|
managed care organization reimburse an out-of-network provider for |
|
health care services at a rate that is equal to the allowable rate |
|
for those services, as determined under Sections 32.028 and |
|
32.0281, Human Resources Code; |
|
(13) a requirement that, notwithstanding any other |
|
law, including Sections 843.312 and 1301.052, Insurance Code, the |
|
organization: |
|
(A) use advanced practice registered nurses and |
|
physician assistants in addition to physicians as primary care |
|
providers to increase the availability of primary care providers in |
|
the organization's provider network; and |
|
(B) treat advanced practice registered nurses |
|
and physician assistants in the same manner as primary care |
|
physicians with regard to: |
|
(i) selection and assignment as primary |
|
care providers; |
|
(ii) inclusion as primary care providers in |
|
the organization's provider network; and |
|
(iii) inclusion as primary care providers |
|
in any provider network directory maintained by the organization; |
|
(14) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
reimburse a federally qualified health center or rural health |
|
clinic for health care services provided to a recipient outside of |
|
regular business hours, including on a weekend day or holiday, at a |
|
rate that is equal to the allowable rate for those services as |
|
determined under Section 32.028, Human Resources Code, if the |
|
recipient does not have a referral from the recipient's primary |
|
care physician; |
|
(15) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
develop, implement, and maintain a system for tracking and |
|
resolving all provider appeals related to claims payment, including |
|
a process that will require: |
|
(A) a tracking mechanism to document the status |
|
and final disposition of each provider's claims payment appeal; |
|
(B) the contracting with physicians who are not |
|
network providers and who are of the same or related specialty as |
|
the appealing physician to resolve claims disputes related to |
|
denial on the basis of medical necessity that remain unresolved |
|
subsequent to a provider appeal; |
|
(C) the determination of the physician resolving |
|
the dispute to be binding on the managed care organization and |
|
provider; and |
|
(D) the managed care organization to allow a |
|
provider with a claim that has not been paid before the time |
|
prescribed by Subdivision (7)(A)(ii) to initiate an appeal of that |
|
claim; |
|
(16) a requirement that a medical director who is |
|
authorized to make medical necessity determinations is available to |
|
the region where the managed care organization provides health care |
|
services; |
|
(17) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
ensure that a medical director and patient care coordinators and |
|
provider and recipient support services personnel are located in |
|
the South Texas service region, if the managed care organization |
|
provides a managed care plan in that region; |
|
(18) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
provide special programs and materials for recipients with limited |
|
English proficiency or low literacy skills; |
|
(19) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
develop and establish a process for responding to provider appeals |
|
in the region where the organization provides health care services; |
|
(20) a requirement that the managed care organization: |
|
(A) develop and submit to the commission, before |
|
the organization begins to provide health care services to |
|
recipients, a comprehensive plan that describes how the |
|
organization's provider network complies with the provider access |
|
standards established under Section 533.0061; |
|
(B) as a condition of contract retention and |
|
renewal: |
|
(i) continue to comply with the provider |
|
access standards established under Section 533.0061; and |
|
(ii) make substantial efforts, as |
|
determined by the commission, to mitigate or remedy any |
|
noncompliance with the provider access standards established under |
|
Section 533.0061; |
|
(C) pay liquidated damages for each failure, as |
|
determined by the commission, to comply with the provider access |
|
standards established under Section 533.0061 in amounts that are |
|
reasonably related to the noncompliance; and |
|
(D) regularly, as determined by the commission, |
|
submit to the commission and make available to the public a report |
|
containing data on the sufficiency of the organization's provider |
|
network with regard to providing the care and services described |
|
under Section 533.0061(a-1) [533.0061(a)] and specific data with |
|
respect to access to primary care, specialty care, long-term |
|
services and supports, nursing services, and therapy services on |
|
the average length of time between: |
|
(i) the date a provider requests prior |
|
authorization for the care or service and the date the organization |
|
approves or denies the request; and |
|
(ii) the date the organization approves a |
|
request for prior authorization for the care or service and the date |
|
the care or service is initiated; |
|
(21) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
demonstrate to the commission, before the organization begins to |
|
provide health care services to recipients, that, subject to the |
|
provider access standards established under Section 533.0061: |
|
(A) the organization's provider network has the |
|
capacity to serve the number of recipients expected to enroll in a |
|
managed care plan offered by the organization; |
|
(B) the organization's provider network |
|
includes: |
|
(i) a sufficient number of primary care |
|
providers; |
|
(ii) a sufficient variety of provider |
|
types; |
|
(iii) a sufficient number of providers of |
|
long-term services and supports and specialty pediatric care |
|
providers of home and community-based services; and |
|
(iv) providers located throughout the |
|
region where the organization will provide health care services; |
|
and |
|
(C) health care services will be accessible to |
|
recipients through the organization's provider network to a |
|
comparable extent that health care services would be available to |
|
recipients under a fee-for-service or primary care case management |
|
model of Medicaid managed care; |
|
(22) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
develop a monitoring program for measuring the quality of the |
|
[health care] services provided by the organization's provider |
|
network that: |
|
(A) incorporates the National Committee for |
|
Quality Assurance's Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information |
|
Set (HEDIS) measures or, as applicable, the national core |
|
indicators adult consumer survey and the national core indicators |
|
child family survey for individuals with an intellectual or |
|
developmental disability; |
|
(B) focuses on measuring outcomes; and |
|
(C) includes the collection and analysis of |
|
clinical data relating to prenatal care, preventive care, mental |
|
health care, and the treatment of acute and chronic health |
|
conditions and substance abuse; |
|
(23) subject to Subsection (a-1), a requirement that |
|
the managed care organization develop, implement, and maintain an |
|
outpatient pharmacy benefit plan for its enrolled recipients: |
|
(A) that exclusively employs the vendor drug |
|
program formulary and preserves the state's ability to reduce |
|
waste, fraud, and abuse under Medicaid; |
|
(B) that adheres to the applicable preferred drug |
|
list adopted by the commission under Section 531.072; |
|
(C) that includes the prior authorization |
|
procedures and requirements prescribed by or implemented under |
|
Sections 531.073(b), (c), and (g) for the vendor drug program; |
|
(D) for purposes of which the managed care |
|
organization: |
|
(i) may not negotiate or collect rebates |
|
associated with pharmacy products on the vendor drug program |
|
formulary; and |
|
(ii) may not receive drug rebate or pricing |
|
information that is confidential under Section 531.071; |
|
(E) that complies with the prohibition under |
|
Section 531.089; |
|
(F) under which the managed care organization may |
|
not prohibit, limit, or interfere with a recipient's selection of a |
|
pharmacy or pharmacist of the recipient's choice for the provision |
|
of pharmaceutical services under the plan through the imposition of |
|
different copayments; |
|
(G) that allows the managed care organization or |
|
any subcontracted pharmacy benefit manager to contract with a |
|
pharmacist or pharmacy providers separately for specialty pharmacy |
|
services, except that: |
|
(i) the managed care organization and |
|
pharmacy benefit manager are prohibited from allowing exclusive |
|
contracts with a specialty pharmacy owned wholly or partly by the |
|
pharmacy benefit manager responsible for the administration of the |
|
pharmacy benefit program; and |
|
(ii) the managed care organization and |
|
pharmacy benefit manager must adopt policies and procedures for |
|
reclassifying prescription drugs from retail to specialty drugs, |
|
and those policies and procedures must be consistent with rules |
|
adopted by the executive commissioner and include notice to network |
|
pharmacy providers from the managed care organization; |
|
(H) under which the managed care organization may |
|
not prevent a pharmacy or pharmacist from participating as a |
|
provider if the pharmacy or pharmacist agrees to comply with the |
|
financial terms and conditions of the contract as well as other |
|
reasonable administrative and professional terms and conditions of |
|
the contract; |
|
(I) under which the managed care organization may |
|
include mail-order pharmacies in its networks, but may not require |
|
enrolled recipients to use those pharmacies, and may not charge an |
|
enrolled recipient who opts to use this service a fee, including |
|
postage and handling fees; |
|
(J) under which the managed care organization or |
|
pharmacy benefit manager, as applicable, must pay claims in |
|
accordance with Section 843.339, Insurance Code; and |
|
(K) under which the managed care organization or |
|
pharmacy benefit manager, as applicable: |
|
(i) to place a drug on a maximum allowable |
|
cost list, must ensure that: |
|
(a) the drug is listed as "A" or "B" |
|
rated in the most recent version of the United States Food and Drug |
|
Administration's Approved Drug Products with Therapeutic |
|
Equivalence Evaluations, also known as the Orange Book, has an "NR" |
|
or "NA" rating or a similar rating by a nationally recognized |
|
reference; and |
|
(b) the drug is generally available |
|
for purchase by pharmacies in the state from national or regional |
|
wholesalers and is not obsolete; |
|
(ii) must provide to a network pharmacy |
|
provider, at the time a contract is entered into or renewed with the |
|
network pharmacy provider, the sources used to determine the |
|
maximum allowable cost pricing for the maximum allowable cost list |
|
specific to that provider; |
|
(iii) must review and update maximum |
|
allowable cost price information at least once every seven days to |
|
reflect any modification of maximum allowable cost pricing; |
|
(iv) must, in formulating the maximum |
|
allowable cost price for a drug, use only the price of the drug and |
|
drugs listed as therapeutically equivalent in the most recent |
|
version of the United States Food and Drug Administration's |
|
Approved Drug Products with Therapeutic Equivalence Evaluations, |
|
also known as the Orange Book; |
|
(v) must establish a process for |
|
eliminating products from the maximum allowable cost list or |
|
modifying maximum allowable cost prices in a timely manner to |
|
remain consistent with pricing changes and product availability in |
|
the marketplace; |
|
(vi) must: |
|
(a) provide a procedure under which a |
|
network pharmacy provider may challenge a listed maximum allowable |
|
cost price for a drug; |
|
(b) respond to a challenge not later |
|
than the 15th day after the date the challenge is made; |
|
(c) if the challenge is successful, |
|
make an adjustment in the drug price effective on the date the |
|
challenge is resolved[,] and make the adjustment applicable to all |
|
similarly situated network pharmacy providers, as determined by the |
|
managed care organization or pharmacy benefit manager, as |
|
appropriate; |
|
(d) if the challenge is denied, |
|
provide the reason for the denial; and |
|
(e) report to the commission every 90 |
|
days the total number of challenges that were made and denied in the |
|
preceding 90-day period for each maximum allowable cost list drug |
|
for which a challenge was denied during the period; |
|
(vii) must notify the commission not later |
|
than the 21st day after implementing a practice of using a maximum |
|
allowable cost list for drugs dispensed at retail but not by mail; |
|
and |
|
(viii) must provide a process for each of |
|
its network pharmacy providers to readily access the maximum |
|
allowable cost list specific to that provider; |
|
(24) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
and any entity with which the managed care organization contracts |
|
for the performance of services under a managed care plan disclose, |
|
at no cost, to the commission and, on request, the office of the |
|
attorney general all discounts, incentives, rebates, fees, free |
|
goods, bundling arrangements, and other agreements affecting the |
|
net cost of goods or services provided under the plan; |
|
(25) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
not implement significant, nonnegotiated, across-the-board |
|
provider reimbursement rate reductions unless: |
|
(A) subject to Subsection (a-3), the |
|
organization has the prior approval of the commission to make the |
|
reductions [reduction]; or |
|
(B) the rate reductions are based on changes to |
|
the Medicaid fee schedule or cost containment initiatives |
|
implemented by the commission; [and] |
|
(26) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
make initial and subsequent primary care provider assignments and |
|
changes; |
|
(27) a requirement that the managed care organization: |
|
(A) not deny a reasonable prior authorization |
|
request or claim for a technical or minimal error; and |
|
(B) not abuse the appeals or external medical |
|
review process to deter a recipient or provider from requesting |
|
health care services; |
|
(28) a requirement that the managed care organization: |
|
(A) automatically, without a request from a |
|
recipient or program, continue to provide the pre-reduction or |
|
pre-denial level of services to the recipient during an internal |
|
appeal or a review by the external medical reviewer described by |
|
Section 533.00715 of a reduction in or denial of services, unless |
|
the recipient or the recipient's parent on behalf of the recipient |
|
opts out of the automatic continuation of services; and |
|
(B) provide the commission and the recipient with |
|
a notice of continuing services; |
|
(29) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
comply with the external medical review procedure established under |
|
Section 533.00715 and comply with the external medical reviewer's |
|
determination; and |
|
(30) a requirement that the managed care organization |
|
pay liquidated damages for each substantiated failure to adhere to |
|
contractual requirements. |
|
(g) The commission shall provide guidance and additional |
|
education to managed care organizations regarding requirements |
|
under federal law and Subsection (a)(28) to continue to provide |
|
services during an internal appeal, an external medical review, and |
|
a Medicaid fair hearing. |
|
SECTION 13. Section 533.0051, Government Code, is amended |
|
by adding Subsection (h) to read as follows: |
|
(h) To monitor performance measures, the commission shall |
|
develop a data-sharing platform that enables divisions within the |
|
commission to electronically view data and access data analysis in |
|
a single location. |
|
SECTION 14. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 533.0058 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0058. INITIAL THERAPY EVALUATION IN CERTAIN |
|
MANAGED CARE PROGRAMS. A Medicaid managed care organization that |
|
provides health care services under the STAR Health program or the |
|
STAR Kids managed care program may require prior authorization for |
|
an initial therapy evaluation for a recipient only if the |
|
requirement aligns with clinical criteria. |
|
SECTION 15. The heading to Section 533.0061, Government |
|
Code, is amended to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0061. PROVIDER ACCESS STANDARDS AND NETWORK |
|
ADEQUACY; REPORT. |
|
SECTION 16. Section 533.0061, Government Code, is amended |
|
by amending Subsection (a) and adding Subsections (a-1), (b-1), |
|
(b-2), (b-3), (b-4), (d), and (e) to read as follows: |
|
(a) In this section: |
|
(1) "Access to care" means access to care and services |
|
available under Medicaid at least to the same extent that similar |
|
care and services are available to the general population in the |
|
recipient's geographic area. |
|
(2) "Network adequacy" means the adequacy of a |
|
Medicaid managed care organization's provider network determined |
|
according to standards established by federal law. |
|
(a-1) The commission shall establish minimum provider |
|
access standards for the provider network of a managed care |
|
organization that contracts with the commission to provide health |
|
care services to recipients. The access standards must ensure that |
|
a Medicaid managed care organization provides recipients |
|
sufficient access to: |
|
(1) preventive care; |
|
(2) primary care; |
|
(3) specialty care; |
|
(4) after-hours urgent care; |
|
(5) chronic care; |
|
(6) long-term services and supports; |
|
(7) nursing services; |
|
(8) therapy services, including services provided in a |
|
clinical setting or in a home or community-based setting; and |
|
(9) any other services identified by the commission. |
|
(b-1) Except as provided by Subsection (b-4), the |
|
commission shall use travel time and distance standards to measure |
|
network adequacy. |
|
(b-2) In determining network adequacy, the commission shall |
|
use automated data validation and calculation tools to decrease |
|
processing time and resources required for calculating provider |
|
distance and travel time. The commission shall use Medicaid |
|
managed care organization contract data to validate network |
|
adequacy determinations. |
|
(b-3) The commission shall integrate access to care data |
|
with network adequacy data to evaluate and monitor provider network |
|
adequacy based on both provider location and availability. |
|
(b-4) To account for differences in recipient population |
|
and provider entity size, the commission shall establish provider |
|
network adequacy standards, other than travel time and distance |
|
standards, applicable in assessing the network adequacy for |
|
personal care attendants and licensed providers of home and |
|
community-based services in the home who travel to a recipient to |
|
provide care. The commission shall develop and implement a process |
|
to assist Medicaid managed care organizations in implementing the |
|
network adequacy standards. The external quality review |
|
organization shall periodically evaluate and report to the |
|
commission on personal care attendant network adequacy. |
|
(d) The executive commissioner by rule shall ensure that an |
|
evaluation of a Medicaid managed care organization's provider |
|
network adequacy conducted by the commission or the external |
|
quality review organization with information obtained from a |
|
managed care organization's provider network directory is based on |
|
the total number of providers listed in the directory. The |
|
commission or external quality review organization must consider a |
|
provider with incorrect contact information or who is no longer |
|
participating in Medicaid as having no appointment availability for |
|
purposes of the evaluation. |
|
(e) The external quality review organization shall use |
|
existing encounter data to monitor a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's network adequacy and the accuracy of the |
|
organization's provider directories. |
|
SECTION 17. Section 533.0063, Government Code, is amended |
|
by adding Subsections (d) and (e) to read as follows: |
|
(d) The commission shall use the commission's master file of |
|
Medicaid providers to validate the provider network directory of a |
|
managed care organization described by Subsection (a). The |
|
commission shall establish a procedure to ensure the commission's |
|
master file of Medicaid providers is accurate and up-to-date. |
|
(e) The commission shall prepare and submit to the |
|
legislature not later than December 1, 2020, a report describing |
|
the procedure required by Subsection (d) and how the procedure |
|
improves the current method of verifying and updating provider |
|
lists and the master file described by that subsection. This |
|
subsection expires September 1, 2021. |
|
SECTION 18. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 533.00661 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.00661. PROVIDER INCENTIVES: SELECTIVE PRIOR |
|
AUTHORIZATION REQUIREMENTS. (a) The commission may implement |
|
quality-based incentives designed to reduce the administrative |
|
burdens and number of prior authorization requirements for |
|
providers who are providing appropriate, quality care. The |
|
commission may include incentives under which Medicaid managed care |
|
organizations selectively require prior authorization for services |
|
ordered by providers based on provider performance on quality |
|
measures and adherence to evidence-based medicine or other |
|
contractual agreements, such as risk-sharing arrangements. |
|
(b) Criteria for selectively requiring prior authorization |
|
described by Subsection (a) may include ordering or prescribing |
|
patterns that align with evidence-based guidelines or historically |
|
high prior authorization request approval rates. |
|
(c) As part of the incentives under this section, the |
|
commission may encourage Medicaid managed care organizations to: |
|
(1) use programs that selectively require prior |
|
authorization based on classifications of provider performance and |
|
adherence to evidence-based medicine; |
|
(2) develop criteria, with the input of the providers |
|
or provider organizations, for the selection of providers to |
|
participate in the selective prior authorization programs and for |
|
their continued participation in the programs; |
|
(3) make the criteria described by Subdivision (2) |
|
transparent and easily accessible to providers; and |
|
(4) make appropriate adjustments to prior |
|
authorization requirements for providers participating in |
|
risk-based payment contracts. |
|
SECTION 19. Section 533.0071, Government Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0071. ADMINISTRATION OF CONTRACTS. (a) The |
|
commission shall make every effort to improve the administration of |
|
contracts with Medicaid managed care organizations. To improve the |
|
administration of these contracts, the commission shall: |
|
(1) ensure that the commission has appropriate |
|
expertise and qualified staff to effectively manage contracts with |
|
managed care organizations under the Medicaid managed care program; |
|
(2) evaluate options for Medicaid payment recovery |
|
from managed care organizations if the enrollee dies or is |
|
incarcerated or if an enrollee is enrolled in more than one state |
|
program or is covered by another liable third party insurer; |
|
(3) maximize Medicaid payment recovery options by |
|
contracting with private vendors to assist in the recovery of |
|
capitation payments, payments from other liable third parties, and |
|
other payments made to managed care organizations with respect to |
|
enrollees who leave the managed care program; and |
|
(4) decrease the administrative burdens of managed |
|
care for the state, the managed care organizations, and the |
|
providers under managed care networks to the extent that those |
|
changes are compatible with state law and existing Medicaid managed |
|
care contracts, including decreasing those burdens by: |
|
(A) where possible, decreasing the duplication |
|
of administrative reporting and process requirements for the |
|
managed care organizations and providers, such as requirements for |
|
the submission of encounter data, quality reports, historically |
|
underutilized business reports, and claims payment summary |
|
reports; |
|
(B) allowing managed care organizations to |
|
provide updated address information directly to the commission for |
|
correction in the state system; |
|
(C) promoting consistency and uniformity among |
|
managed care organization policies, including policies relating to |
|
the preauthorization process, lengths of hospital stays, filing |
|
deadlines, levels of care, and case management services; |
|
(D) reviewing the appropriateness of primary |
|
care case management requirements in the admission and clinical |
|
criteria process, such as requirements relating to including a |
|
separate cover sheet for all communications, submitting |
|
handwritten communications instead of electronic or typed review |
|
processes, and admitting patients listed on separate |
|
notifications; and |
|
(E) providing a portal through which providers in |
|
any managed care organization's provider network may submit acute |
|
care services and long-term services and supports claims[; and
|
|
[(5)
reserve the right to amend the managed care
|
|
organization's process for resolving provider appeals of denials
|
|
based on medical necessity to include an independent review process
|
|
established by the commission for final determination of these
|
|
disputes]. |
|
(b) For a contract described by Subsection (a), the |
|
commission shall: |
|
(1) automate the process for receiving and tracking |
|
contract amendment requests and incorporating an amendment into a |
|
contract; |
|
(2) make the most recent contract amendment |
|
information readily available among divisions within the |
|
commission; and |
|
(3) provide technical assistance and education to help |
|
a commission employee determine whether a requested contract |
|
amendment is necessary or whether the issue could be resolved |
|
through the uniform managed care manual, a memorandum, or guidance. |
|
(c) The commission shall create a summary compliance |
|
framework that summarizes contract provisions to help Medicaid |
|
managed care organizations comply with those provisions. |
|
(d) The commission shall annually review and assess |
|
contract deliverables and eliminate unnecessary deliverables for |
|
Medicaid managed care contracts. The commission may identify |
|
measures to strengthen the contract deliverables and implement |
|
those measures as needed. |
|
SECTION 20. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 533.00715 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.00715. EXTERNAL MEDICAL REVIEW. (a) In this |
|
section, "external medical reviewer" and "reviewer" mean a |
|
third-party medical review organization that provides objective, |
|
unbiased medical necessity determinations conducted by clinical |
|
staff with education and practice in the same or similar practice |
|
area as the procedure for which an independent determination of |
|
medical necessity is sought in accordance with applicable state law |
|
and rules. |
|
(b) The commission shall contract with an independent |
|
external medical reviewer to conduct external medical reviews and |
|
review: |
|
(1) the resolution of a recipient appeal related to a |
|
reduction in or denial of services on the basis of medical necessity |
|
in the Medicaid managed care program; or |
|
(2) a denial by the commission of eligibility for a |
|
Medicaid program in which eligibility is based on a recipient's |
|
medical and functional needs. |
|
(c) A Medicaid managed care organization may not have a |
|
financial relationship with or ownership interest in the external |
|
medical reviewer with which the commission contracts. |
|
(d) The external medical reviewer with which the commission |
|
contracts must: |
|
(1) be overseen by a medical director who is a |
|
physician licensed in this state; and |
|
(2) employ or be able to consult with staff with |
|
experience in providing private duty nursing services and long-term |
|
services and supports. |
|
(e) The commission shall establish a common procedure for |
|
reviews. The procedure must provide that a service ordered by a |
|
health care provider is presumed medically necessary and the |
|
Medicaid managed care organization bears the burden of proof to |
|
show the service is not medically necessary. Medical necessity |
|
must be based on publicly available, up-to-date, evidence-based, |
|
and peer-reviewed clinical criteria. The reviewer shall conduct |
|
the review within a period specified by the commission. The |
|
commission shall also establish a procedure for expedited reviews |
|
that allows the reviewer to identify an appeal that requires an |
|
expedited resolution. |
|
(f) An external medical review described by Subsection |
|
(b)(1) occurs after the internal Medicaid managed care organization |
|
appeal and before the Medicaid fair hearing and is granted when a |
|
recipient contests the internal appeal decision of the Medicaid |
|
managed care organization. An external medical review described by |
|
Subsection (b)(2) occurs after the eligibility denial and before |
|
the Medicaid fair hearing. The recipient or applicant, or the |
|
recipient's or applicant's parent or legally authorized |
|
representative, must affirmatively opt out of the external medical |
|
review to proceed to a Medicaid fair hearing without first |
|
participating in the external medical review. |
|
(g) The external medical reviewer's determination of |
|
medical necessity establishes the minimum level of services a |
|
recipient must receive. |
|
(h) The external medical reviewer shall require a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization, in an external medical review relating |
|
to a reduction in services, to submit a detailed reason for the |
|
reduction and supporting documents. |
|
(i) The external medical reviewer shall establish and |
|
maintain an Internet portal through which a recipient may track the |
|
status and final disposition of a review. |
|
(j) The external medical reviewer shall educate recipients |
|
and employees of Medicaid managed care organizations regarding |
|
appeal and review processes, options, and proper and improper |
|
denials of services on the basis of medical necessity. |
|
SECTION 21. The heading to Section 533.0072, Government |
|
Code, is amended to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0072. CORRECTIVE ACTION PLANS AND [INTERNET
|
|
POSTING OF] SANCTIONS IMPOSED FOR CONTRACTUAL VIOLATIONS. |
|
SECTION 22. Section 533.0072, Government Code, is amended |
|
by amending Subsections (a), (b), and (c) and adding Subsections |
|
(b-1) and (b-2) to read as follows: |
|
(a) The commission shall prepare and maintain a record of |
|
each enforcement action initiated by the commission [that results
|
|
in a sanction, including a penalty, being imposed] against a |
|
managed care organization for failure to comply with the terms of a |
|
contract to provide health care services to recipients through a |
|
managed care plan issued by the organization, including: |
|
(1) an enforcement action that results in a sanction, |
|
including a penalty; |
|
(2) the imposition of a corrective action plan; |
|
(3) the imposition of liquidated damages; |
|
(4) the suspension of default enrollment; and |
|
(5) the termination of the organization's contract. |
|
(b) The record must include: |
|
(1) the name and address of the organization; |
|
(2) a description of the contractual obligation the |
|
organization failed to meet; |
|
(3) the date of determination of noncompliance; |
|
(4) the date the sanction was imposed, if applicable; |
|
(5) the maximum sanction that may be imposed under the |
|
contract for the violation, if applicable; and |
|
(6) the actual sanction imposed against the |
|
organization, if applicable. |
|
(b-1) In assessing liquidated damages against a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization, the commission shall: |
|
(1) include in the record prepared under Subsection |
|
(a): |
|
(A) each step taken in the process of |
|
recommending and assessing liquidated damages; and |
|
(B) the reason for any reduction of liquidated |
|
damages from the recommended amount; |
|
(2) assess liquidated damages in an amount that is |
|
sufficient to ensure compliance with the uniform managed care |
|
contract and is a reasonable forecast of the damages caused by the |
|
noncompliance; and |
|
(3) apply liquidated damages and other enforcement |
|
actions consistently among Medicaid managed care organizations for |
|
similar violations. |
|
(b-2) If the commission reduces the sanction or penalty in |
|
an enforcement action, the commission shall include in the record |
|
prepared under Subsection (a) the reason for the reduction. |
|
(c) The commission shall post and maintain the records |
|
required by this section on the commission's Internet website in |
|
English and Spanish. The commission's office of inspector general |
|
shall post and maintain the records relating to corrective action |
|
plans required by this section on the office's Internet website. |
|
The records must be posted in a format that is readily accessible to |
|
and understandable by a member of the public. The commission and |
|
the office shall update the list of records on the website at least |
|
quarterly. |
|
SECTION 23. Section 533.0075, Government Code, is amended |
|
to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0075. RECIPIENT ENROLLMENT. (a) The commission |
|
shall: |
|
(1) encourage recipients to choose appropriate |
|
managed care plans and primary health care providers by: |
|
(A) providing initial information to recipients |
|
and providers in a region about the need for recipients to choose |
|
plans and providers not later than the 90th day before the date on |
|
which a managed care organization plans to begin to provide health |
|
care services to recipients in that region through managed care; |
|
(B) providing follow-up information before |
|
assignment of plans and providers and after assignment, if |
|
necessary, to recipients who delay in choosing plans and providers; |
|
and |
|
(C) allowing plans and providers to provide |
|
information to recipients or engage in marketing activities under |
|
marketing guidelines established by the commission under Section |
|
533.008 after the commission approves the information or |
|
activities; |
|
(2) consider the following factors in assigning |
|
managed care plans and primary health care providers to recipients |
|
who fail to choose plans and providers: |
|
(A) the importance of maintaining existing |
|
provider-patient and physician-patient relationships, including |
|
relationships with specialists, public health clinics, and |
|
community health centers; |
|
(B) to the extent possible, the need to assign |
|
family members to the same providers and plans; [and] |
|
(C) geographic convenience of plans and |
|
providers for recipients; |
|
(D) a recipient's previous plan assignment; |
|
(E) the Medicaid managed care organization's |
|
performance on quality assurance and improvement; |
|
(F) enforcement actions, including liquidated |
|
damages, imposed against the managed care organization; |
|
(G) corrective action plans the commission has |
|
required the managed care organization to implement; and |
|
(H) other reasonable factors that support the |
|
objectives of the managed care program; |
|
(3) retain responsibility for enrollment and |
|
disenrollment of recipients in managed care plans, except that the |
|
commission may delegate the responsibility to an independent |
|
contractor who receives no form of payment from, and has no |
|
financial ties to, any managed care organization; |
|
(4) develop and implement an expedited process for |
|
determining eligibility for and enrolling pregnant women and |
|
newborn infants in managed care plans; and |
|
(5) ensure immediate access to prenatal services and |
|
newborn care for pregnant women and newborn infants enrolled in |
|
managed care plans, including ensuring that a pregnant woman may |
|
obtain an appointment with an obstetrical care provider for an |
|
initial maternity evaluation not later than the 30th day after the |
|
date the woman applies for Medicaid. |
|
(b) To help new recipients easily compare managed care plans |
|
with regard to quality and patient satisfaction measures, the |
|
commission shall incorporate information the commission determines |
|
is relevant in Medicaid managed care report cards, including: |
|
(1) feedback from recipient complaints; |
|
(2) a Medicaid managed care organization's rate of |
|
denials of Medicaid-covered services, appeals, and external |
|
medical reviews; |
|
(3) outcomes of internal appeals and external medical |
|
reviews; and |
|
(4) information for each organization related to |
|
external medical reviews under Section 533.00715. |
|
(c) After enrolling a recipient in the medically dependent |
|
children (MDCP) waiver program or the STAR+PLUS Medicaid managed |
|
care program, the commission shall require the recipient's or |
|
legally authorized representative's signature to verify the |
|
recipient received the recipient handbook. |
|
(d) The commission shall: |
|
(1) survey a select sample of recipients receiving |
|
benefits under the medically dependent children (MDCP) waiver |
|
program or the STAR+PLUS Medicaid managed care program to determine |
|
whether the recipients: |
|
(A) received the recipient handbook required by |
|
contract to be provided within the required period; and |
|
(B) understand the information in the recipient |
|
handbook; and |
|
(2) provide a sample recipient handbook to Medicaid |
|
managed care organizations. |
|
SECTION 24. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Section 533.0095 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.0095. CERTAIN PRIOR AUTHORIZATION EXTENSIONS. (a) |
|
The commission shall establish a list of health care services and |
|
prescription drugs for which a Medicaid managed care organization |
|
must grant extended prior authorization periods or amounts, as |
|
applicable, without requiring additional proof or documentation. |
|
The commission shall also establish a list of disabilities, chronic |
|
health conditions, and mental health conditions the treatments for |
|
which a Medicaid managed care organization must grant extended |
|
prior authorization periods without requiring additional proof or |
|
documentation. The commission shall establish the extended periods |
|
and amounts. |
|
(b) The commission shall establish the lists in |
|
consultation with clinical experts, physicians, hospitals, patient |
|
advocacy groups, and Medicaid managed care organizations. The |
|
commission shall also consult with stakeholders through the |
|
Medicaid managed care advisory committee. |
|
(c) The commission's medical director shall solicit and |
|
receive provider feedback regarding extended prior authorization |
|
periods, including feedback related to which health care services, |
|
prescription drugs, and disabilities and health and mental health |
|
conditions should be subject to extended prior authorization |
|
periods. |
|
(d) The commission shall update the lists every two years |
|
with input from the medical care advisory committee established |
|
under Section 32.022, Human Resources Code. |
|
SECTION 25. The heading to Section 533.015, Government |
|
Code, is amended to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.015. [COORDINATION OF] EXTERNAL OVERSIGHT |
|
ACTIVITIES. |
|
SECTION 26. Section 533.015, Government Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subsections (d) and (e) to read as follows: |
|
(d) In overseeing Medicaid managed care organizations, the |
|
commission's office of inspector general shall use a program |
|
integrity methodology appropriate for managed care. The office may |
|
explore different options to measure program integrity efforts, |
|
including: |
|
(1) quantifying and validating cost avoidance in a |
|
managed care context; and |
|
(2) adapting existing program integrity tools within |
|
the office to permit the office to address specific risks and |
|
incentives related to risk-based and value-based arrangements. |
|
(e) The commission's office of inspector general shall |
|
apply standards established in a contract between a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization and a provider to the extent the contract |
|
is allowed by a contract between the commission and a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization or state or federal law, rules, or |
|
policy. |
|
SECTION 27. Subchapter A, Chapter 533, Government Code, is |
|
amended by adding Sections 533.026, 533.027, 533.028, 533.031, and |
|
533.032 to read as follows: |
|
Sec. 533.026. ENHANCED DATA COLLECTION AND REPORTING OF |
|
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS; CONTRACT OVERSIGHT. (a) The commission |
|
shall collect accurate, consistent, and verifiable data from |
|
Medicaid managed care organizations, including line-item data for |
|
administrative costs. |
|
(b) The commission shall use data collected from a Medicaid |
|
managed care organization under this section to: |
|
(1) identify grievances, as defined by Section |
|
533.027; |
|
(2) monitor contract compliance; |
|
(3) identify other programmatic issues; and |
|
(4) identify whether the organization is: |
|
(A) unnecessarily denying, reducing, or |
|
otherwise failing to provide health care services to recipients; |
|
(B) delaying or denying provider claims due to |
|
technical or minimal errors; or |
|
(C) otherwise engaging in behavior that merits an |
|
enforcement action. |
|
(c) A Medicaid managed care organization shall report |
|
administrative costs in the organization's financial statistical |
|
report and shall report those costs to the commission at least |
|
annually. The commission shall report information provided under |
|
this subsection annually to the lieutenant governor, the speaker of |
|
the house, and each standing committee of the legislature with |
|
jurisdiction over financing, operating, and overseeing Medicaid. |
|
(d) The commission shall use data from grievances collected |
|
under Section 533.027 for contract oversight and to determine |
|
contract risk. |
|
(e) The commission shall: |
|
(1) provide financial subject matter expertise for |
|
Medicaid managed care contract review and compliance oversight |
|
among divisions within the commission; |
|
(2) conduct extensive validation of Medicaid managed |
|
care financial data; and |
|
(3) analyze the ultimate underlying cause of an issue |
|
to resolve that cause and prevent similar issues from arising in the |
|
future within Medicaid managed care. |
|
(f) The commission's office of inspector general shall |
|
assist the commission in implementing this section. |
|
Sec. 533.027. MANAGED CARE GRIEVANCES: PROCESSES AND |
|
TRACKING. (a) In this section: |
|
(1) "Comprehensive long-term services and supports |
|
provider" means a provider of long-term services and supports under |
|
Chapter 534 that ensures the coordinated, seamless delivery of the |
|
full range of services in a recipient's program plan. The term |
|
includes: |
|
(A) a provider under the ICF-IID program, as |
|
defined by Section 534.001; and |
|
(B) a provider under a Medicaid waiver program, |
|
as defined by Section 534.001. |
|
(2) "Grievance" means any expression of |
|
dissatisfaction or dispute, other than a denial, expressing |
|
dissatisfaction with any aspect of a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's operations, activities, or behavior. The term |
|
includes a complaint about access to a provider in a recipient's |
|
local area, a formal complaint, a request for an internal appeal, a |
|
request for an external medical review, a request for a fair |
|
hearing, and a complaint brought by an individual or entity, |
|
including a legislator or the commission, submitted to or received |
|
by: |
|
(A) a commission employee; |
|
(B) a Medicaid managed care organization; |
|
(C) a comprehensive long-term services and |
|
supports provider; |
|
(D) the commission's office of inspector |
|
general; |
|
(E) the commission's office of the ombudsman; |
|
(F) the office of ombudsman for Medicaid |
|
providers; or |
|
(G) the Department of Family and Protective |
|
Services. |
|
(b) The commission shall: |
|
(1) provide education and training to commission |
|
employees on the correct issue resolution processes for Medicaid |
|
managed care grievances; and |
|
(2) require those employees to promptly report |
|
grievances into the commission's grievance tracking system to |
|
enable employees to track and timely resolve grievances. |
|
(c) To ensure all grievances are managed consistently, the |
|
commission shall ensure the definition of a grievance is consistent |
|
among: |
|
(1) commission employees and divisions within the |
|
commission; |
|
(2) Medicaid managed care organizations; |
|
(3) comprehensive long-term services and supports |
|
providers; |
|
(4) the commission's office of inspector general; |
|
(5) the commission's office of the ombudsman; |
|
(6) the office of ombudsman for Medicaid providers; |
|
and |
|
(7) the Department of Family and Protective Services. |
|
(d) The commission shall enhance the Medicaid managed care |
|
grievance-tracking system's reporting capabilities and standardize |
|
data reporting among divisions within the commission. |
|
(e) In coordination with the executive commissioner's |
|
duties under Section 531.0171, the commission shall implement a |
|
no-wrong-door system for Medicaid managed care grievances reported |
|
to the commission. The commission shall ensure that commission |
|
employees, Medicaid managed care organizations, comprehensive |
|
long-term services and supports providers, the commission's office |
|
of inspector general, the commission's office of the ombudsman, the |
|
office of ombudsman for Medicaid providers, and the Department of |
|
Family and Protective Services use common practices and policies |
|
and provide consistent resolutions for Medicaid managed care |
|
grievances. |
|
(f) The commission shall: |
|
(1) implement a data analytics program to aggregate |
|
rates of inquiries, complaints, calls, and denials; and |
|
(2) include in each Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's quality rating: |
|
(A) the aggregate rating and data analysis; and |
|
(B) fair hearing requests and outcomes data. |
|
(g) The commission's office of inspector general shall |
|
review the commission's duties under Subsection (f). |
|
(h) The commission shall ensure that a comprehensive |
|
long-term services and supports provider may submit a grievance on |
|
behalf of a recipient. |
|
Sec. 533.028. CARE COORDINATION AND CARE COORDINATORS. (a) |
|
In this section, "care coordination" means assisting recipients to |
|
develop a plan of care, including a service plan, that meets the |
|
recipient's needs and coordinating the provision of Medicaid |
|
benefits in a manner that is consistent with the plan of care. The |
|
term is synonymous with "service coordination" and "service |
|
management." |
|
(b) The commission shall ensure a person who is engaged by a |
|
Medicaid managed care organization to provide care coordination |
|
benefits is consistently referred to as a "care coordinator" |
|
throughout divisions within the commission and across all Medicaid |
|
programs and services for recipients receiving benefits under a |
|
managed care delivery model. |
|
(c) The commission shall expeditiously develop materials |
|
explaining the role of care coordinators by Medicaid managed care |
|
product line. The commission shall establish clear expectations |
|
that the care coordinator communicate with a recipient's health |
|
care providers with the goal of ensuring coordinated, effective, |
|
and efficient care delivery. |
|
(d) The commission shall collect data on care coordination |
|
touchpoints with recipients. |
|
(e) The commission shall provide to each Medicaid managed |
|
care organization information regarding best practices for care |
|
coordination services for the organization to incorporate into |
|
providing care. |
|
(f) The executive commissioner by rule shall determine |
|
which providers are eligible to have a Medicaid managed care |
|
organization's care coordinator on-site or available through |
|
virtual means at the provider's practice. The commission shall |
|
ensure a care coordinator is reimbursed for care coordination |
|
services provided on-site or virtually and encourage managed care |
|
organizations to place care coordinators on-site or make the care |
|
coordinators available through virtual means. |
|
(g) The commission shall ensure that care coordinators |
|
coordinate with physicians and other health care providers in |
|
compiling documentation to satisfy Medicaid managed care |
|
organization requirements, including prior authorization |
|
requirements. |
|
(h) In this subsection, "potentially preventable admission" |
|
and "potentially preventable readmission" have the meanings |
|
assigned by Section 536.001. The commission shall change the |
|
methodology for calculating potentially preventable admissions and |
|
potentially preventable readmissions to exclude from those |
|
admission and readmission rates hospitalizations in which a |
|
Medicaid managed care organization did not adequately coordinate |
|
the patient's care. The methodology must apply to physical and |
|
behavioral health conditions. The change in methodology must be |
|
clinical in nature. |
|
(i) The executive commissioner shall include a provision |
|
establishing key performance metrics for care coordination in a |
|
contract between a managed care organization and the commission for |
|
the organization to provide health care services to recipients |
|
receiving home and community-based services under the: |
|
(1) STAR+PLUS Medicaid managed care program; |
|
(2) STAR Kids managed care program; or |
|
(3) STAR Health program. |
|
(j) The commission shall establish for Medicaid managed |
|
care organizations and ensure compliance with metrics for the |
|
following: |
|
(1) a dedicated toll-free care coordination telephone |
|
number; |
|
(2) the time frame for the return of telephone calls; |
|
(3) notice of the name and telephone number of a |
|
recipient's care coordinator for a recipient that has an assigned |
|
care coordinator; |
|
(4) notice of changes in the name or telephone number |
|
of a recipient's care coordinator for a recipient that has an |
|
assigned care coordinator; |
|
(5) initiation of assessments and reassessments; |
|
(6) establishment and regular updating of |
|
comprehensive, person-centered individual service plans; |
|
(7) number of face-to-face and telephonic contacts for |
|
each care coordination level; |
|
(8) care coordinator turnover rates; and |
|
(9) follow-up after hospitalization. |
|
Sec. 533.031. COORDINATION OF BENEFITS UNDER MEDICALLY |
|
DEPENDENT CHILDREN (MDCP) WAIVER PROGRAM. The commission shall |
|
prohibit a Medicaid managed care organization providing health care |
|
services under the medically dependent children (MDCP) waiver |
|
program from requiring additional authorization from an enrolled |
|
child's health care provider for a service if the child's |
|
third-party health benefit plan issuer authorizes the service, |
|
except to minimize the opportunity for fraud, waste, abuse, gross |
|
overuse, inappropriate or medically unnecessary care, or clinical |
|
abuse or misuse. |
|
Sec. 533.032. NOTICE OF CONTRACT AMENDMENT. (a) For |
|
purposes of this section, "contract" includes a manual or document |
|
that is incorporated by reference into a contract. |
|
(b) Subject to Subsection (d), the commission must provide |
|
notice of the commission's intent to amend a contract with a |
|
Medicaid managed care organization to and allow for the receipt of |
|
comments on the proposed amendment from: |
|
(1) the Medicaid managed care organization; |
|
(2) appropriate stakeholders, including organizations |
|
representing each provider type that provides health care services |
|
to recipients; and |
|
(3) other interested parties. |
|
(c) A contract amendment may not take effect before the 21st |
|
day after the date the commission provides notice under this |
|
section. |
|
(d) The commission: |
|
(1) shall provide the notice required by Subsection |
|
(b) by: |
|
(A) e-mail, if the commission has the e-mail |
|
address of the person to whom the commission is required to send the |
|
notice; and |
|
(B) posting the notice on the commission's |
|
Internet website; |
|
(2) may provide the notice required by Subsection (b) |
|
in any other format the commission determines appropriate; and |
|
(3) shall include in the notice required by Subsection |
|
(b): |
|
(A) the proposed contract amendment; |
|
(B) the method by which a person may comment on |
|
the proposed contract amendment; and |
|
(C) directions for providing comment. |
|
(e) If the commission seeks to amend a contract in |
|
accordance with a change in state or federal law, rule, policy, or |
|
guideline, the commission shall make all reasonable efforts to |
|
ensure that the effective date of the contract amendment, subject |
|
to Subsections (b) and (c), is on or before the effective date of |
|
the change in state or federal law, rule, policy, or guideline. |
|
SECTION 28. Section 536.007, Government Code, is amended by |
|
adding Subsection (b) to read as follows: |
|
(b) The commission's medical director is responsible for |
|
convening periodic meetings with Medicaid health care providers, |
|
including hospitals, to analyze and evaluate all Medicaid managed |
|
care and health care provider quality-based programs to ensure |
|
feasibility and alignment among programs. |
|
SECTION 29. As soon as practicable after the effective date |
|
of this Act, the Health and Human Services Commission shall |
|
implement the changes in law made by this Act. |
|
SECTION 30. Section 533.005, Government Code, as amended by |
|
this Act, applies only to a contract entered into or renewed on or |
|
after the effective date of this Act. A contract entered into or |
|
renewed before that date is governed by the law in effect on the |
|
date the contract was entered into or renewed, and that law is |
|
continued in effect for that purpose. |
|
SECTION 31. If before implementing any provision of this |
|
Act a state agency determines that a waiver or authorization from a |
|
federal agency is necessary for implementation of that provision, |
|
the agency affected by the provision shall request the waiver or |
|
authorization and may delay implementing that provision until the |
|
waiver or authorization is granted. |
|
SECTION 32. If any provision of this Act or its application |
|
to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the invalidity does |
|
not affect other provisions or applications of this Act that can be |
|
given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to |
|
this end the provisions of this Act are declared to be severable. |
|
SECTION 33. This Act takes effect September 1, 2019. |