|
|
|
A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
|
|
AN ACT
|
|
relating to competition and transparency in digital advertising. |
|
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: |
|
SECTION 1. Title 2, Business & Commerce Code, is amended by |
|
adding Chapter 18 to read as follows: |
|
CHAPTER 18. COMPETITION AND TRANSPARENCY IN DIGITAL ADVERTISING |
|
SUBCHAPTER A. GENERAL PROVISIONS |
|
Sec. 18.001. DEFINITIONS. In this chapter: |
|
(1) "Brokerage customer" means a person who purchases |
|
or sells digital advertisements, or directly related goods or |
|
services, through a buy-side brokerage or a sell-side brokerage. |
|
(2) "Buy-side brokerage" means a person in the |
|
business of effecting transactions on digital advertising |
|
exchanges, including by offering software or services that assist |
|
in serving or displaying digital advertisements, for other buyers. |
|
(3) "Digital advertisement" means an advertisement |
|
that is served electronically over a computer network, including |
|
the Internet. |
|
(4) "Digital advertising exchange" means a person who |
|
constitutes, maintains, or provides a marketplace for or |
|
facilitates bringing together buyers and one or more sellers of |
|
digital advertisements, or for otherwise performing with respect to |
|
digital advertising the functions commonly performed by a digital |
|
advertising marketplace. |
|
(5) "Digital advertising revenue" means the greater |
|
of: |
|
(A) global revenue derived from or directly |
|
related to the operation of a digital advertising exchange, a |
|
buy-side brokerage, or a sell-side brokerage; or |
|
(B) the largest of: |
|
(i) the sum of the clearing prices of all |
|
digital advertisements bought or sold from or through a digital |
|
advertising exchange; |
|
(ii) the total value of the gross |
|
advertising spending managed by a buy-side brokerage; or |
|
(iii) the total value of the gross |
|
advertising sales managed by a sell-side brokerage. |
|
(6) "Divestiture deadline" means the 30th day after |
|
the date on which the attorney general approves or denies a required |
|
divestiture. |
|
(7) "Own" means ownership whether directly or |
|
indirectly or wholly or partly. The term includes operation or |
|
control, whether directly or indirectly or wholly or partly. |
|
(8) "Person" includes: |
|
(A) a subsidiary of an entity; and |
|
(B) a corporate parent of an entity. |
|
(9) "Required divestiture" means a divestiture, sale, |
|
or other transaction undertaken to comply with this chapter. The |
|
term does not include an action required by a state or federal |
|
court. |
|
(10) "Sell-side brokerage" means a person in the |
|
business of effecting transactions on digital advertising |
|
exchanges, including by offering software or services that assist |
|
in serving or displaying digital advertisements, for other sellers. |
|
(11) "Third party," for a person subject to this |
|
chapter, means an entity that: |
|
(A) does not own or is not owned by that person; |
|
and |
|
(B) is not affiliated with that person through |
|
direct or indirect ownership or control. |
|
Sec. 18.002. CONSTRUCTION OF CHAPTER. This chapter may not |
|
be construed to: |
|
(1) prohibit a person from: |
|
(A) selling the person's own inventory of |
|
advertising space if: |
|
(i) the inventory was not acquired solely |
|
for resale purposes, except to monetize the person's own content or |
|
intellectual property; and |
|
(ii) the person does not also assist a third |
|
party in the sale or purchase of advertising space, other than |
|
purchasing advertising space from that person; or |
|
(B) buying inventory to market the products or |
|
services of the person; |
|
(2) prohibit a person from, consistent with antitrust |
|
law, entering into a joint venture or other collaboration to |
|
prevent harm from spam, fraud, or other forms of abuse in digital |
|
advertising; or |
|
(3) require the disclosure of information if the |
|
disclosure would violate a law of this state, the United States, or |
|
a foreign country. |
|
SUBCHAPTER B. PROHIBITIONS AND REQUIREMENTS |
|
Sec. 18.051. PROHIBITED PRACTICES. A person with more than |
|
$20 billion in digital advertising revenue for the preceding |
|
calendar year may not: |
|
(1) own a digital advertising exchange if that person |
|
owns either a buy-side brokerage or a sell-side brokerage or is a |
|
seller of digital advertising space; |
|
(2) own a sell-side brokerage if that person owns a |
|
buy-side brokerage; or |
|
(3) own a buy-side brokerage or a sell-side brokerage |
|
if that person is also a buyer or seller of digital advertising |
|
space. |
|
Sec. 18.052. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS. A person that is a |
|
buy-side brokerage or sell-side brokerage with more than $5 billion |
|
in digital advertising revenue for the preceding calendar year |
|
shall: |
|
(1) in the course of providing services as a |
|
brokerage, use reasonable diligence, care, and skill to act in the |
|
best interest of the brokerage customer and may not put the |
|
brokerage's own interest ahead of the interest of the brokerage |
|
customer; and |
|
(2) seek the most favorable terms reasonably available |
|
under the circumstances for each order transaction of the brokerage |
|
customer. |
|
Sec. 18.053. DIGITAL ADVERTISING REVENUE ADJUSTMENT. (a) |
|
In this section, "consumer price index" means the average over a |
|
calendar year of the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers |
|
(CPI-U), U.S. City Average, published monthly by the United States |
|
Bureau of Labor Statistics, or its successor in function. |
|
(b) Beginning in 2027, on January 1 of each year, the |
|
attorney general may adjust the digital advertising revenue amount |
|
prescribed by Sections 18.051 and 18.052 by an amount equal to the |
|
percentage increase, if any, in the consumer price index in digital |
|
advertising revenue for the preceding calendar year. |
|
(c) The attorney general shall make the determination |
|
required by this section and may adopt rules related to making that |
|
determination. |
|
Sec. 18.054. TRANSPARENCY REQUIREMENTS. (a) On written |
|
request from a brokerage customer, a buy-side brokerage or |
|
sell-side brokerage shall provide to the customer, within a |
|
reasonable time, information sufficient to permit the customer to |
|
verify the brokerage's compliance with Section 18.052. |
|
(b) The information disclosed under Subsection (a) must |
|
include, if requested and to the extent the information is |
|
collected by the brokerage in the ordinary course of business: |
|
(1) if a sell-side brokerage is providing information |
|
to a sell-side brokerage customer: |
|
(A) a unique and persistent identifier that |
|
identifies each unique digital advertising space for sale; |
|
(B) for each identifier described by Paragraph |
|
(A), all bids received and, for each bid received: |
|
(i) the bid submitted to the digital |
|
advertising exchange on behalf of the buy-side brokerage customer; |
|
(ii) the winning price; |
|
(iii) the uniform resource locator or other |
|
property identifier at the lowest level of granularity; |
|
(iv) the identity of the digital |
|
advertising exchange or other digital advertising venue returning |
|
the bid; |
|
(v) the date and time that the bid response |
|
was received in microseconds or a lower level of granularity; |
|
(vi) the web domain associated with the |
|
advertising creative; |
|
(vii) the advertising creative size and |
|
format; and |
|
(viii) whether the bid won the seller's |
|
impression; |
|
(C) the nature of any data collected or derived |
|
from the brokerage customer or any user or customer of the brokerage |
|
customer and the ways in which that data is used by the sell-side |
|
brokerage; |
|
(D) the order or bid routing practices or |
|
processes, including any material exceptions to the standard |
|
practice of the brokerage; and |
|
(E) the source and nature of any compensation |
|
paid or received in connection with transactions; and |
|
(2) if a buy-side brokerage is providing information |
|
to a buy-side brokerage customer: |
|
(A) all bids won by the buy-side brokerage |
|
customer, and for each bid won: |
|
(i) the maximum allowed bid, if any, of the |
|
advertiser; |
|
(ii) the uniform resource locator or other |
|
property identifier at the lowest level of granularity; |
|
(iii) the date; |
|
(iv) the digital advertising exchange; |
|
(v) the web domain associated with the |
|
advertising creative; |
|
(vi) the advertising creative size and |
|
format; |
|
(vii) the winning price; |
|
(viii) the bid submitted to the digital |
|
advertising exchange on behalf of the buy-side brokerage customer; |
|
and |
|
(ix) if possible, whether the advertisement |
|
served and whether the advertisement rendered; |
|
(B) the order or bid routing practices or |
|
processes; and |
|
(C) the source and nature of any compensation |
|
paid or received in connection with transactions. |
|
Sec. 18.055. RETENTION OF RECORDS. (a) A brokerage shall |
|
retain the records specified in Section 18.054(b), as applicable, |
|
if collected by the brokerage in the ordinary course of business, |
|
until the later of: |
|
(1) the 90th day after the date the data is collected; |
|
or |
|
(2) the date the brokerage provides the data to a |
|
customer in response to a request submitted by that customer under |
|
Section 18.054(a), if the request was submitted before the 90th day |
|
after the date the data was collected. |
|
(b) A brokerage shall retain billing information for a |
|
brokerage customer until the first anniversary of the collection of |
|
that information. |
|
Sec. 18.056. USER PRIVACY. (a) When providing information |
|
to a brokerage customer in response to a request authorized by |
|
Section 18.054(a), the brokerage shall, to the greatest extent |
|
possible consistent with the purpose of this chapter, anonymize, |
|
hash, or otherwise render the information incapable of being tied |
|
to an individual Internet user. |
|
(b) A brokerage customer may not use data or information |
|
received in response to a request made under Section 18.054(a) for |
|
any purpose other than: |
|
(1) verifying the brokerage's compliance with Section |
|
18.052; or |
|
(2) bringing an action under Section 18.105. |
|
Sec. 18.057. POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR INTERNAL |
|
COMPLIANCE. A buy-side brokerage and sell-side brokerage shall |
|
establish, maintain, and enforce a written policy and procedures |
|
reasonably designed to ensure compliance with the requirements of |
|
this subchapter. |
|
Sec. 18.058. POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR EXTERNAL |
|
COMPLIANCE. A buy-side brokerage, sell-side brokerage, digital |
|
advertising exchange, or other person when acting as a buyer or |
|
seller of digital advertising, as applicable, that is not subject |
|
to the prohibitions under Section 18.051 shall establish, maintain, |
|
and enforce a written policy and procedures reasonably designed to |
|
ensure that those persons operate separately from and independently |
|
of one another and transact business with one another at arm's |
|
length. |
|
Sec. 18.059. FAIR ACCESS DUTY. A digital advertising |
|
exchange shall provide to each buyer and seller in the exchange fair |
|
access, including access with respect to operations of the |
|
exchange, colocation, any technology systems or data, information |
|
related to transactions, service, or products offered, exchange |
|
processes, and functionality. |
|
Sec. 18.060. TIME SYNCHRONIZATION. A digital advertising |
|
exchange, buy-side brokerage, or sell-side brokerage shall |
|
synchronize and maintain the exchange's or brokerage's business |
|
clocks at a minimum to within a two-millisecond tolerance of the |
|
time maintained by the atomic clock of the National Institute of |
|
Standards and Technology. |
|
Sec. 18.061. DATA OWNERSHIP. All records pertaining to an |
|
order solicited or submitted by a brokerage customer, and the |
|
subsequent result of the order, remain the property of the |
|
brokerage customer, including any bid solicited from or submitted |
|
to a digital advertising exchange, unless the information is |
|
publicly available. |
|
Sec. 18.062. ROUTING PRACTICES DISCLOSURE. A buy-side |
|
brokerage or sell-side brokerage shall: |
|
(1) make publicly available for each calendar quarter |
|
a report on the order routing practices of the buy-side brokerage or |
|
sell-side brokerage, as applicable, for digital advertisements |
|
during that quarter broken down by calendar month; and |
|
(2) retain the report described by Subdivision (1) |
|
posted on an Internet website that is free and readily accessible to |
|
the public until the third anniversary of the date the report is |
|
posted. |
|
Sec. 18.063. FORMAT. A report made available under Section |
|
18.062 must: |
|
(1) be rendered in a format that is readily |
|
informative to the average brokerage customer; and |
|
(2) include for the 10 venues to which the largest |
|
number of total bid requests or bid responses were routed for |
|
execution and for any venue to which five percent or more of bid |
|
requests or bid responses were routed for execution: |
|
(A) the total number of bids routed; |
|
(B) the total number of bids executed; |
|
(C) the fill rate of bids; |
|
(D) the average net execution fee or rebate per |
|
1,000 impressions; |
|
(E) the average time in milliseconds between when |
|
a bid request is sent and when a bid response is received; and |
|
(F) the value and form of any compensation given |
|
in exchange for routing or execution. |
|
Sec. 18.064. CERTIFICATION. A digital advertising |
|
exchange, buy-side brokerage, or sell-side brokerage shall |
|
annually certify to the attorney general that the digital |
|
advertising exchange has complied with the requirements of this |
|
subchapter. |
|
SUBCHAPTER C. ENFORCEMENT |
|
Sec. 18.101. ENFORCEMENT BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL. (a) The |
|
attorney general may bring an action on behalf of persons in this |
|
state injured in their business or property by a violation of this |
|
chapter. |
|
(b) In an action brought under this section, the attorney |
|
general is entitled to: |
|
(1) obtain injunctive relief; and |
|
(2) recover actual damages sustained by the injured |
|
persons. |
|
Sec. 18.102. DAMAGES. (a) In an action brought under |
|
Section 18.101, a court may award on a prompt motion by the attorney |
|
general simple interest on actual damages awarded under that |
|
section. |
|
(b) A court may not award any damages under this subchapter |
|
that are duplicative of damages awarded before the date of the award |
|
in a separate civil action pertaining to the same conduct and |
|
injured party. |
|
(c) A court awarding damages to a person in a civil action |
|
after the date of an award of damages under this subchapter that |
|
would be duplicative of damages awarded to the attorney general on |
|
behalf of the person shall direct that the damages must first be |
|
paid by the office of the attorney general from amounts in the |
|
antitrust consumer damages fund under Section 18.103 and, to the |
|
extent the damages are not fully paid by the office of the attorney |
|
general from amounts in that fund, shall then be paid by the |
|
defendant. |
|
Sec. 18.103. ANTITRUST CONSUMER DAMAGES FUND. (a) The |
|
antitrust consumer damages fund is a special fund in the state |
|
treasury outside the general revenue fund to be administered and |
|
used by the attorney general for the purposes authorized by this |
|
chapter. |
|
(b) Notwithstanding any other law, any amounts received by |
|
the attorney general under an award under this subchapter shall be |
|
deposited in the fund and shall be available to the attorney |
|
general, without further appropriation, for distribution to |
|
persons harmed by a violation of this chapter. |
|
(c) Effective on the 10th anniversary of the date on which |
|
an award is received under Section 18.102, the unobligated balances |
|
in the fund of amounts that were received under the award are |
|
rescinded and shall be deposited in the general revenue fund of the |
|
state treasury. |
|
Sec. 18.104. DIVESTITURE ENFORCEMENT. The attorney general |
|
may bring an action on behalf of this state and may obtain |
|
injunctive relief on showing by a preponderance of the evidence |
|
that the defendant has: |
|
(1) violated Section 18.106; or |
|
(2) undertaken a required divestiture that |
|
unnecessarily harms or threatens competition in any market in this |
|
state. |
|
Sec. 18.105. PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION. (a) A brokerage |
|
customer in this state harmed by a knowing violation of Subchapter B |
|
may bring an action to obtain injunctive relief, if appropriate, |
|
and to recover damages in the amount of the greater of: |
|
(1) $1 million for each month in which a violation of |
|
Subchapter B occurred and reasonable attorney's fees; or |
|
(2) actual damages and reasonable attorney's fees. |
|
(b) No person subject to this chapter may require a class |
|
action waiver for a claim under this chapter, including for |
|
arbitration of a claim under this chapter. |
|
(c) A person harmed by a violation of Section 18.051 may |
|
bring a civil action for a violation of that section any time after |
|
the later of: |
|
(1) the expiration of any applicable divestiture |
|
deadline; or |
|
(2) the expiration of the deadline under Section |
|
18.106 if no filing has been made. |
|
Sec. 18.106. DIVESTITURE. (a) An agreement or other |
|
document setting out the terms of a required divestiture must be |
|
filed with the attorney general not later than the later of: |
|
(1) the effective date of the agreement or other |
|
document; or |
|
(2) the earlier of: |
|
(A) the 30th day after the date on which an |
|
agreement making a required divestiture under this chapter is |
|
executed; or |
|
(B) the 180th day after meeting a criterion |
|
specified by Section 18.051. |
|
(b) The attorney general shall approve a required |
|
divestiture on a showing by the person making the divestiture that |
|
the terms of the divestiture, including the qualifications of any |
|
counterparties to the divestiture, will not unnecessarily harm or |
|
threaten competition in any market in this state. |
|
(c) The attorney general shall grant or deny approval of a |
|
required divestiture, unless agreed to by the parties, not later |
|
than the later of: |
|
(1) the 60th day after receipt of all information |
|
obtained under Subsection (f); or |
|
(2) the 60th day after receipt of the filing made under |
|
Subsection (a). |
|
(d) A divestiture must be completed not later than the |
|
divestiture deadline. |
|
(e) The attorney general shall issue and maintain guidance |
|
on the divestiture process under this section and the certification |
|
requirement under Section 18.064. |
|
(f) The attorney general may request or issue a civil |
|
investigative demand under Section 15.10 for documents from any |
|
person involved in a required divestiture to determine the |
|
competitive effects of the divestiture. |
|
SECTION 2. The attorney general shall issue guidance as |
|
required by Section 18.106(e), Business & Commerce Code, as added |
|
by this Act, not later than the 120th day after the effective date |
|
of this Act. |
|
SECTION 3. This Act takes effect September 1, 2025. |